Iceland's Banned Rang-tan Christmas Advert: Why Clearcast Said No

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-11-25.

Iceland's Rang-tan Christmas Advert and the 2018 Broadcast Decision

The short answer: Iceland's 2018 Christmas advert was not refused because of anything it showed. The animated film, Rang-tan, had been made by Greenpeace, and Clearcast, the body that vets adverts before UK broadcast, would not approve it because it was tied to an organisation it treated as political. Television rules in Britain forbid political advertising, so the film never ran in an ad break. It went online instead, where tens of millions of people watched it within weeks.

What follows explains what the film is about, why the rule exists, how the story played out, and what the palm oil debate looks like once the noise of a viral moment fades.

What the Rang-tan film shows

Rang-tan is a ninety-second cartoon in the style of a picture book. A young orangutan turns up in a little girl's bedroom, swinging from the curtains, throwing her toys about and refusing to leave. When the girl asks why it is there, the orangutan explains that people destroyed its forest to grow oil palms, and that its mother is gone. The girl ends the film promising to tell the world.

The narration is by actor Emma Thompson, who is heard but never seen. Greenpeace UK released the film in August 2018 as part of its campaign against "dirty" palm oil, meaning oil grown on land cleared from rainforest and peatland.


Iceland's Rang-tan Christmas Advert and the 2018 Broadcast Decision
Iceland's Rang-tan Christmas Advert and the 2018 Broadcast Decision

The stills above come from the animation: the girl comforting the orangutan, and later holding up her hand-drawn sign that reads "Save my friend". The simple, warm style is deliberate. It lets a children's story carry a message about global supply chains without a single graphic image.

Why Iceland wanted it as a Christmas advert

Iceland, the British frozen food chain, had already made palm oil part of its brand. In April 2018 it announced it would remove palm oil from all of its own-label products, which made it the first major UK supermarket to take that step. Using Greenpeace's film as its festive television spot was meant to push the same message to a far bigger audience.

Christmas adverts are a big deal in Britain. Retailers such as John Lewis spend heavily on them, and people discuss them like new films. Iceland's founder, Malcolm Walker, reportedly said of Rang-tan: "It would have blown the John Lewis ad out of the window." Whether or not that is true, the chain clearly saw it as its best shot at a seasonal talking point.

Why Clearcast would not clear it

Clearcast is an industry body owned by the major commercial broadcasters. It checks adverts against the BCAP Code, the rulebook for broadcast advertising in the UK. That code follows the Communications Act 2003, which bans political advertising on television and radio. The idea behind the ban is that wealthy groups should not be able to buy airtime to sway political debates.

The rule covers more than election material. An advert can fall foul of it if it is placed by, or on behalf of, a body whose objects are wholly or mainly political, and Greenpeace's campaigning to change laws and corporate policy put it in that category for broadcast purposes. A Clearcast spokeswoman said it was "concerned that it doesn't comply with the political rules of the BCAP code," adding that the organisation linked to the film had not been able to show compliance.

In other words, the issue was who made the film rather than what it depicted. Clearcast did not rule that the orangutan story was untrue, offensive or harmful. That distinction matters: a broadcast refusal says nothing either way about whether the environmental claims in an advert are accurate.

From "banned" to viral

Iceland announced on social media on 9 November 2018 that its Christmas advert would not be on television, and posted the film for people to share. Calling it "banned" was technically loose, since Clearcast had refused clearance rather than issued a ban, but the word did its job. Celebrities including James Corden, Julia Bradbury and Ralf Little shared it, and coverage spread far beyond the advertising trade press.


This commercial was banned from TV for being too political. I think everyone should see it x pic.twitter.com/ns2XnGSnv6

— James Corden (@JKCorden) November 11, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)



Within days the film had passed 30 million online views, according to industry coverage at the time, and a fundraising case study later put the total above 65 million by early December 2018. A Change.org petition asking for the advert to be shown on TV collected hundreds of thousands of signatures, and Greenpeace's own palm oil petition reached around 1.2 million UK signatures by early 2019.

Some marketing writers argued the refusal was the best thing that could have happened to Iceland, since a "forbidden" advert travels faster than a paid one. Others questioned whether the chain had expected the outcome. Iceland denied any stunt, and there is no evidence it planned the refusal. Either way, the episode shows how a regulatory decision can amplify a message it was meant to keep off the air.

Palm oil and orangutans: what the evidence says

Palm oil is the most widely used vegetable oil in the world. It turns up in biscuits, margarine, instant noodles, shampoo, soap and detergents, often under names such as palmitate or sodium laureth sulphate derived from palm. Its appeal is simple: oil palms yield far more oil per hectare than soy, rapeseed or sunflower.

The problem lies in where it is grown. Much of the expansion since the 1990s took place in Indonesia and Malaysia, including on Borneo and Sumatra, the only places where wild orangutans live. Clearing forest and draining peat swamps for plantations destroys orangutan habitat, releases large amounts of carbon and opens remote areas to hunters.

The Bornean orangutan has been listed as Critically Endangered by the IUCN since 2016, with roughly 104,700 thought to remain in the wild. Habitat loss, including plantation expansion, is a leading threat, alongside fires, illegal logging, hunting and the pet trade. The figure of "25 orangutans lost every day", quoted widely in 2018 and repeated in tweets about the advert, was a campaign estimate; it is hard to verify and should be read as a rough indication of scale rather than a precise count.

Is avoiding palm oil the answer?

Not necessarily, and this is a common misunderstanding. Because oil palms are so productive, replacing them with other oil crops could need much more land, shifting the damage elsewhere. Many conservation groups therefore push for palm oil that is genuinely deforestation-free and traceable, rather than an outright boycott. Certification schemes exist, but campaigners argue they have been unevenly enforced.

That debate was already running when the advert appeared. Back in 2010, members of the Consumer Goods Forum, a network of large manufacturers and retailers, pledged to reach zero net deforestation in their supply chains by 2020. Greenpeace's campaign was largely about holding brands to that promise, which most did not fully meet.

What a shopper can actually do

  • Read labels with context. In the UK and EU, palm oil in food must be named on the ingredients list, but in cosmetics and cleaning products it often hides behind chemical names.
  • Look for credible sourcing claims. A brand that publishes where its palm oil comes from, down to mill level, is usually more trustworthy than one using vague green wording.
  • Think about scale. Single purchases matter less than pressure on large buyers, which is why campaigns target multinational companies rather than individual households.
  • Support habitat protection. Orangutan rescue and forest conservation groups in Borneo and Sumatra work directly on the ground.

Why the story still matters

Rang-tan has become a textbook case in marketing courses, both for its emotional storytelling and for the way a refused broadcast turned into free publicity. It also highlights a real tension in British media law: charities and pressure groups can speak freely online and in print, yet are largely shut out of paid television and radio airtime. Greenpeace later made a follow-up film in the same style, featuring a jaguar in a boy's kitchen, aimed at meat and soy supply chains.

For anyone searching for the "banned Iceland advert", the key points are simple. The film is about deforestation for palm oil. It was refused for broadcast because of its link to a political campaigning body, not because of its content. And the underlying problem it describes is real, even if some of the numbers circulated at the time were rough campaign estimates.

Iceland: Website | Facebook | Instagram | Twitter | YouTube

Sources: Film by Greenpeace UK, narrated by Emma Thompson; Iceland campaign with agency Mother. SOFII: Rang-tan case study; Campaign: Rang-tan ad hits 30m online views; Wikipedia: Iceland (supermarket); Wikipedia: Bornean orangutan; Clearcast.

COMMENTS