Gabi Mann: The Seattle Girl Who Gets Gifts From Crows

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-12-24.

Gabi Mann and the Objects Crows Left in Her Garden

Gabi Mann is the Seattle girl who fed her neighbourhood crows and found small objects waiting for her in return: beads, buttons, bits of glass, a tiny metal heart, even a camera lens cap her mother had lost. Her story reached readers around the world in early 2015, when the BBC visited the family and photographed her carefully labelled collection. Gabi was eight at the time.

Below is what actually happened, what the "gifts" were, and what crow researchers say about whether birds really give presents to the people who feed them.

How a dropped lunch turned into a daily routine

It started by accident. As a small child, Gabi was a messy eater, and scraps tended to fall wherever she went. The local American crows noticed. Over time she began sharing food with them on purpose, including on the walk to and from the school bus with her brother, and the birds learned to watch for the children.

By 2013 the casual sharing had become a family habit. Each morning Gabi and her mother, Lisa, refilled the backyard birdbath with clean water and put out food on a platform feeder, mostly peanuts along with some dog food. Audubon, which covered the story in March 2015, noted that peanuts were the crows' clear favourite.

Not long after the routine became regular, small objects started turning up on the feeder tray and around the birdbath.

Gabi Mann and the Objects Crows Left in Her Garden

A smiling child of the Mann household with the flock gathered on the lawn behind. Crows that are fed at the same place and time every day quickly learn the routine and the people involved in it.

The collection: what the crows left behind

Gabi treated each find like a museum piece. She stored the objects in small plastic bags inside a bead-organiser box, and many bags carry a note of where and when the item appeared. One label, attached to a piece of broken light bulb, records a black table near the feeder, a time of 2:30 p.m. and a date in November 2014.

Gabi Mann and the Objects Crows Left in Her Garden

The bead box that holds the collection. Each compartment or bag keeps one object together with a handwritten record of where it was found, which makes the collection far more useful than a simple pile of trinkets.

The objects reported over the years include:

  • beads, buttons and paper clips
  • Lego pieces and scraps of foam
  • polished sea glass
  • a piece of metal stamped with the word "best"
  • a pearl-coloured heart, which Gabi named her favourite
  • a screw, a tube of lip balm and other odd bits of hardware
Gabi Mann and the Objects Crows Left in Her Garden

Part of the collection laid out on a purple cloth. Most items are small, light and easy for a crow to carry in its beak, and many are the kind of everyday litter found along city streets and alleys.

Not every delivery was pleasant. Lisa once had to throw away a rotting crab claw that a crow had left in the yard. Gabi also said she kept the screw even though she did not like touching it, simply because it seemed such an unusual thing for a bird to bring.

The lens cap and the bird camera

The most striking episode involved Lisa rather than Gabi. While photographing a bald eagle near their home, she lost the cap of her camera lens in an alley. Before she had a chance to search for it, the cap turned up on the rim of the birdbath.

Gabi Mann and the Objects Crows Left in Her Garden

Crows at the family's birdbath, the spot where the lost lens cap reappeared. A stone basin like this works as both a water source and a place where birds linger and drop things.

The family had a camera trained on the feeding area, so Lisa checked the footage. According to her account to the BBC, it showed a crow carrying the cap into the yard, walking it over to the birdbath and spending time dipping it in the water before leaving it on the edge. Whether the bird meant to "return" the cap or was simply handling an interesting object near its food source cannot be known, but the timing made it the family's favourite crow story.

Gabi Mann and the Objects Crows Left in Her Garden

A crow at the platform feeder stocked with peanuts. Consistent, predictable food in one place is what turns a passing flock into regular visitors who know the household.

Do crows really give gifts? What the research says

Crows belong to the corvid family, along with ravens, jays and magpies, and they are among the most intelligent birds studied. Audubon describes them as skilled tool users, and research groups have documented crows solving multi-step puzzles and remembering individual people for years.

The best known work on wild urban crows comes from John Marzluff, a professor of wildlife science at the University of Washington in Seattle. In his experiments, researchers wearing a particular mask trapped and banded crows. Afterwards, crows scolded anyone wearing that mask, and birds that had never been trapped joined in, showing that the knowledge spread through the flock and down the generations.

Marzluff, who wrote Gifts of the Crow with artist Tony Angell, told reporters that he had never received a gift from a crow himself but had seen many objects that crows brought to people who fed them. His advice to anyone hoping for a similar bond was simple: be consistent in rewarding them. He also warned that presents are not guaranteed, and that some people receive unwelcome ones, such as dead nestlings.

Scientists are cautious about calling these objects gifts in the human sense. A crow may be trading, caching, playing with an object or simply dropping it at a place it associates with food. What the Mann family recorded is real behaviour; the meaning behind it is our interpretation. That is exactly why Gabi's habit of noting time and place is valuable: it separates what was observed from what we imagine the birds intended.

If you want to befriend crows yourself

Feeding crows is legal in most places, but local rules vary and some cities or housing associations restrict feeding wildlife, so check first. If you go ahead, a few practical points help both you and the birds:

  • Be predictable. Same place, similar time, every day. Crows learn routines and faces quickly.
  • Offer suitable food. Unsalted peanuts in the shell, plain cooked egg or a little dry pet food are better than bread or salty leftovers.
  • Keep it modest. Small amounts avoid attracting rats and avoid making the birds dependent on you.
  • Provide clean water. A birdbath that is rinsed and refilled often is as attractive as food.
  • Keep your distance. Watch, don't grab. Wild birds should stay wild, and in spring parents defend fledglings fiercely.
  • Keep a notebook. Record what you see and when, the way Gabi did. It turns a hobby into a small piece of citizen science.

Expect patience to matter more than anything else. Many people feed crows for years without receiving a single object, and that is normal.

Gabi Mann and the Objects Crows Left in Her Garden

Gabi and her mother Lisa. The whole family became interested in the crows over time, and the daily ritual of food and water was something mother and daughter shared each morning.

Why this story still resonates

Part of the appeal is simple: a child was kind to animals that many people dislike, and the animals seemed to answer. But the story also shows how much ordinary attention can reveal. Gabi's dated labels, the family's bird camera and a lot of patience turned a backyard into a small window on corvid behaviour, the same kind of curiosity that drives Marzluff's research a few miles away.

Whether the crows were saying thank you, trading for peanuts or just leaving things near a reliable meal, they clearly knew this family, and the family came to know them.

Sources: Photographs via BBC News Magazine (2015); Audubon: Seattle girl befriends neighborhood crows; Wikipedia: John Marzluff.

COMMENTS