The Harp Twins' Cover of Metallica's One, Played on One Harp

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
The Harp Twins Cover Metallica's One

The Harp Twins are Camille and Kennerly Kitt, American identical twins who arrange rock and metal songs for two harps. Their cover of Metallica's "One", released as a video in 2015, stands out even in their catalogue because both sisters play a single harp at the same time, sharing the strings between four hands. You can watch it below, followed by the story of the song, the sisters and how a 1980s thrash epic ends up on a concert harp.

Watch the Harp Twins play "One"

The performance opens quietly, much as the original does, and the harp suits that first half surprisingly well. Metallica's song begins with clean, melancholy guitar arpeggios before building into heavy riffs, and the plucked strings of a harp naturally carry that fragile, ringing quality. As the song gathers pace, the twins have to suggest the drive of drums and distorted guitars using only attack, rhythm and the low bass strings.

When the video came out, the sisters explained the idea in a few words to the music site Louder: they wanted to discover how much they could draw out of a single harp played by both of them at once. Their verdict, in their own words: "We had to invent some new techniques, but the answer is… a lot."

The song behind the cover

"One" appeared on …And Justice for All, Metallica's fourth studio album, released in 1988. James Hetfield and Lars Ulrich wrote the music, and Hetfield wrote the lyrics. The song is told from the point of view of a First World War soldier left blind, deaf, mute and unable to move after a landmine explosion, trapped inside his own body.

Its theme overlaps with Johnny Got His Gun, Dalton Trumbo's 1939 anti-war novel and his 1971 film adaptation. Metallica used clips from the film in their black-and-white music video, which premiered on MTV in January 1989. The band later bought the rights to the film so that they would not have to keep paying royalties to show the video.

The track runs nearly seven and a half minutes on the album, yet it became one of the band's biggest songs. It reached number 35 on the US Billboard Hot 100 and number 13 in the UK, and in 1990 it won the first ever Grammy Award for Best Metal Performance.

Who are Camille and Kennerly Kitt?

The Kitt sisters began on piano as children and switched to harp in junior high school. They paid for their first instrument, a used lever harp, with money earned from babysitting and dog walking. Both went on to earn Bachelor of Music degrees in harp performance from the Wheaton College Conservatory of Music, graduating with highest honours.

Although classically trained, they built their following online by arranging contemporary music for harp duet. Their cover of "Nothing Else Matters", another Metallica song, came out in 2012, and their version of Ozzy Osbourne's "Crazy Train" followed in 2014. Over the years they have recorded songs by Iron Maiden, Pink Floyd, Coldplay, Enya and many more, along with themes from film, television and video games, and they have released a long series of albums, including the Harp Attack rock-and-metal records and the Harp Fantasy soundtrack collections.

A few less expected details round out the picture. The sisters represented the United States at the World Harp Festival in Asunción, Paraguay, in 2014, they have had small acting roles, and both are former Taekwondo instructors with third-degree black belts.

How do you turn a metal song into a harp duet?

The harp is not an obvious instrument for metal. A concert pedal harp usually has 47 strings, seven per octave, spanning about six and a half octaves. Seven pedals at its base each change one note name in every octave at once, which makes the instrument excellent for sweeping chords and scales in a key, but awkward for music full of chromatic movement. Metal riffs often lean on exactly those half-step shifts, so an arranger has to plan pedal changes carefully or find alternative notes that keep the character of the line.

The twins play both large concert pedal harps and electric lever harps. On a lever harp, the player flips small levers on individual strings by hand to raise their pitch, which offers another way around the instrument's limits.

In an interview about their process, the sisters described starting each arrangement by listening to the original repeatedly, building the melodic framework first and then sorting out the other parts. They often keep adjusting even while memorising a piece. They also stressed that they avoid overdubs, loops and backing tracks, so whatever you hear comes from two harps live. One line sums up their approach: "There is something very beautiful to us in stripping a song down to its essence and building again from there."

What to listen for

  • How the low strings take over the role of bass guitar and kick drum in the heavier second half.
  • Where the sisters let notes ring and where they damp them, the harp's version of palm-muting.
  • How a guitar solo becomes a run of fast, plucked notes rather than a sustained, distorted line.

Another favourite: Megadeth's "A Tout le Monde"

Metallica is not the only metal band in the twins' repertoire. Their version of Megadeth's "A Tout le Monde", originally from the 1994 album Youthanasia, shows how well a slower, melodic metal ballad fits the harp, with its French-language chorus carried by bright upper strings.

Covers like these have drawn mixed reactions. Many metal fans and musicians enjoy hearing a familiar song in a new texture, and outlets such as CBS News have praised the twins' arrangements. Some academic writers have argued that the harp's angelic, gentle image is part of what makes the contrast with heavy music so marketable. Both views can be true: the appeal lies partly in surprise and partly in genuine musicianship.

If you enjoyed these, their YouTube channel holds hundreds of arrangements spanning rock, metal, folk and soundtrack music, from Iron Maiden and Deep Purple to Fleetwood Mac and Cyndi Lauper.

Sources: Louder, 1 September 2015: Metallica's One covered by Harp Twins; Wikipedia: Camille and Kennerly; Wikipedia: One (Metallica song); Wikipedia: Pedal harp. Videos by Camille and Kennerly Kitt on YouTube.

Related articles

COMMENTS