
Elon Musk's view of education can be summed up in one distinction: going to school and actually learning are not the same thing. Since around 2014 he has argued in interviews that children are often taught material without being shown why it matters, and that a university degree tells an employer surprisingly little about what a person can do. He has acted on both ideas, opening a small private school for his own children and saying publicly that he hires for proven ability rather than diplomas.
That is the short answer. The longer one is more interesting, because Musk's own path ran through several universities, the school he founded has changed shape twice since, and education research both supports and complicates his favourite example about screwdrivers and engines.
What Musk has actually said about school
Musk's criticism is less about schools existing than about how they teach. In his telling, pupils are asked to absorb tools and facts first and are only later, if ever, shown the problem those tools solve. Many children, he has said, sit in class unsure why they are there, and a lot of what they memorise is never used again.
His alternative is to start from a real problem and let the tools arrive when they are needed. His best-known illustration is an engine. A conventional course, he suggested, would begin with lessons on screwdrivers and wrenches. He would hand learners an engine and ask them how to take it apart. The moment they need a screwdriver, its purpose becomes obvious. In his words, as quoted in coverage of a 2015 interview, "It's important to teach problem-solving or teach to the problem and not the tools."
He has also argued that children differ in what they are drawn to, whether languages, mathematics or music, and that they develop at different speeds. Grouping them strictly by age, in his view, makes less sense than matching lessons to each child's aptitude.

His own schooling, and why the bullying matters
Musk grew up in Pretoria, South Africa, and attended Waterkloof House Preparatory School, Bryanston High School and Pretoria Boys High School, from which he graduated. By his own account he was a capable but unremarkable student. His school years were marked by bullying; after one fight he was beaten so badly that he ended up in hospital. He has also described a wilderness camp where, as he put it, bullying was treated as a virtue.
It is worth correcting a common myth here: Musk is not a college dropout in the usual sense. He entered Queen's University in Ontario in 1990, transferred two years later to the University of Pennsylvania, and Penn awarded him two bachelor's degrees, a BA in physics and a BS in economics from the Wharton School, in 1997 (Musk says he completed them in 1995). He was accepted into a graduate programme in materials science at Stanford in 1995 but never enrolled, choosing to start a company instead.
So the man arguing that degrees are overrated holds two of them. That does not make his point wrong, but it does show that his criticism comes from someone who used formal education as a springboard before deciding its credentials were not the main thing.
His business record is the reason his opinions get attention. He co-founded the online payments company X.com in 1999, which merged with Confinity, the maker of PayPal, in 2000. He leads Tesla and SpaceX, and Tesla bought the solar installer SolarCity, a company he had backed, in 2016.
Degrees, hiring and the numbers
In a 2014 interview with the German magazine Auto Bild, Musk said formal education was not a priority when he looked at job applicants: "There's no need even to have a college degree, or even high school really." A good university, he added, may hint at ability but does not prove it. What he says he looks for instead is evidence of exceptional work.
A widely shared line goes further. In a screenshot that circulates on social media, Musk supposedly replies to someone who claims you need schooling to get into Harvard with "Don't confuse schooling with education", adding that he did not go to Harvard but people who work for him did. No original post containing those words has been found, so it is best treated as an attributed quote rather than a confirmed one.
Whatever one employer prefers, degrees still matter in the wider labour market. Figures from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics for 2025 put median weekly earnings at $1,578 for workers with a bachelor's degree, compared with $966 for those whose highest qualification is a high school diploma. Unemployment was 2.8% for degree holders and 4.3% for high school graduates. Musk's argument works best at the level of an individual hiring decision; it is not evidence that degrees have stopped paying off on average.

