I Am Odd, I Am New: Benjamin Giroux's Autism Poem and Its Story

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-03-04.

"I Am Odd, I Am New" is a short poem written in 2016 by Benjamin Giroux, then a 10-year-old fifth-grader in Plattsburgh, New York, who is autistic. A classroom exercise asked pupils to write an "I am" poem about themselves. Benjamin used it to describe how it feels to see the world differently from the people around him, to want to fit in and to fear being laughed at.

His father shared the poem online, the National Autism Association passed it on, and within days it had travelled around the world under the hashtag #oddtoo. It later became songs, a music video and an illustrated picture book. Here is the story behind it, what the poem actually says, and how parents and teachers can use it well.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A homework assignment in Plattsburgh

In spring 2016 Benjamin was a pupil at Cumberland Head Elementary School in Plattsburgh, a small city in upstate New York close to the Canadian border. His class was given a familiar writing template, often called an "I am" poem. Each line opens with a short prompt such as I am, I wonder, I hear, I see, I feel, I worry, I dream or I hope, and the child fills in the rest. The structure is popular in schools because it gives young writers a frame while leaving the content entirely to them.

News reports at the time said Benjamin had been diagnosed with Asperger syndrome. Since 2013, the main US diagnostic manual has folded Asperger's into the single diagnosis of autism spectrum disorder, so today the same profile would usually simply be described as autism. Reports also described how he settled at the kitchen table and kept working until he was satisfied with the result.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

Benjamin Giroux, the young poet, in a portrait shared alongside the #oddtoo hashtag. The tag, short for "odd too", became the way readers showed they identified with the poem.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

The original handwritten poem on lined school paper. It shows the full text in Benjamin's own handwriting, including the repeated "I am odd, I am new" refrain that gives the poem its title.

What the poem says

The poem is only about 20 lines long, but it moves through a clear emotional arc. It opens by naming difference directly, then describes sensations and situations that set the writer apart: noticing things others do not, feeling isolated, worrying about other people's opinions and shrinking when people laugh.

Some of the most quoted images are spatial. Benjamin compares himself to a castaway, and in one line writes, "I feel like a boy in outer space". It is a vivid way for a child to describe being surrounded by people yet far from them.

The refrain is where the poem quietly changes. At first the speaker wonders whether the reader is odd too; later he pretends that they are; and near the end he arrives at something closer to recognition: "I understand now that so are you". The poem finishes with a wish to fit in and a hope that one day he will, before returning to the refrain one last time.

That shift is a large part of why adults responded so strongly. The poem does not ask for pity. It asks readers to admit that everyone feels out of place sometimes, while being honest about how much harder that can be for an autistic child.

How a family post went global

Benjamin's father, Sonny Giroux, said he was moved to tears when he read the poem, and he sent it to the National Autism Association. The charity posted it on its Facebook page in April 2016. Within days the post had about 22,000 likes and more than 14,000 shares, according to reports at the time; later figures cited by other outlets were higher.

His father told reporters the family was "so proud, and yet so heartbroken" that this was how their son felt. The attention also had a personal cost: Benjamin was due to read the poem to his class the next day but stayed home after an anxiety attack, a reminder that a viral moment can be overwhelming for the child at its centre.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

Benjamin's name and the #oddtoo hashtag painted on the ice of a professional hockey rink. The poem's popularity brought him invitations and public appearances well beyond Plattsburgh.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A tweet from Benjamin's account on 7 April 2017, marking a year since he wrote the poem. He explains that his dad posted it online three days later to show him it was good.

Songs, a picture book and a hometown honour

Musicians quickly picked up the text. Several song versions appeared, and a musician credited as Martin Parcelman recorded a setting of the poem that Benjamin shared on social media. In April 2022 a music video based on the poem was released.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A still from a YouTube video illustrating the line about crying when people laugh. Two green apples, one hiding behind a paper sign, turn the image of shrinking into something younger viewers can picture.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

Benjamin announcing on Twitter, in November 2018, the premiere of a new song that uses his poem as its lyrics. It was one of several musical versions created by different artists.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A Facebook post from Benjamin's page sharing the song by Martin Parcelman, which came in rock, alternative and choir versions. The video description credits the words to Benjamin, written when he was 10.

