
Is depression a choice? No. Depression is a medical condition, and the idea that people can simply decide to stop being depressed is one of the most common and most hurtful myths about it. In November 2017 the comedian Andy Richter, best known as Conan O'Brien's long-time sidekick, answered that myth on Twitter with a frank account of his own life with depression. His thread was shared tens of thousands of times, and the replies turned into a small public conversation about what the illness actually feels like.
The tweet that started it
Richter has been on television since 1993, when he joined Late Night with Conan O'Brien as sidekick and writer. He went on to co-host The Tonight Show with Conan O'Brien and the TBS show Conan until 2021. Away from the jokes, he had rarely gone into detail about his mental health until a four-word post caught his eye.

The selfie above, with Richter's unimpressed face and a blue-headed parrot on his shoulder, became the picture that news sites used to illustrate the exchange.

On 12 November 2017 a Twitter user posted just "depression is a choice". The post gained some attention on its own, but it reached a far bigger audience five days later, when Richter quoted it.

His first reply on 17 November was a blunt, profane one-liner turning the "choice" logic back on its author. It collected around 155,000 likes, and he followed it with a longer thread explaining why the remark had made him angry.
What Richter said about living with depression

Richter admitted that answering a stranger's tweet might look like an easy target, but said he had pulled his car over after the school run to reply because he was angry.

He then described the illness itself. "I have been followed by an ever-present amorphous sadness for almost my entire life," he wrote, adding that he was 51. On good days it is a quiet suspicion that he will never feel the joy other people find in a sunset; on bad days it becomes a feeling that being dead might be a relief. That range, from a muted background sadness to dark thoughts, is something many people with depression recognise.

Crucially, he described the treatment he relies on. "I've been on meds for decades. I'm a devout believer in the talking cure of therapy," he wrote, and he called them life-saving. He listed what he has: a successful career, a long marriage and two children he loves. His point was that depression does not go away because life looks good from the outside.

He still expected to walk through most of his life with what he called an emotional limp. He was clear that he does not wallow or blame anyone: it is simply bad luck, in the same way that some people are born with a weak heart or poor eyesight.

Next he translated the slogan. Telling someone depression is a choice, he argued, really means telling them their pain is their own fault, that they could fix it by trying harder, and that their suffering is inconvenient to the speaker.

His closing advice was aimed at anyone who has never experienced it. "If you are unburdened by depression, real true depression, count yourself lucky," he wrote, before urging people to keep quick fixes to themselves, learn first and then speak, because careless messages like this can cost lives.


Later that evening he thanked people for the kindness in the replies, saying it was why he stayed on the platform at all. He also corrected one detail with a joke: he had added four years to his marriage, which was 23 years old at the time, not 27. Richter married writer and actress Sarah Thyre in 1994; the couple announced their separation in 2019.
How other people with depression responded
Thousands of replies came in, many from people describing their own experience for the first time in public.



Singer Richard Marx said he related and called Richter's description the best he had ever heard. Others wrote that they felt sorry for anyone who believed depression was a choice, or shared that they had fought depression for thirty years and wished they could simply "look on the bright side".



One person remembered life before depression and anxiety and said nobody would choose this. A nurse compared chronic depression to diabetes, a medical condition that can relapse even with treatment. Another reply asked who would ever choose to feel unhappy, disconnected and overwhelmed.



Some used comparison: people choose depression, one wrote, about as much as they choose their sexuality. Another admitted that he used to think sufferers just needed to snap out of it until friends showed him otherwise. A third said music was the one thing that kept him going in his darkest years.



A man recalled his father telling him as a teenager that happiness is not for everyone, and said the depression Richter described had followed him ever since. Others thanked Richter for finding words for feelings they had never managed to express, and a father wrote that his biggest fear was feeling like this forever while his family had to cope with it.





Comment threads elsewhere picked up the same themes. People pointed out how often depression is confused with an occasional sad day, compared "just stay positive" to telling someone with an empty tank to just start the car, and described depression as constant rather than a passing mood: a numbness in which you know what you should feel but cannot feel it.
What the medical evidence says
The US National Institute of Mental Health describes depression, also called major depressive disorder or clinical depression, as an illness that can cause severe symptoms affecting how a person feels, thinks and handles daily activities. It can affect anyone, regardless of age, income or background. NIMH notes that ordinary sadness usually passes with time, while depression is a different thing: an illness that needs treatment.
Research points to a mix of causes: genetic, biological, environmental and psychological factors all play a part. One of the replies above described depression as a chemical imbalance in the brain. That phrase was common for years, but many researchers now regard it as an oversimplification; brain chemistry is involved, but it is only one part of a more complicated picture.
The encouraging part is that depression is treatable. NIMH lists talk therapy, medication and, for some people whose depression has not responded to other treatment, brain stimulation therapies. Richter's own description of decades of medication plus therapy is a typical long-term approach, and it shows that treatment often manages the condition rather than switching it off.
Common myths, and better things to say
- "Just think positive." Depression changes how thoughts and feelings work. Positivity is not a switch a person is refusing to flip.
- "You have a good life, so what is there to be depressed about?" Richter's thread is a clear answer: success, love and family do not make a person immune.
- "Needing medication is weakness." Treatment choices should be made with a doctor, and for many people medication and therapy are what keep them well.
If someone tells you they are depressed, simple words help more than advice. "I'm glad you told me", "That sounds really hard" and "Would it help if I came with you to see a doctor?" do not fix anything, but they make it easier for a person to seek help. If you think you might be depressed, talk to a doctor. If you or someone you know is in crisis or thinking about suicide, contact emergency services; in the United States you can call or text 988, the Suicide and Crisis Lifeline.
Image sources: Andy Richter, _asiastabler
Sources: Tweets by Andy Richter (17 November 2017); Upworthy, 17 November 2017; NIMH: Depression; Wikipedia: Andy Richter.

He said what I feel all the time.
ReplyDelete