Originally published 2018-10-11.

Bipolar
Can taking more holiday time really help you live longer? One long-running Finnish study is often quoted as proof that it does. The honest answer is more interesting: in one specific group of middle-aged men at risk of heart disease, those who took three weeks or less of vacation a year were more likely to die over the following three decades. That is a real finding, but it is an association in a subgroup, not a guarantee for everyone.
Here is what the Helsinki Businessmen Study did, what it found, what it did not find, and what sensible lessons it offers about rest and stress.
What the study found
The results were presented at the European Society of Cardiology (ESC) Congress in Munich on 28 August 2018 by Professor Timo Strandberg of the University of Helsinki. According to the ESC, among men who had received an intensive heart-health programme, those with three weeks or less of annual vacation had a 37% higher chance of dying between 1974 and 2004 than men who took more than three weeks.
Crucially, vacation length made no difference in the comparison group of men who received ordinary care. So the headline number does not describe "people" in general. It describes one arm of a trial, made up of a particular kind of man, at a particular time.
Who was in the Helsinki Businessmen Study
The study recruited 1,222 male executives, born between 1919 and 1934, in 1974 and 1975. Every one of them had at least one cardiovascular risk factor, such as smoking, high blood pressure, high cholesterol, raised triglycerides, glucose intolerance or excess weight.
The men were randomly split into two groups for five years:
- Intervention group (612 men): seen every four months and advised on exercise, diet, weight and quitting smoking. If advice was not enough, they were also given the blood pressure and cholesterol drugs available at the time.
- Control group (610 men): left to their usual healthcare and not seen by the researchers.
Researchers then followed the men's health and deaths through national registers for decades, eventually reaching 2014.
The surprise: more care, more deaths
At first, the programme looked like a success. By the end of the five-year trial, estimated cardiovascular risk in the intervention group had fallen by 46%.
Yet when the team looked again 15 years later, in 1989, there had been more deaths in the intervention group than among the controls. That puzzling gap persisted until 2004, after which death rates in the two groups were about the same.
The vacation analysis was an attempt to understand this paradox. When the researchers dug into data collected at the start, they found the excess deaths in the intervention group were concentrated among men who took shorter holidays. Those men also tended to work longer hours and sleep less.

David Sacks
Strandberg's interpretation was that a high-pressure lifestyle may have cancelled out the benefits of the medical advice, and that the intense programme itself may have added psychological stress. As he put it in the ESC release: "Vacations can be a good way to relieve stress."
He was careful to add that the results do not mean health education is harmful. Stress management simply was not part of heart-disease prevention in the 1970s, and today's drugs, such as statins and modern blood pressure medicines, are very different from those the men received.
What this study cannot tell you
It is easy to turn this research into a slogan, so it helps to be precise about its limits.
- It is observational on the vacation question. The men were randomised to receive health advice, not to take more or less holiday. Men who took short vacations may have differed in many other ways, such as job type, personality, finances or existing health.
- The sample is narrow. All participants were Finnish, male, white-collar, middle-aged and already at risk of heart disease, and they were living in the 1970s. Women, younger people and today's workers were not studied.
- It applies to one group only. In the control group, vacation length showed no link with survival.
- "37% more likely to die young" is a simplification. The figure refers to the chance of dying during a 30-year follow-up in that subgroup, not to an average loss of years for everyone who skips a holiday.
None of this means the finding is worthless. It is a useful signal that fits with a wider body of research linking chronic work stress, long hours and poor sleep to heart problems. It simply should not be read as proof that a holiday adds a fixed amount of life.
What other research says about rest and health
The Helsinki study fits a broader picture about overwork. In May 2021 the World Health Organization and the International Labour Organization published the first global estimate of deaths linked to long working hours. They found that working 55 or more hours a week was associated with about a 35% higher risk of stroke and a 17% higher risk of dying from ischaemic heart disease, compared with a 35 to 40 hour week. They estimated that 745,000 deaths from stroke and heart disease in 2016 were linked to long hours.
At the same time, many people notice that the relaxed feeling of a trip wears off soon after they are back at their desks, and some research on holiday wellbeing reportedly points the same way. That points to a practical idea: regular breaks, and a working life that is sustainable between them, may matter more than one big annual escape.

Alistair Berg
Practical takeaways
- Use the leave you have. Many workers leave paid days unused. Spreading them through the year can give more frequent recovery.
- Rest does not have to mean travel. The benefit researchers point to is time away from work stress, which can happen at home, in nature or with family.
- Protect sleep. In the Helsinki data, shorter holidays went together with less sleep and more work, a combination worth watching in your own life.
- Do not trade one for the other. A holiday does not cancel out smoking, inactivity or unmanaged blood pressure. Healthy habits and genuine rest work best together.
- Talk to a doctor if stress, sleep problems or heart risk factors are worrying you.
The World Economic Forum shared a short video summary of the study when it made headlines:
The fairest summary is this: for a group of stressed, at-risk Finnish executives, short holidays went hand in hand with a higher risk of dying earlier. It is a good reason to take your time off seriously, not a magic formula for a longer life.
Sources: European Society of Cardiology press release, 28 August 2018: Take a vacation, it could prolong your life; WHO/ILO, 17 May 2021: Long working hours increasing deaths from heart disease and stroke. Photos credited as in the original post (Bipolar, David Sacks, Alistair Berg); video by the World Economic Forum.

Nice Article. Great information. To know more about health information you can visit cialisforsalecialiscostcye.com
ReplyDelete