The poem then became a picture book. I Am Odd, I Am New: An Autism Awareness Poem for Children, illustrated by Canadian illustrator Roz MacLean and published by Schiffer Publishing, is a 32-page hardback aimed at children aged roughly 5 to 8, with a foreword from the National Autism Association. It received a starred review from Kirkus Reviews and was named a Kirkus Best Book of the Year. A reviewer for Canada's CM Reviews praised its bright, self-assured illustrations, which translate each line into a picture, such as a boy floating among the stars.

According to his publisher, Benjamin has since been named poet laureate of Plattsburgh, has become an award-winning songwriter and has served as the face of the National Autism Association's anti-bullying campaign. The poem has been translated into several languages.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

Benjamin at home in a dinosaur T-shirt and headphones. Pictures like this, shared by his family, helped readers see the ordinary boy behind the widely shared words.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A cheerful Benjamin in a red rain poncho on a Niagara Falls boat cruise. The family's posts mixed news about the poem with everyday moments like this one.

What readers wrote back

For Benjamin, the most meaningful part of the response has been messages from people who saw themselves in his lines. The screenshots below, from Twitter and Facebook, give a sense of that reaction. Many came from parents and grandparents of autistic children.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A short thank-you tweet sent to Benjamin in November 2018, more than two years after the poem first spread. Readers kept discovering it long after the original news cycle.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A June 2016 reply telling Benjamin that people are not odd but unique. It echoes the poem's own turn towards the idea that difference is shared.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

Another reader reassures Benjamin that he is significant and that his words will stay with people. Messages like this arrived in the weeks after the poem went viral.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A parent of a son on the autism spectrum borrows the poem's imagery, telling Benjamin to touch the stars. It is one of many comments from families who felt the poem described their own child.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A reader hoping the poem would become a book. That wish came true when Schiffer Publishing released the illustrated edition.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A fellow writer says the poem made her feel less alone. Adults, not only children, found the words relevant to their own lives.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A supportive comment telling Benjamin to follow his own path whatever others say. Many replies took the form of direct encouragement to him.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A reader describes the poem as a voice reaching out from behind closed doors. That image captures why the poem felt like a rare first-person view.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A brief, emotional reaction from a reader who said the poem made her cry. Responses like this were typical of the comment threads.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A short comment praising the young writer's talent. Recognition of Benjamin as a writer, not just a symbol, was part of the response.

Benjamin Giroux's I Am Poem Gives Readers His Own Perspective

A grandmother shares that her autistic grandson had recently begun to communicate, and recalls the first time he said he loved her. It is one of many personal stories readers posted in reply.

Reading the poem well at home and in class

The poem is one child's account of his own experience. Autism is a broad spectrum, and many autistic people would describe their lives very differently; some reject words like "odd" altogether, while others embrace them. The most respectful way to read it is as Benjamin's voice, not as a definition of autism.

A few ideas for using it with children:

  • Start with noticing. Ask which line surprised them and why, rather than asking what the poem "teaches" about autism.
  • Write their own. The "I am" frame works for any child. Prompts such as I notice or I wonder invite different kinds of self-expression.
  • Make sharing optional. Benjamin's anxiety before reading aloud shows that personal writing should be shared only if the child chooses.
  • Talk about laughter. The poem's line about crying when people laugh opens a natural conversation about teasing and how it feels on the receiving end.

Ten years on, the poem still works because it is honest and specific. A child sat down with a homework sheet, wrote down how he felt, and reminded a great many adults that feeling out of place is something to understand, not to hide.

Sources: Inquirer.net (April 2016): Young boy's poem about Asperger syndrome goes viral; Schiffer Publishing: I Am Odd, I Am New by Benjamin Giroux, illustrated by Roz MacLean; CM Reviews: I Am Odd, I Am New. Images: Benjamin Giroux (@GirouxBenjamin) and public social media replies.

COMMENTS