Taxi Driver Ejects Littering Passenger: What the Dashcam Shows

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-11-15.

Furious Taxi Driver Dragged His Passenger Out Of The Car For Dropping Litter

A short dashcam clip filmed in traffic near St Petersburg, Russia, shows a taxi passenger tossing a plastic bottle out of the window, and the driver answering in the most dramatic way possible: he stops, collects the bottle, hauls the young man out of the back seat and drives off without him. The video spread widely in November 2018 and was usually shared as a story of instant justice.

It is worth watching for what it says about littering, about how fast people cheer for punishment, and about the line between standing up for shared spaces and putting someone in danger. Here is what the footage shows, what it does not show, and what actually works against roadside litter.

What the dashcam footage shows

The recording comes from the car directly behind the taxi, a silver BMW 3 Series with a roof sign, while both vehicles crawl along in slow traffic. A bottle drops from the passenger side onto the verge. Within seconds the taxi pulls over, its driver steps out and raises a hand towards the car behind, a small apology for holding up the lane.

He walks back, picks the bottle up from the roadside and returns to the rear door. Then the mood changes. He grabs the passenger by the collar and the waistband of his trousers and drags him out head first, leaving him sprawled beside the road. The driver gets back behind the wheel, swings the car round in a tight U-turn and leaves.

The whole incident takes well under a minute. The passenger, still picking himself up, can only watch the taxi disappear. Nobody in the clip appears to be badly hurt, but nothing in the footage tells us whether he was injured, whether he paid, or what happened next.

Frame by frame

The stills below come from the same recording, which carries a ViralHog watermark. The first one is the moment most people remember; the rest follow the incident from the start.

Furious Taxi Driver Dragged His Passenger Out Of The Car For Dropping Litter

The passenger lies in the dust at the edge of the road while the driver, in a navy T-shirt and shorts, strides back towards his door. The taxi's roof sign and brake lights are still on.

Furious Taxi Driver Dragged His Passenger Out Of The Car For Dropping Litter

The silver BMW brakes hard just after the bottle leaves the passenger side. In the original video the bottle can be seen dropping onto the sandy verge.

Furious Taxi Driver Dragged His Passenger Out Of The Car For Dropping Litter

The driver gets out, leaving his door open, and walks to the back of the car rather than straight to his passenger.

Furious Taxi Driver Dragged His Passenger Out Of The Car For Dropping Litter

A raised hand towards the car behind. It is the only calm moment in the clip: a polite apology for blocking the lane before things turn rough.

Furious Taxi Driver Dragged His Passenger Out Of The Car For Dropping Litter

Bending down on the shoulder, the driver retrieves the bottle himself. Had the clip stopped here, it would have been a simple lesson in tidiness.

Furious Taxi Driver Dragged His Passenger Out Of The Car For Dropping Litter

Instead he opens the rear door and pulls the young man out by his clothing, head first, in one movement.

Furious Taxi Driver Dragged His Passenger Out Of The Car For Dropping Litter

The taxi swings round in a tight U-turn and kicks up dust, while the passenger, now on his feet, watches his ride leave without him.

Why the clip went viral

A witness, apparently the person filming, told reporters the driver had decided to teach his passenger a lesson and called the outcome justice. That reaction captured the mood online. Plenty of people have watched someone flick a can or a cigarette butt from a car window and felt powerless; seeing the litterer instantly lose his ride is a satisfying fantasy.

Russia also produces an unusual amount of this kind of footage. Dashboard cameras are common there because drivers use them as evidence against insurance fraud and against corrupt traffic police, and courts often look at the recordings when deciding who caused a collision. The same habit gave the world dozens of angles on the Chelyabinsk meteor in 2013, and it means everyday road dramas, like this one, are filmed far more often than in most countries.

Littering is a real problem

The driver's anger is easy to understand. Roadside rubbish is ugly, but it is also expensive and harmful. In the United States, cleaning up litter is estimated to cost around $11 billion a year, roughly ten times what it costs to dispose of the same waste properly. A large share of land-based litter eventually washes into streams and rivers, and most marine debris begins on land.

Bottles are a particular nuisance. Plastic does not rot away in any human time frame, broken glass cuts animals' paws, and open containers collect rainwater where mosquitoes breed. Animals also mistake small pieces of rubbish for food.

Researchers who study littering note a frustrating pattern: litter attracts more litter. A verge that already has a few bottles on it signals that nobody cares, and people are more likely to add to the pile. That is one reason picking up a single bottle, as the driver did first, is not a pointless gesture.

Where the driver crossed a line

Agreeing with the driver about litter is not the same as agreeing with what he did next. Pulling a person out of a car by the neck, head first, beside moving traffic, could easily have ended with a head injury or with the passenger stumbling into the lane. In most countries that would count as assault, and a professional driver could lose his licence or job over it.

There is also a proportion problem. Littering is usually punished with a fine. In the United States every state has an anti-litter law, with first-offence fines commonly starting around $200; in England and Wales it is an offence under the Environmental Protection Act 1990, typically handled with a fixed penalty notice. None of these systems treats a thrown bottle as grounds for physical force.

The clip is more useful as a reminder that two things can be true at once: the passenger behaved badly, and the response was dangerous. Applauding the most aggressive person in a video encourages more of the same.

Better ways to deal with a littering passenger

Taxi and rideshare drivers do have options that make the same point without risking anyone's safety:

  • Stop and say it plainly. Pulling over and asking the passenger to pick up what they threw often works, especially when the request is calm and public.
  • End the ride. Drivers can usually refuse to continue a trip with a passenger who behaves badly, and let them out at a safe spot rather than hurling them onto a verge.
  • Keep a bag in the car. Many littering passengers simply have nowhere to put their rubbish. A small bin or bag in the back removes the excuse.
  • Use the record. If a car has a dashcam, the footage can be reported to the taxi company or local authority, which can issue fines where the law allows.

For the rest of us, the lesson is simpler: keep your rubbish in the car until you reach a bin, and if you see a bottle on the roadside near your home, picking it up makes the next person less likely to drop theirs.

Sources: Dashcam video embedded from YouTube; stills from ViralHog footage; incident as reported in British media in November 2018. Background: Wikipedia: Dashcam; Wikipedia: Litter.

COMMENTS