Teen Answers Grandma’s Facebook Post About Muslims in Congress

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
A Granddaughter's Replies in a Family Facebook Debate

Can a Muslim member of the US Congress be sworn in without a Bible? Yes. The Constitution asks every federal official for an oath or affirmation to support it, and it explicitly bans any religious test for public office. No holy book is legally required at all.

That point sat at the centre of a family argument that went viral in December 2018. After Rashida Tlaib and Ilhan Omar were elected as the first two Muslim women in Congress, a grandmother shared a Facebook graphic warning that they could not swear on the Bible and calling their election a Trojan horse. Her teenage granddaughter replied in the comments, calmly and politely, with a civics lesson. Screenshots of the thread, with names blurred, spread online, where thousands of readers praised the girl and her parents.

Below you will find the exchange, the reactions, and a check of the facts each side used.

Who Rashida Tlaib and Ilhan Omar are

A Granddaughter's Replies in a Family Facebook Debate

AP

Ilhan Omar takes an oath with her right hand raised. Born in Mogadishu, Somalia, in 1982, she spent four years in a Kenyan refugee camp before her family was granted asylum in the United States in 1995. She served in the Minnesota House from 2017 and entered the US House of Representatives on 3 January 2019.

A Granddaughter's Replies in a Family Facebook Debate

Reuters

Rashida Tlaib was born in Detroit, Michigan, in 1976, to Palestinian immigrant parents. She was sworn into Congress the same day as Omar, using an English translation of the Quran, while Omar used a copy that had belonged to her grandfather. They were the first Muslim women to serve in Congress, though not the first Muslims: Keith Ellison of Minnesota was elected in 2006.

The grandmother’s post and the first reply

A Granddaughter's Replies in a Family Facebook Debate

The grandmother shared a red text graphic with a short exclamation of her own. The graphic claimed the two women could not put their hands on the Bible and uphold the Constitution because of their faith. That claim mixes two separate things: the oath is to the Constitution, and the book, if any, is a personal choice.

A Granddaughter's Replies in a Family Facebook Debate

The granddaughter, addressing her grandmother as Meema, opened with affection and then cited the First Amendment’s protection of religious freedom. She argued that keeping non-Christians out of office would be like banning Christians in an area with many atheists, and said at least a fifth of Americans are not Christian. She credited what she had learned in her government class and signed off hoping to see her grandmother at Christmas.

Her numbers were, if anything, cautious. Gallup found about 74 percent of US adults identified as Christian in 2016, and Pew surveys from 2018 and 2019 put the religiously unaffiliated alone at around 26 percent.

Immigration, safety and fear

A Granddaughter's Replies in a Family Facebook Debate

The grandmother replied that her concern was Muslims in Congress at a time when the country was supposed to be stopping illegal immigration. She said she worried about her great-grandchildren being hurt and blamed immigrants for taking jobs in her town, which is blurred in the screenshot.

A Granddaughter's Replies in a Family Facebook Debate

The granddaughter answered that, as far as she knew, both women were born in America, and that crime is driven more by people born in the country than by immigrants. She added that police are more likely to arrest Black and Latino Americans, and that she was more worried about a man shouting antisemitic threats than about two Muslim women taking office.

One correction is needed here: Tlaib was born in Detroit, but Omar was born in Somalia and became a US citizen after arriving as a refugee. On crime, her broader point has research support. Most studies find no causal link between immigration and higher overall crime, and the United States is a notable exception to the pattern of immigrants being over-represented in prisons seen in some other Western countries.

A Granddaughter's Replies in a Family Facebook Debate

The grandmother then said what really frightened her was suicide bombers who target innocent people, and that she simply did not want that near the children she loved. It is the emotional core of the thread: her worry is sincere, even though it is aimed at two elected lawmakers with no link to violence.

A Granddaughter's Replies in a Family Facebook Debate

In the longest reply, the granddaughter told her grandmother that her fear was far out of proportion to the actual risk. She pointed to mass shootings in schools, malls and churches by American-born men as a more present danger in her own life, and said the immigrant and religious-minority students at her school were kind people she would stand with in a crisis. She also thanked her mother, the grandmother’s daughter, for teaching her how to respond.

