Teen Asks How to Get Vaccinated Without Parental Consent

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-02-17.

In most of the United States, a 15-year-old cannot simply walk into a clinic and get the full set of childhood vaccines without a parent or legal guardian signing off. There are exceptions, and they differ from state to state: some laws let minors consent to particular shots, such as hepatitis B, and some cover teenagers who live independently, are married or are parents themselves. For everyone else, the realistic routes are a conversation with a doctor or school nurse, a call to the local health department, help from the other parent, or waiting until 18.

That is roughly the answer a Minnesota teenager received when he asked Reddit's legal-advice forum for help in 2018. His post went viral a few months later, in January 2019, just as a measles outbreak was spreading through southwest Washington. Below we walk through the screenshots that circulated, explain what the law he quoted actually says, and look at what happened next, including the story of an Ohio teenager who took his own case to the US Senate.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

The shareable cover card used a stock photo of a hand covered in a red rash, clearly labelled "not the actual photo". The image is by iStock contributor olostock and was chosen to suggest a contagious illness; the boy in the story was not sick.

How an old Reddit question became a viral thread

The post itself was not new when it took off. The screenshots show the original replies stamped "4 months ago" and a second wave of comments stamped "2 days ago", which places the question in the second half of 2018 and its revival in late January 2019. What revived it was a tweet.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

On 25 January 2019, the writer and game designer Andrea Phillips tweeted that teenagers asking how to get vaccinated without parental consent had become a whole genre of Reddit post. The tweet drew tens of thousands of likes, and screenshots of it were often shared alongside the Reddit thread. It landed on the same day Washington's governor declared a state of emergency over measles.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

A reader named Terry Price asked a reasonable follow-up: did she mean flu shots? Plenty of adults skip the yearly flu vaccine, so the question was whether these teens were simply catching up on optional extras.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Phillips replied that these teenagers were looking for the measles-mumps-rubella (MMR) and diphtheria-tetanus-pertussis (DTP) vaccines normally given in infancy and early childhood. In other words, they were missing the most basic protection on the standard schedule, not seasonal boosters.

What the 15-year-old asked

The teenager, later interviewed by Bored Panda under the name Danny, wrote a careful and polite post. The screenshots below follow it in order.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

He introduced himself as the 15-year-old son of a parent opposed to vaccines and said he had spent four years trying to change his mother's mind. Having failed, he wanted to know whether he could be vaccinated on his own. The tone is calm rather than angry, which is part of why readers found the post so affecting.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

He explained that he lived in Minnesota and had been reading the state's health statutes, including the sections on minors' consent to health services and the school immunization law (section 121A.15). Few adults would think to read the statute book before asking a lawyer.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Here he cites Minnesota Statutes section 144.3441, which really does let a minor consent to a hepatitis B vaccination on their own, with no other person's consent needed. Minnesota added this exception so teenagers could get protected quickly against a virus that spreads through blood and sexual contact.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

His uncertainty was about everything else: what form a parent's consent has to take for other vaccines. In practice, clinics usually ask for a parent or guardian's signature or verbal authorisation recorded in the chart, and the details are set by each provider and state.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

He quoted a summary from the Minnesota House research department stating the general rule: minors need a parent's or guardian's consent for health care unless a statute says otherwise. That rule is the default in nearly every US state.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Next he asked what section 144.345, titled "Representations to persons rendering service", actually meant. It is a sensible thing to be confused by, because the title gives little away.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

This is the text of that section. It protects a health provider who relied in good faith on a minor's claim that they could legally consent. It is a shield for the provider, not a new right for the teenager, and it would not cover a minor who knowingly misrepresented their situation.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

He summed up his understanding: apart from hepatitis B, he did not think he could get any vaccines without parental consent. Commenters agreed that, for a 15-year-old living at home in Minnesota, that reading was essentially right.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Finally he asked what legal trouble he might face for faking his parent's signature. Every serious reply told him firmly not to do it, as the next screenshots show.

The practical advice Reddit gave him

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

A user called ADHDCuriosity suggested talking to the school nurse, especially about any immunizations required for school attendance. School nurses deal with exemption paperwork and missing records every year and often know the local options better than anyone.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

The user shiranamiko pointed out that signing a parent's name is forgery, which is a crime. Their advice: if there is no legal way to get consent, wait until 18 and get vaccinated then.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

In a longer reply, the same user listed the realistic options: wait until adulthood, ask the father if he has legal authority over medical decisions and agrees, or speak to a school nurse or the county health department. It closed by repeating the warning against forging a signature.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Rainbowdeathcake praised the teenager for looking after his own health and agreed that, without either parent's consent, waiting until 18 might be the only option. Many replies in the thread shared this mix of encouragement and realism.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Oddlikeeveryoneelse recommended searching for the county public health department. Many US counties run clinics devoted to vaccinations and testing for communicable diseases, without general medical care.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

The comment continued: walk in, ask whether they will accept his consent or can suggest another route, and check sliding-scale pricing. The writer noted that low-income programmes for under-18s may need a parent's participation, so paying full price could be the trade-off.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