Ad Astra: the school he built
In 2014 Musk took his five children out of their school and, with educator Josh Dahn, set up a small school on the SpaceX campus in Hawthorne, California. He named it Ad Astra, Latin for "to the stars". Musk explained that the existing schools were not doing what he believed they should. Dahn later said that Musk's only brief at the start was to make the school great.
Ad Astra taught a small group, mostly Musk's children and children of SpaceX employees, free of charge. It had no grades, and foreign languages and music were not part of the curriculum. Lessons leaned on projects, problem-solving and open-ended discussion; its teachers developed "Conundrums", ethical and practical dilemmas with no single right answer, designed to get children arguing constructively.
The school left the SpaceX campus in June 2020. Its staff then founded Astra Nova, a nonprofit online school led by Dahn with co-founders Rosemary Rohde and Tara Safronoff. Astra Nova says it had 315 students from 45 countries in mid-2026. The Conundrums later reached far more classrooms through a partnership with ClassDojo, and a commercial spin-off called Synthesis grew out of the same work.
Musk returned to the idea in Texas. In November 2024 the state's child-care regulator granted a permit for an Ad Astra preschool in Bastrop, near Austin, for children aged 3 to 6, with a lower-elementary programme for ages 6 to 9 planned alongside it. The school describes its approach as hands-on and project-based with a strong STEM focus. Musk has also said that education should feel as engaging as a good video game.
What education research says about learning by doing
Musk's engine example belongs to a long tradition. Problem-based learning was formalised in the 1960s at McMaster University's medical school in Canada, where Howard Barrows and colleagues found students struggled to see how textbook material applied to patients. Instead of lectures first, students tackled clinical cases and learned what each case demanded.
The evidence is encouraging but not one-sided. A 2008 systematic review by Koh and colleagues found positive effects on doctors' competence after graduation, particularly in communication and coping with uncertainty. Research on inquiry-based science teaching has reported gains for middle school pupils too.
On the other side, the cognitive scientist John Sweller and others have shown that beginners often learn faster from clearly worked examples than from being dropped into open problems, because novices can be overwhelmed by everything they do not yet know. A much-cited 2006 paper by Kirschner, Sweller and Clark argued that minimally guided instruction does not work well for novices. The practical middle ground most researchers accept is guided problem-solving: give learners a real task, but support them with explanation and examples, then gradually withdraw that support.
In other words, taking apart an engine is a fine way to learn, as long as someone explains what a torque setting is before the head gasket comes off.
Common myths about Musk and education
- "Musk dropped out of college." He holds two bachelor's degrees from the University of Pennsylvania. He skipped a Stanford graduate programme before it began.
- "Musk says school is useless." His criticism targets methods, especially teaching tools without context, rather than learning itself. He built a school, after all.
- "Degrees no longer matter." One employer's hiring philosophy does not change the national data, which still show higher earnings and lower unemployment for graduates.
- "Every quote online is his." Several of the punchiest lines attributed to him, including the Harvard reply, have no traceable original.
Practical takeaways for parents and learners
Very few families can build a school, but the core idea travels well. At home, start with something a child already cares about, a bike that needs fixing, a game they want to design, a question about why the sky changes colour, and let the reading, maths and research follow from it. Ask "what problem does this solve?" whenever a new topic appears in homework. Encourage projects that end in something real: a model, a short film, a working circuit.
At the same time, keep the foundations. Reading fluency, arithmetic and writing are the screwdrivers of almost every later subject, and most children need deliberate practice to master them. A good teacher, in a public school or anywhere else, combines the two. A single entrepreneur's experience, however remarkable, is one data point. The better question for any family is not "school or no school" but whether a child is curious, supported and learning to solve real problems.
Sources: Wikipedia: Elon Musk; Wikipedia: Astra Nova School; Education Week, November 2024: Elon Musk is opening a school for young students; US Bureau of Labor Statistics: Unemployment rates and earnings by educational attainment; Wikipedia: Problem-based learning; header photo of Elon Musk (2015) via Wikimedia Commons.

I have been following Ilon Mask for a long time from various social networks and I like some of his thoughts. I agree that the field of education is still one of the most important topics and we need to think more about it.
ReplyDelete