Cassey Ho's 'Perfect Body' Through History Photoshop Series

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

In late 2018, fitness instructor and YouTuber Cassey Ho, the creator of Blogilates, posted a series of photos of herself digitally reshaped to match the "perfect" female body of different eras, from the Italian Renaissance to Instagram in 2018. Her body grows rounder, then boyish, then curvy, then extremely thin, then curvy again, all within a few frames. The point was not that any of these bodies is right. It was how quickly the target keeps moving, and how unfair it is to expect real women to chase it.

Ho said the project started with her own insecurity. Scrolling through Instagram full of "belfies", or butt selfies, left her feeling there was something wrong with her own small behind. Rather than chase that look, she used Photoshop to show where it sat in a longer history of shifting ideals. Below is each image, what era it represents, and how well her short descriptions hold up against the history.

Who Cassey Ho is, and why she made the series

Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

This is Ho as she actually looks, in a mirror selfie in a dance studio wearing a sports bra and leggings. A Pilates instructor with a large online following, she built her Blogilates brand around home workouts and her own activewear line.

The 2018 series was not her first experiment with editing software. In 2015 she posted a viral video called "The 'Perfect' Body", in which she airbrushed her own photo to enlarge her bust, shrink her waist and add a thigh gap, as a response to hurtful comments about her shape. The 2018 version went further by adding history. As she wrote alongside it: "I find it disturbing that an aspect of a woman's body can be deemed hideous in one era and then glorified in the next!"

The 2010s and 2000s: curves, then thin, then curves again

Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

2018: small waist, big butt. Ho widened her hips and enlarged her bottom to match the Instagram look of the late 2010s, associated with celebrities and influencers who popularised full curves on a slim frame. Her caption linked the look to a boom in buttock implants and injections, citing a 58% rise between 2012 and 2014. Buttock procedures did grow quickly in that period, but we could not confirm that exact figure against a primary source.

Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

Mid-1990s to 2000s: big bust, long legs. This frame adds a fuller chest and slimmer, longer legs, the look Ho associated with lingerie runway shows of the era. Her note that breast augmentation was America's most common cosmetic operation around 2010 fits statistics published by the American Society of Plastic Surgeons, which ranked it at or near the top for most of those years.

Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

1990s: extreme thinness. Here Ho's body is narrowed to a very slim, angular frame. In the early to mid 1990s, fashion photography embraced a gaunt, pale look later labelled "heroin chic", seen in Kate Moss's 1993 Calvin Klein campaign. It drew fierce criticism, including from US President Bill Clinton in 1997, and faded by the end of the decade.

The 1950s and 1920s: hourglass versus boyish

Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

1950s: the hourglass. Ho fills out her bust and hips while keeping a tight waist, the shape linked with stars such as Marilyn Monroe and Elizabeth Taylor. Measurements quoted for these stars come mostly from studio publicity and fan magazines, so treat them as legend rather than fact. The timeline details do check out: Playboy launched in 1953 and Barbie went on sale in 1959.

Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

1920s: boyish and straight. In this frame Ho's curves are flattened into a straight up-and-down line. Flapper fashion favoured a youthful, boyish figure with short bobbed hair, a dropped waist and a flattened chest, achieved with bust bodices and bras designed to flatten rather than lift. It was a deliberate break from the pinched-waist corsets of earlier decades.

The Renaissance: full and rounded

Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

1400 to 1700: full and curvy. The final frame gives Ho a rounded stomach, wide hips and heavy thighs, echoing the figures in paintings by artists such as Titian and, later, Rubens. Ho's caption tied this to the idea that being well fed signalled wealth. That is a popular explanation, and there is some truth in it, but three centuries of European art cannot be reduced to one ideal, and painted nudes were not necessarily a guide to what ordinary people found attractive.

Seen together, the six frames make her case clearly. The same woman, in the same room, on the same yoga mat, would have been "ideal" in one century and "wrong" in the next.

The real Cassey Ho, and how people responded

Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

Ho laughing with a plate of powdered beignets, the kind of photo she shared to make the opposite point to the edits: real bodies enjoy food. Her message with the series was to treat your body with respect and love what you have.

Cassey Ho’s Edited Body Images Question Changing Beauty Ideals

Ho doing the splits in a gym, an unedited photo that shows what her training has built. Strength and flexibility, unlike silhouettes, do not go out of fashion.

The comment section filled quickly. A selection of responses posted under the series on Instagram follows.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

One reader agreed strongly and pointed out that men have not faced the same dramatic swings in ideal shape, adding that women themselves often reinforce the pressure.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

Another commenter praised the post and argued that trying to look like everyone else only hides who people really are. Individuality, in her view, is worth more than any trend.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

This reader hoped many women would see the series and conclude that no single body shape is perfect. Her comment ended with a simple thank-you to Ho.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

A commenter joked that she is "stuck in 1950" and happy about it, and thanked Ho for showing how society pushes women to feel they can never measure up.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

A short reply that sums up a common view among readers: the best body is a healthy one, whatever its shape. It shifts the focus from looks to wellbeing, which was much of Ho's own point.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

Another follower thanked Ho directly for sharing the message with women everywhere. Many replies were like this one: short, personal and grateful.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

This reader simply reminded others that every body is different and worth embracing. Difference, rather than conformity, was the theme running through most responses.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

Humour came through too: one commenter decided she has a perfect body, just born in the wrong era, and claimed the Renaissance as her own.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

This commenter called the series a simple, powerful way to show why chasing beauty standards is both dangerous and absurd.

People congratulated her on her positive project in the comments

A last reader said she knew standards were shifting, but seeing them laid out side by side made it real. That visual comparison is exactly what gave the series its reach.

What the series gets right, and what to take from it

As history, the series is simplified. Each "era" mixes runway fashion, celebrity and art, and every period had many competing ideals depending on class, region and culture. Ho's images are interpretations made in Photoshop, not a record of her changing her actual body. The numbers in her captions are best read as commentary rather than data.

As an argument, though, it is hard to fault. Ideals are set by fashion, media and art, and they change faster than any body can. If the shape you are told to have keeps changing, the sensible response is to stop chasing it and focus on what your body can do: move, rest, recover and feel strong.

If worries about weight or shape are affecting your eating, mood or daily life, talk to a doctor. Those feelings are common and help is available.

For another project that asks how photos shape what we see as beautiful, read about Arber Bytyqi's bridal makeup portraits.

Sources: Images and comments from Cassey Ho (Blogilates) on Instagram, first collected by Bored Panda. Reporting and background: Euronews / TODAY (December 2018); Heroin chic (Wikipedia); Flapper (Wikipedia).

COMMENTS