Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2019-02-04.

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

With a population of approximately 7.5 million and very little developable land, Hong Kong is the least affordable housing market today, making so-called 'coffin cubicles' common. The UN has condemned those nightmarish cage-apartments as "an insult to human dignity." According to the Society for Community Organisation, however, for some 200,000 people it remains the only alternative.


"That day, I came home and cried," Benny Lam said, describing his experience of photographing living conditions. With his photographic series "Trapped," Lam aims to illuminate the suffocating local dwellings which stand out of the reach of Hong Kong's glamorous neon lights. As Lam wrote on his Facebook page:


"You may wonder why we should care, as these people are not a part of our lives. They are exactly the people who come into your life every single day: they are serving you as the waiters in the restaurants where you eat, they are the security guards in the shopping malls you wander around, or the cleaners and the delivery men on the streets you pass through. The only difference between us and them is [their homes]. This is a question of human dignity."


In order to create the 'coffin cubicles,' flats are illegally divided into 15 - 120-square-foot (roughly 1.5–11 m²) 'apartments.' To illustrate, Wong Tat-ming, 63, that is on benefits after sclerosis in his leg left him unable to drive a taxi, lives in an 18-square-feet dwelling for about $307 (HK$2,400) a month.


More info: Facebook (h/t: nationalgeographic)


Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

Benny Lam's Photographs of Hong Kong's Subdivided Homes

The frame makes limited space visible

Lam's photographs show how a room's dimensions shape ordinary activities such as sleeping, eating, and storing belongings. The overhead viewpoint can make those constraints immediately legible, but each image still represents a particular home and moment. It should not be treated as a complete portrait of everyone living in Hong Kong or of a resident's entire life.

Read the figures beside their dates

Rent examples and estimates of residents in subdivided accommodation depend on definitions and the period being measured. Keeping that context avoids turning historical figures into present-day housing data. The photographs invite attention to dignity, privacy, and access to adequate space; their subjects deserve more than being used as a startling comparison with someone else's larger home.

About the Trapped series

Lam spent four years visiting more than 100 subdivided flats in the city’s old district for Trapped, which was commissioned by the Society for Community Organization (SoCO), a non-profit founded in 1972. The units range from about 15 to 100 square feet and often have no windows; residents call them “cages” or “coffins”, and some are too small to stand up or lie down in fully. A 400-square-foot flat may be divided into space for 20 double-decker beds, each renting for about HK$2,000 a month. When the photographs were published in 2017, about 200,000 people, including 40,000 children, lived in such spaces. “Living like that should never be normal. I had become numb,” Lam said. In 2018 he gave works from the series to the M+ museum in Hong Kong; one print in its collection is dated 2012.

Sources: National Geographic, 26 July 2017: Life inside Hong Kong’s “coffin cubicles” M+ collection: Benny Lam, Trapped—sub-divided units 04 (2012)

COMMENTS