CBS's Song-Lyrics Patent: What It Covers and Why EFF Mocked It

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-03-13.

EFF Names CBS’s Song-Lyrics Patent Its “Stupid Patent of the Month”

Yes, there really is a US patent about discussing song lyrics online. Patent No. 9,401,941, titled "Song lyric processing with user interaction," was granted to CBS Interactive on 26 July 2016. It describes a system that shows lyrics on a screen, lets a reader select a line, opens a menu of options and records what the reader does next, such as adding an interpretation or sharing the line.

In early 2017 the Electronic Frontier Foundation (EFF), a digital-rights group, picked it as its "Stupid Patent of the Month." The patent did not make it illegal for you and a friend to argue about what a chorus means. What critics objected to was a company owning exclusive rights over a website feature that already existed and that, in their view, added nothing inventive to ordinary web programming.

What the lyrics patent actually describes

A patent has two layers that are easy to mix up. The title and summary give a broad picture; the numbered claims at the end define what the owner can actually enforce. Headlines about "patenting lyric discussions" were built on the broad picture.

The record on Google Patents lists three inventors, Alan Juristovski, Milun Tesovic and Sushant Sund, with CBS Interactive as the original assignee. The family goes back to a provisional application filed on 25 February 2011. A full application followed in February 2012, and the patent that was granted in 2016 came from a continuation filed on 20 March 2015.

The specification walks through familiar steps:

  • sending lyrics to a phone or browser so they can be displayed;
  • detecting when a reader highlights part of a line;
  • showing a menu, for example "add meaning," "report a misheard lyric" or "share";
  • storing each choice in a database and acting on it;
  • analysing the stored interpretations so that common or recent ones can be shown to other readers.

A writer on Medium who went through the document in 2016 made the obvious point: almost every lyrics site in the world already sent lyrics to readers' screens, and sites such as Rap Genius and Musixmatch already let people annotate lines.

Read the patent claims separately from criticism of them

Rap Genius was doing this years earlier

Genius began life in 2009 as Rap Exegesis, became Rap Genius at the end of that year and relaunched as Genius in July 2014. It was founded by three Yale graduates, Tom Lehman, Ilan Zechory and Mahbod Moghadam. Its core idea was exactly the one at issue: highlight a fragment of a lyric, then read or write an explanation of it in a pop-up.

That matters because a patent must be new and non-obvious compared with what came before its priority date, here February 2011. The patent examiner noticed. Google Patents lists a page titled "What is Rap Genius?", dated 22 December 2010, among the references considered during examination.

When an examiner raises prior art like this, applicants usually do not give up. They amend the claims, adding limitations until the claimed method looks different enough from the earlier work.

How the claims were narrowed, and why critics were not satisfied

According to Ars Technica's reporting on the EFF award, CBS's lawyers responded by adding a step in which the system suggests interpretations to a reader based on interpretations that earlier users had already entered. The specification describes something similar: the software pulls up "common interpretations" for a selected line and displays them next to the reader's own entry.

The narrower version is much less likely to catch an ordinary lyrics site. Daniel Nazer, the EFF staff attorney who wrote the post, argued that it still should not have been granted, because recommending content based on what other users have done was itself a routine feature of websites well before 2011.

Critics also pointed to a practical weakness in the system. An examiner has limited time to search for an earlier document showing every element of a claim in exactly the same combination. If an applicant keeps adding small details, the search can become a hunt for a perfect match that may not exist in written form, even if each piece was common knowledge. At that point examiners often allow the application. Nobody outside the patent office can say for certain that this is what happened here, but it is a recurring complaint about software patents.

Read the patent claims separately from criticism of them

The flow chart above is one of the patent's figures. Drawings like this make a fairly simple sequence of web actions look like a complex machine, which is part of why software patents are hard for non-specialists to judge.

The Alice test and "do it on a computer" patents

Nazer's second argument relied on Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International, a unanimous US Supreme Court decision of 19 June 2014 written by Justice Clarence Thomas. Alice set a two-step test for patent eligibility:

  1. Is the claim directed to an abstract idea, a law of nature or a natural phenomenon?
  2. If so, does it add an "inventive concept," something more than the abstract idea itself?

The Court made clear that taking an abstract idea and saying "do it on a generic computer" is not enough to pass the second step. Discussing and annotating song lyrics is an old human activity; storing those notes in a database and showing them to other readers is, in EFF's view, standard web development. Because the continuation application was filed in March 2015, after Alice, the EFF argued that the examiner should have rejected it on eligibility grounds alone.

It is worth keeping the layers separate. EFF is an advocacy organisation, and the "Stupid Patent of the Month" series is commentary. No court has ruled on whether this particular patent is valid, and we found no record of CBS suing anyone over it.

Where MetroLyrics and the patent ended up

The patent was tied to MetroLyrics, a lyrics site launched in 2002 and acquired by CBS Interactive in October 2011. The patent number appeared at the bottom of MetroLyrics song pages, which is how many readers first noticed it.

MetroLyrics went offline abruptly in late June 2021. Google Patents records that rights passed from CBS Interactive to RV Carousel Holdings in December 2020, a company that renamed itself CNET Media in 2021. Google lists the patent as active with an anticipated expiry in 2032, though it notes that its legal-status data is an assumption rather than a legal conclusion.

What this case says about software patents

A few practical lessons come out of the story:

  • Read the claims, not the title. A broad title does not mean a broad monopoly. The claims as granted were narrower than the headlines suggested.
  • Granted does not mean valid. A patent office grant can still be challenged in court or through review at the Patent Trial and Appeal Board, where prior art like Rap Genius would be central.
  • Talking about songs is safe. A patent covers making, using or selling a claimed system. It cannot stop people from discussing lyrics in comments, chats or over coffee.
  • Weak patents still have costs. Even unenforced, a vague patent can make a small developer hesitate before building a feature, which is the main reason groups like EFF publicise examples.

The common myth around this story is that CBS "owned" lyric interpretation. It never did. The real question was narrower and more technical: whether a company should hold a 20-year exclusive right to a combination of everyday web features that annotation sites were already using. On that question, EFF's answer was a firm no.

Sources: Google Patents: US9401941B2, Song lyric processing with user interaction; Medium: MetroLyrics patent 9401941; Wikipedia: Alice Corp. v. CLS Bank International; Wikipedia: Genius (company); Wikipedia: MetroLyrics.

COMMENTS