Originally published 2019-02-17.
What are men really thinking during a long shower, a blank stare or a strangely long stride? In early 2019 a Reddit user asked the AskReddit community a simple question: what are some "guy secrets" girls don't know about? The post collected more than 80,000 upvotes and about 40,700 comments, and the answers ranged from bathroom humour to unexpectedly moving confessions about loneliness and mental health.
Below are 38 of the best-known replies as screenshots, each with a short note on what the writer is saying and why it struck a chord. We have grouped them by theme: communication, affection, mental health and the gloriously silly. The original thread is on Reddit.

The question that started it all, posted to r/AskReddit by user mustafarangoon52. The screenshot shows the post at roughly 80,100 upvotes and 40,700 comments, which places it among the busiest discussions on the subreddit that year.
The thread that started it

The opening answer clears up a common misunderstanding: an erection does not always mean arousal. The writer jokes that it sometimes happens out of nowhere and leaves him as puzzled as anyone. Doctors describe such spontaneous erections as a normal body reflex, especially in younger men.

One of the most practical replies in the thread: if you want something, ask directly. The writer says many men are task-focused, so a hint such as "I'm cold" may not register as a request for a blanket. He adds that unspoken anger is harder to fix than a clear complaint.

A gloriously specific story: after reading about fighter jets, the writer remembered a childhood folder showing a T. rex flying a jet, burst out laughing and could not explain why. His point is that men are rarely hiding anything dramatic. Sometimes the secret really is a dinosaur at flight school.

This answer describes the urge to fix a problem when someone comes to you upset. Because many problems cannot be fixed, the writer suggests opening with something like "Can I vent for a minute?" so the listener knows the job is simply to listen. It is advice that works for any couple.

Short and sweet: the writer admits that men sometimes enjoy being the little spoon when cuddling. Several replies in the thread agreed, a reminder that tenderness is not tied to gender.

This reply is aimed at parents of teenage boys: do not burst in first thing in the morning demanding that he jump out of bed. Morning erections are common and involuntary, and a few minutes' grace spares everyone embarrassment. The original wording is blunt, but the advice is kind.
Communication: just say it

The classic misunderstanding: what looks like staring is really a man daydreaming about how he would run a brewery in medieval England, with his eyes happening to point your way. It is a good-natured reminder that a blank gaze is usually just a wandering mind.

When a man says he is thinking about "nothing," this writer insists he often means it literally. The 'nothing box' joke is a long-running staple of relationship comedy, and plenty of people of every gender recognise the feeling.

Another plea for directness: a comment like "I almost broke my neck in the driveway" may be heard as news, not as a request to shovel the snow. The writer says his honest reaction would simply be to thank you for the warning.

A one-line summary of a theme that runs through the whole thread: you are far more likely to get what you want if you ask for it plainly. Communication researchers would broadly agree that clear requests beat hints in most relationships.

A self-mocking story: after fixing a woman's car, the writer was invited in for a shower and politely declined because he had no clean clothes to change into. She giggled, and he only understood the hint much later. It is the thread's favourite example of missing a signal.

Wanting time alone, this writer explains, is not a rejection of a partner; sometimes a person needs a break from everyone. Many introverts of any gender would say the same.

This answer is about dating: if you want something to happen, meet him halfway. The writer says a man who is not making a move may simply be trying hard not to mess things up. Uncertainty and fear of rejection run through several replies.

This writer says the problem is not missing hints but fearing to read too much into them. When someone seems flirtatious, he wonders whether she is interested or just friendly, and often plays it safe.

After work, this writer says, men need 20 to 30 minutes on the couch to switch off before talking about the day, and the drive home does not count. He admits the same is probably true of everyone.
Affection, compliments and the need to be noticed

Two words and an ellipsis, and some 40,000 upvotes: the writer simply likes hugs. Its popularity says a lot about how often men feel they are not supposed to admit it.

Proof of how long a compliment can last: one woman told this writer his haircut looked nice, so he has kept the same cut for four years. Several later answers return to the same idea.

This writer says that when a partner shows even mild interest in a goofy hobby, it means a great deal. His wife asking whether he was looking forward to the video game Anthem made him feel noticed. Small questions about someone's passions are an easy way to show care.

This writer says many men are starved for touch and suggests simple gestures such as a hand on the back, a head scratch or linked arms while walking. He says it grounds him when he is worried about money or work. The need for affectionate touch is widely recognised as important for wellbeing.

