LEGO's Sugarcane Plant Pieces: What 'Plants From Plants' Means

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
LEGO's 2018 Sugarcane-Based Botanical Elements

LEGO's plant-shaped pieces, the trees, bushes, leaves and palm fronds that decorate countless sets, were the first LEGO elements made from plant-based plastic. The company announced on 2 March 2018 that these botanical elements would be produced from polyethylene made with sugarcane rather than fossil fuels, and said they would be in boxes that year. LEGO summed up the idea with a neat slogan: plants from plants.

The pieces look, feel and fit exactly like the old ones. What changed is where the raw material comes from. That distinction explains both why the move was welcomed and why some critics called it a small first step rather than a green revolution.

What LEGO actually changed

Most classic LEGO bricks are moulded from ABS, a hard, rigid plastic. The botanical elements are different: they are made from polyethylene (PE), a softer, more flexible plastic suited to bendable leaves and branches. It is this group of PE pieces that switched to a plant-based source.

The new material starts as sugarcane. The cane is processed into ethanol, and the ethanol is turned into ethylene, the building block of polyethylene. Chemically, the result is the same polymer as polyethylene made from oil or gas. Tim Brooks, then LEGO's vice president for environmental responsibility, said plant-based polyethylene "has the same properties as conventional polyethylene", and that children and parents would not notice any difference in quality or appearance.

LEGO's 2018 Sugarcane-Based Botanical Elements

A forest of LEGO pine trees, grass tufts, leaves and bushes, the kinds of botanical elements that moved to sugarcane-based polyethylene in 2018. Photo: The LEGO Group

LEGO's 2018 Sugarcane-Based Botanical Elements

A pile of the plant-based pieces, from tall cones and palm leaves to small branching plant stems. Their flexibility is why they are made from polyethylene rather than the hard ABS used for standard bricks. Photo: The LEGO Group

LEGO's 2018 Sugarcane-Based Botanical Elements

Individual botanical elements laid out on a white surface: round bushes, fern-like fronds, three-leaf clovers and seaweed shapes. Builders cannot tell them apart from the older fossil-based versions, which was exactly LEGO's aim. Photo: The LEGO Group

The botanical parts are found in many ordinary sets, and LEGO also sold collections of plant pieces; one such set is available on Amazon.

How big a step was it?

In scale terms, a small one. According to LEGO, polyethylene elements make up only about 1 to 2 percent of the plastic elements it produces. CBC Kids News put that in context: LEGO makes around 19 billion pieces a year, and the vast majority are still made from conventional plastics.

LEGO presented the plant pieces as the first visible result of a bigger commitment. The company had partnered with WWF since 2013 on sourcing questions, joined the Bioplastic Feedstock Alliance in 2016, and set a goal of using sustainable materials in its core products and packaging by 2030. The sugarcane was certified under the Bonsucro chain-of-custody standard for responsibly produced sugarcane, intended to address concerns about land use and labour in growing it.

Plant-based is not the same as biodegradable

This is the most common misunderstanding about the launch. Because the bio-PE is chemically identical to ordinary polyethylene, it behaves the same way at the end of its life. CBC Kids News stated it plainly: polyethylene is not biodegradable. A sugarcane LEGO tree left in a field will last just as long as an oil-based one.

The environmental benefit lies at the start of the life cycle instead. Sugarcane absorbs carbon dioxide as it grows, and a LEGO spokesperson argued the material is sustainable because the cane is replaced as fast as it is used, unlike fossil oil. Whether the overall footprint is lower depends on farming practices, processing and transport, which is why certification and independent life-cycle studies matter more than the label "plant-based" alone.

For LEGO bricks, durability is arguably a feature. A toy that is handed down through generations, sold second-hand or donated is not single-use plastic, and keeping pieces in use is one of the most effective things owners can do.

The harder challenge: the bricks themselves

Switching soft botanical parts was the easy case, because a drop-in plant-based version of polyethylene already existed. Finding a replacement for ABS is much harder: a standard brick must grip its neighbours with precise "clutch power" for decades, keep its colour and stay safe for children.

LEGO has continued to test alternatives since the 2018 launch, including a prototype brick made from recycled drink bottles shown in 2021. In 2023 the company reportedly shelved that recycled-PET approach after finding it would not reduce carbon emissions overall. It is a reminder that "sustainable materials" is a research problem, and that the botanical pieces were a beginning rather than an answer.

What it means for families who build

  • No difference in play. Plant-based pieces mix with older ones and fit the same way.
  • Don't throw them away expecting them to rot. Treat them like any other plastic; better still, keep, pass on or donate them.
  • Look at material claims carefully. "Plant-based", "recycled" and "biodegradable" mean different things, on toys and on any other product.

LEGO's own video about the plant-based elements:

More on plant-based alternatives: Leaf Packaging in Asian Supermarkets: A Closer Look.

Sources: Photos and video: The LEGO Group; LEGO Group press release: First sustainable LEGO bricks will be launched in 2018; Dezeen, 2 March 2018; Brickset, 2 March 2018; CBC Kids News: Lego's going green with some of its blocks, but how green?.

COMMENTS