The same commenter added some forward-looking advice about sexual health: the clinic is also a place where couples can get tested for sexually transmitted infections together. It is an unusual turn for a vaccine thread, but the point about making testing a routine habit is sound public-health advice.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Liz_eliza raised a detail few others had considered. If the teen waited until 18 but was still on a parent's health insurance, the insurer's explanation-of-benefits statement could show his parents which services he had received.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Her suggested workaround: research low-cost clinics and uninsured prices ahead of time, consider one primary care doctor to manage a multi-dose catch-up schedule, save money if needed, and check what a future college health centre can provide. Catch-up schedules for teens and adults do exist, so starting late still works.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Mcherm asked whether he could travel, since consent laws vary between states and countries. That is true, although for a 15-year-old living at home, travelling alone for medical care raises its own legal and practical problems.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Yensid7 quoted the Minnesota Department of Health's summary of exceptions to the parental-consent rule, starting with the hepatitis B provision and its purpose of giving teens easy access to that vaccine.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

The list goes on: minors who live apart from their parents and manage their own money, minors who have married or given birth, and emergencies in which a professional judges that waiting for consent would put the young person at risk. None of these fit a 15-year-old living at home with a healthy, if unvaccinated, body.

Jokes, frustration and personal stories

When the thread resurfaced in 2019, a new wave of commenters arrived, and the tone shifted from legal research to reaction.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Nonameisthatfrench offered a crude one-liner contrasting what teenagers used to hide from their parents with what they hide now. It became one of the most upvoted reactions, a sign of how absurd many readers found the situation.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Peynus posted a deliberately ridiculous "plan" built on going to prison to get free health care. It is plainly dark humour, not advice, and nobody in the thread took it seriously.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Brenbop said this had been their own story: no vaccines until they turned 18 and could consent alone, and being thrown out of home over it. Comments like this were a reminder that family conflict over vaccination can carry real costs for the young person.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

Eriksarcasm summed up the mood with a four-word sigh about living in a dystopia.

A Teenager's Online Question About Vaccination Consent

The last commenter said that at 16 they had gone to medical appointments alone to get treatment for depression, because their mother believed prayer alone would fix it, and that a family friend who was a lawyer helped them. The claim about age 16 depends entirely on the state. If you are struggling with thoughts of suicide, please talk to a doctor or someone you trust; in the US you can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.

What Danny said later, and the teenager who testified

Speaking to Bored Panda, Danny described his mother's decision as well-meant and said the two could talk openly. His breakthrough came at a routine check-up: he kept pressing the issue and asked the doctor to explain vaccine risks and safety. He and the doctor persuaded his mother to allow tetanus and polio shots. He also said he had received no further vaccines since, and that his younger siblings had none at all.

His story echoed that of Ethan Lindenberger, an Ohio teenager whose mother rejected vaccines. Lindenberger also asked Reddit for advice, got vaccinated after turning 18, and on 5 March 2019 testified before the US Senate Committee on Health, Education, Labor and Pensions at a hearing titled "Vaccines Save Lives: What Is Driving Preventable Disease Outbreaks?". His appearance turned the private struggle of teenagers like Danny into part of a national debate about outbreaks and exemptions.

The measles outbreak in the background

The thread went viral during the 2019 Pacific Northwest measles outbreak. Clark County, Washington, confirmed its first case in late December 2018 and declared a local emergency on 18 January 2019; Governor Jay Inslee declared a statewide emergency a week later. The outbreak eventually sickened 71 people, and more than 90 percent of them had not been vaccinated. The county's measles vaccination rate at the time was about 78 percent, well below the level needed to stop measles spreading.

On 10 May 2019 Inslee signed a law removing personal and philosophical exemptions for the MMR vaccine for school attendance. Medical and religious exemptions remained, and the change applied only to MMR. Nationally, 2019 became the worst year for measles in the US in more than a quarter of a century.

If you are a teenager in the same position

  • Look up your own state or country. Rules differ widely. Some places let minors consent to specific vaccines or to health care from a certain age; others do not.
  • Talk to a professional. A family doctor, school nurse or local health department can tell you what is possible where you live and may help you talk to your parents.
  • Bring in the other parent or guardian. In many places, consent from one person with legal authority is enough.
  • Never forge a signature. It is a crime and can also put the clinic in a difficult position.
  • Plan for 18. Catch-up schedules exist, and a doctor can set one up so you get every dose you missed.

Above all, keep the conversation respectful. Danny's partial success came from patience and from letting a doctor answer his mother's questions directly.

Sources: Original thread on Reddit r/legaladvice; interview and screenshots via Bored Panda; cover photo by olostock / iStock. Law and background: Minnesota Statutes 144.3441; Minnesota Statutes 144.345; Washington Governor's emergency proclamation; Wikipedia, 2019 Pacific Northwest measles outbreak; OPB, 10 May 2019; Wikipedia, Ethan Lindenberger.

COMMENTS