A reassuring answer about hair: this writer insists men genuinely like it curly, straight, freshly cut or just out of bed. As long as it looks roughly like the hair on a child's stick figure, he jokes, it looks good.

An oddly specific but widely shared wish: men like it when things are tossed to them instead of handed over. Catching something is a tiny moment of play, and the thousands of upvotes suggest many agree.

Men like compliments too, and this writer says a random comment on his shoes can make his whole day. It is the second of several replies on how rarely men hear praise.

This writer says compliments can stay with a man for weeks, months or even years, whether about his looks or his personality. It ties back to the man who kept the same haircut for four years.

Many men, this writer says, would love to be approached and asked out for a change. It reverses a dating script that still puts most of the pressure on men.
Mental health: the serious side

One of the most upvoted serious answers says men struggle with depression, anxiety and body image too, yet often feel they cannot talk about it. The writer asks readers to notice a friend who withdraws or seems not quite himself. The data back him up, as the section below explains.

A frank description of pressure: many men feel they must be strong, unemotional, the provider who carries everyone. The writer says the fear of asking for help can come out as stress and anger. It echoes what health agencies say about men and mental health.

An important reminder that men can have eating disorders and body-image problems too. The writer says people dismissed his struggles as a phase while the same issues in women were taken seriously. Eating disorders affect people of all genders, and anyone worried should talk to a doctor.
These answers match public health data. In the United States, the CDC reports that men died by suicide at about four times the rate of women in 2023, and that males make up nearly 80% of suicides despite being about half the population. The US National Institute of Mental Health notes that men are less likely than women to have received mental health treatment in the past year, and that depression in men may show up as anger, irritability or aggressiveness rather than obvious sadness. If someone you know seems withdrawn or not himself, asking is a good first step; a primary care doctor can refer him to further help, and in the US anyone can call or text 988 to reach the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.
Bathroom and body confessions

A comic explanation for the odd shuffle some men do on hot days: they are discreetly unsticking themselves. It is one of the earthier answers, included for its honesty rather than its elegance.

A bathroom confession about using the stream to clean stains in the toilet bowl. Juvenile, yes, but it was one of the most upvoted replies, which shows how much of the thread's appeal lies in shared, slightly silly habits.

A near-universal ritual: after tying down a load in a pickup or trailer, men apparently feel obliged to step back and announce that it is not going anywhere. Many readers replied that their fathers did exactly the same.

The answer behind the article's opening question: a long shower does not mean anything suspicious. Sometimes, the writer says, men just enjoy standing under hot water for a long time, like anyone else.

The urge to jump up and touch the top of a doorframe, this writer says, is primal and inexplicable. Hundreds of replies confessed to the same habit.

A second answer on the same theme as the first: an erection does not automatically mean arousal. The writer says it cannot be repeated often enough, and the upvotes suggest many men agree.

A sheepish admission: many men daydream about heroically saving the day during some emergency. It is a fantasy shaped by action films, and it is harmless as long as it stays a daydream.

A bathroom answer in defence of men's aim: the problem, the writer claims, is not poor targeting but an unpredictable spray. Readers who clean bathrooms may have opinions.

A well-known joke rhyme about the last drops ending up in your pants no matter how you shake. It earned its place in the thread through sheer recognition.

A cautionary tale about zips: men learn early to pull the zipper away from the body, and the writer recalls panic when his girlfriend tried to zip him up. Painful zipper accidents are, unfortunately, real.

The thread closes with the 'long stride': the slightly exaggerated step men take to adjust themselves discreetly while walking. Once you know it, you may never unsee it.
What the thread really shows
Strip away the jokes and a pattern appears. The most popular answers fall into a few groups: please say what you mean, men like affection and compliments more than they let on, and many feel pressure to hide fear or sadness. The rest are cheerful oversharing about bodies and bathrooms, which is what made the thread so readable.
It is worth remembering what a Reddit thread is and is not. These are anonymous, self-selected answers, and the most upvoted ones are the funniest or most relatable, not a scientific survey of men. Plenty of women recognised themselves in many of the replies, especially the ones about wanting to be asked directly, needing time alone or loving a compliment. The best use of the list is as a conversation starter: ask the men in your life which ones ring true, and be ready for a laugh or a surprisingly honest answer.
Sources: Reddit r/AskReddit: What are some guy secrets girls don't know about? (2019); CDC: Suicide data and statistics; NIMH: Men and mental health.

COMMENTS