Kerala's Women's Wall: The 620 km Human Chain of 1 January 2019

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-02-04.

Kerala's Women's Wall: A Large-Scale Demonstration on New Year's Day 2019

Aparnesh Dattatreya/Facebook

On the afternoon of 1 January 2019, women across the Indian state of Kerala stood side by side along the main highway and formed a single human chain about 620 kilometres (385 miles) long, from Kasaragod in the far north to the state capital Thiruvananthapuram in the south. They called it the Vanitha Mathil, or "Women's Wall". Its message was gender equality, and its immediate backdrop was the fierce resistance to women of menstruating age entering the Sabarimala temple after India's Supreme Court had opened the shrine to them.

The chain took shape at 4 pm and held for roughly a quarter of an hour. Below is what happened that day, why the wall was built, how many people really took part, and what followed in the temple dispute.

What the Women's Wall was

The wall was organised by Kerala's Left Democratic Front government, led by the Communist Party of India (Marxist), together with more than 170 social and community organisations. Among them were the SNDP Yogam, which represents the Ezhava community, and the Kerala Pulayar Maha Sabha, a Dalit organisation. The government framed the event as a defence of Kerala's "renaissance values": the social reform movements of the late nineteenth and early twentieth centuries that fought caste discrimination and opened temples to people who had been kept out of them.

Health Minister K. K. Shailaja stood at the northern end in Kasaragod, and CPI(M) politburo member Brinda Karat closed the chain at Vellayambalam in Thiruvananthapuram. Participants ranged from schoolteachers, nurses and farm workers to actors, writers and politicians. In many places men lined up on the opposite side of the road in support. At the end the women repeated a pledge to uphold equality, secularism and the reformist legacy of the state.

Interestingly, the pledge did not mention Sabarimala by name. Everyone understood the connection, though, because the event came just three months into the most heated religious and political confrontation Kerala had seen in years.

How many women took part?

The figure that travelled furthest online was five million women. It is worth treating with care. Organisers told reporters that more than three million took part, while several news outlets simply described "lakhs" (hundreds of thousands) of participants without giving a number. Crowd counts along a 620 km road are hard to verify, and the main opposition parties disputed the government's claims.

What nobody seriously disputed is that the turnout was very large and the chain was continuous across all of Kerala's districts. Whether the true number was one, three or five million, it was among the largest coordinated demonstrations ever held in the state, and organisers said they would seek a Guinness record.

The Sabarimala dispute behind it

Sabarimala is a hilltop shrine to the deity Ayyappan inside Periyar National Park, and one of the busiest pilgrimage sites in India, with an estimated 10 to 15 million visitors a year. For decades the temple barred women aged roughly 10 to 50. Girls and older women could visit; women of reproductive age could not. Defenders of the custom say it honours the deity's vow of celibacy. Critics say it rests on the idea that menstruating women are impure.

In 1991 the Kerala High Court upheld the restriction as long-standing custom. Then, on 28 September 2018, a five-judge bench of the Supreme Court of India struck it down by four votes to one. Chief Justice Dipak Misra described the exclusion as a form of "religious patriarchy". The only woman on the bench, Justice Indu Malhotra, dissented, arguing that courts should not decide which practices are essential to a faith.

The ruling set off months of protests. When the temple reopened in October 2018, crowds at the base camps of Nilakkal and Pamba stopped vehicles to check for women of the barred age group, and women journalists were attacked. Several women who tried to make the climb were forced to turn back. On 26 December 2018, supporters of the custom organised their own mass event, the "Ayyappa Jyothi", a line of lamps lit along the roads. The Women's Wall a week later was, in part, the government's answer.

Support, criticism and politics

Supporters saw the wall as a rare show of public solidarity for women's rights in a country where such issues are often handled quietly. For many participants it was less about the temple than about the right to be treated as equals in every sphere, from worship to work.

Critics saw it differently. The Congress party and the BJP called it a "communal wall", accusing the ruling coalition of using state resources for a partisan show and of relying mainly on caste-based groups. Some observers also asked why a pledge about equality avoided naming the very temple dispute that inspired it. These arguments matter if you want to understand the event fully: it was a genuine mass movement, and it was also a political move in a deeply divided state.

What happened the next morning

Within about twelve hours, the debate moved from the highway to the shrine itself. In the early hours of 2 January 2019, two women in their early forties, Bindu Ammini (41), a law lecturer at Kannur University and Dalit activist, and Kanakadurga (40), a manager at the state Civil Supplies Corporation, entered Sabarimala with a police escort through a staff gate. Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan confirmed it later that morning.

The temple's priests closed the sanctum for a purification ritual. Groups opposed to the verdict, backed by the BJP, called a statewide general strike (hartal) for 3 January, and Kerala saw a day of clashes and closures. The two women faced threats and had to live under police protection for some time.

The legal story did not end there either. Dozens of petitions asked the Supreme Court to review its ruling. In November 2019 the court sent the wider questions about religious freedom and women's entry to places of worship to a larger bench, without staying the 2018 judgment. That larger examination has dragged on for years, and in practice very few women of the formerly barred age group have made the pilgrimage since.

The wider picture for women's safety in India

The wall resonated beyond Kerala because it touched on far bigger concerns. In 2018 a Thomson Reuters Foundation survey of about 550 experts ranked India as the most dangerous country in the world for women, citing sexual violence, human trafficking and harmful cultural practices such as child marriage and acid attacks. An earlier 2011 edition had placed India fourth. The survey measured expert perception rather than crime data, and India's National Commission for Women rejected the ranking, but it reflected a real alarm.

That alarm had grown since December 2012, when a 23-year-old physiotherapy student was gang-raped on a moving bus in New Delhi and later died of her injuries. Nationwide protests led to tougher laws in 2013, and four of the attackers were executed in 2020. The Guardian revisited Delhi five years later to ask how much had really changed for women there. India's National Crime Records Bureau still records several hundred thousand crimes against women each year, and campaigners stress that many cases go unreported.

Responses have sometimes been unusual. In 2017 Gopal Bhargava, a minister in the state of Madhya Pradesh, handed out wooden bats to brides so they could defend themselves against drunken, abusive husbands, a gesture critics called a sign of how far the police and courts were falling short. Longer-term efforts include campaigns such as Oxfam India's "We Can" coalition, which works to change attitudes to violence in homes and communities.

(The Facebook post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

Why the Women's Wall still matters

Kerala has some of India's best social indicators: near-universal literacy, a long life expectancy and more women than men in its population. That makes the Sabarimala confrontation especially revealing. Even in the state often held up as a model, questions about women's place in religious life could divide families, parties and courts.

The Women's Wall did not settle those questions. What it did show is how quickly a court ruling on one temple can become a test of a whole society's values, and how many ordinary women were willing to stand on a roadside for fifteen minutes to say where they stood. For readers trying to understand modern Kerala, it is a useful window into the meeting point of faith, law and politics.

Sources: The News Minute: Kerala's wall of resistance; Herald Malaysia / UCA News: Three million join "women's wall" in Kerala; Wikipedia: Sabarimala Temple; The Week: Pilgrims' progress; Thomson Reuters Foundation poll 2018. Photo: Aparnesh Dattatreya.

COMMENTS