How readers reacted

When the screenshots were reposted, most comments were addressed to the girl’s parent, who appears to have shared the thread. The handles below are public usernames from those comment sections.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

A commenter named Gr33nMachine, whose remark collected more than a thousand votes, told the parent their daughter had handled the exchange well. The top reaction set the tone: people admired the tone of the reply as much as its content.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

User breeyag praised the parents for raising a girl with common sense and a voice, adding that the world needs more like her. Several readers made the same point about raising children who think for themselves.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

The same user said she was proud the teen had the courage to speak up to her grandmother. Disagreeing politely with an older relative in public is something many adults avoid, which is why this struck a chord.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

User kusooner simply quoted the US Constitution itself, which settles the oath question in one line.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

RhysIndigo called the girl smart, rational and heartfelt, and said young people like her made them less worried about the future.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

Steps2psychosis argued that fear is one of the main ingredients of blind bigotry. It is a blunt line, but it echoes the girl’s own point that worry was driving her grandmother’s views.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

ChakakMonster noted that America was built by immigrants and asked what the problem was now. Except for Native Americans, almost every US family history does include immigration.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

Davincimode urged readers to praise the parents, reward the child and celebrate the family for raising a tolerant person.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

minipancho94 offered a darker warning: that some of the worst atrocities in history, including the Holocaust, were carried out by people who believed they were acting out of love for their country.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

The same comment appears twice in the original set of screenshots. Its point is that good intentions do not guarantee good outcomes, which is why fears should be checked against facts.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

A user named WhenIGrowUpIWannaBeAnAardvark blamed tribalism and xenophobia, and people being told what to think rather than how to think.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

A commenter who said they were Muslim pointed out that Muslims can swear on the Bible too, since Islam regards it as one of the earlier holy books. Islamic tradition does honour the Torah and the Gospel as earlier revelations, though interpretations of the present-day texts vary.

People applauded the parents that raised such a well-spoken daughter

User brujo1791 closed with praise for raising a sensible, kind-hearted person. That warmth runs through almost every reaction collected here.

The facts behind the oath of office

Article VI of the US Constitution requires officials to be bound by oath or affirmation to support it and adds a clear rule.

“No religious Test shall ever be required as a Qualification to any Office or public Trust under the United States.” — US Constitution, Article VI

The choice of an affirmation instead of an oath accommodates people, such as many Quakers, whose faith discourages swearing. Holding a book is a custom, not a legal requirement, and lawmakers have used different texts, as Tlaib and Omar did with the Quran. When Keith Ellison became the first Muslim in Congress in 2007, he used a copy of the Quran that once belonged to Thomas Jefferson for his re-enacted ceremonial swearing-in.

How to have a hard conversation with family

  • Lead with the relationship. The granddaughter opened and closed with love, which kept the thread from becoming a fight.
  • Answer the claim, not the person. She focused on what the post said, not on her grandmother’s character.
  • Bring sources. Pointing to the Constitution is more persuasive than an opinion.
  • Check your own facts. Even a strong reply can contain an error, as the line about where both women were born shows.
  • Consider a private message. Public threads attract an audience, and audiences can make people defensive.

The thread became popular because it showed something people rarely see online: a disagreement about religion and politics where both sides still said “I love you”.

Sources: Wikipedia, No Religious Test Clause (US Constitution, Article VI); Wikipedia, Ilhan Omar; Wikipedia, Rashida Tlaib; Wikipedia, Keith Ellison; Wikipedia, Religion in the United States; Wikipedia, Immigration and crime; Bored Panda, where the screenshots circulated (December 2018).

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 7
  1. that was written by no kid to her grandma ,and the reason for the crime that comes from within , will if the jobs that the forginers take , rights that they are afforded and not the people from within ,were given to the withins , then they wouldn't be out breaking the law to live would they .again written by a refugee to get people on their side . stay were you at , fix the problems in your own country and stop fucking up everyone else's.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I mean this in the nicest way possible, but that was hard to read. Nowhere in your statement did you manage to put a complete thought together. I'm willing to guess that it's due to a lack of education and a lot of people who react negatively to Muslims and immigrants lack education. Education is what brings us together and teaches us what's really happening and gives us perspective. Without it, you make blind assumptions like I'm sure you just did. Take care "Unknown."

      Delete
  2. I'm British. We've got moslem members of Parliament, a moslem is Mayor of London, there are moslem ladies who read the news on our TV, and in Portsmouth (where I live), there are two mosques. For my part, I'm mot worried a bit.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Ur granny is absolutely right,, untill minority muslims r best neighbours,, whn in equal/majority which anyway they will put their sleep to creat,,, they r molesters,,, terrorists,,, shariya enforcers,,,nativr religion killers,,native culture killers,, n supremacy complexed in the name of islam,,, see canada,, india,, myanmar,, france,,sweeden afganistan syria,,,, I totally agree with grandma,., if u dnt take a lesson for the realities now,,, it vl b too late fr ur kids n liberal views will be in dustbin,,, wakeup,, do more google searching on this,,,

    ReplyDelete
  4. Girl it is not in the constitution but it is TRADITION. If you break tradition, then there should be an explanation. Your grandmother is correct about the trojan horse. The Roman empire fell when non Romans join the army and one of its famous general in fact led a legion to its death.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Islam is NOT just a religion it is also political ideology which WILL become a fascistic "Theocracy" if allowed to. It represses womens rights, allows violence against women, seeks to tax and repress non muslims if not worse and in extreme cases kill homosexuals. Sharia Law, must not be allowed to gain a foothold in America.

    ReplyDelete