Are Short Men More Aggressive? What the Research Really Says

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-10-15.

Men Who Feel Less Masculine Are More Likely to Be Violent, Study Says

Headlines in 2018 claimed that "new research" proved short people get angrier and more violent than tall ones. That is not what the research showed. The study behind the story, run by scientists at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), never measured height at all. It looked at something more interesting: men who feel they fall short of what a "real man" is supposed to be, and who are stressed about it.

Those men did report more violence. Height, on the other hand, has a much weaker and messier link to aggression than the "short man syndrome" stereotype suggests. Here is what each line of research found, and what it does and does not mean.

The CDC study on "masculine discrepancy stress"

The research, led by CDC behavioural scientist Dennis Reidy and published in the journal Injury Prevention in 2015, was based on an online survey carried out in 2012. About 600 American men aged 18 to 50 answered questions about how masculine they felt compared with the average man, whether that bothered them, and whether they had used drugs or alcohol, driven while drunk or been violent.

The researchers separated two ideas. Gender role discrepancy is simply seeing yourself as less stereotypically masculine than other men. Discrepancy stress is the worry that comes with it: fearing that others see you as not manly enough.

Men who felt less masculine but were not troubled by it were actually among the least likely to report violence or drunk driving. The trouble showed up in men who were anxious about it. According to Live Science's report on the study, those with high discrepancy stress reported assaults that caused injury at a rate about 348 percent higher than men with low stress. Earlier coverage summarised this as "nearly three times more likely"; the broad point is the same. The authors suggested that easing this kind of stress could, in turn, help prevent violence.

Why feeling "not man enough" might lead to violence

The study did not test causes, but the researchers and other psychologists offer a plausible explanation. In cultures where toughness and dominance are seen as core parts of manhood, a man who fears he is falling short may try to prove himself in the most visible way available. Fighting, risk-taking and aggression can be ways of repairing a bruised sense of identity in front of others.

This fits a wider body of research on "precarious manhood", the idea that manhood is often treated as a status that must be earned and can be lost, unlike womanhood, which is more often treated as a given. When that status feels threatened, some men respond with displays of strength.

Importantly, the findings point to pressure and expectations, not to anything fixed about a man's body or personality. That is good news, because expectations can change.

What the Oxford "short man" experiment found

The height part of the 2018 story came from a separate study. In January 2014 Oxford psychologist Daniel Freeman and colleagues used virtual reality to simulate a London Underground ride. Participants took the journey twice, once at their normal height and once with their viewpoint lowered so they felt noticeably shorter (by roughly a head, according to press reports).

When they were "shorter", people felt more negative about themselves and were more mistrustful of others in the carriage. They were more likely to think that fellow passengers were staring at them or talking about them. Freeman's team linked this to feelings of inferiority, and wrote about how height and confidence seem to be connected.

What the experiment did not show is that short people are more violent. It measured paranoid thoughts during a short virtual trip, not aggression or behaviour in real life. The fact-checking site Lead Stories rated the 2018 headline false for exactly this reason: it combined two older studies, neither of which tested whether shorter people are more violent.

The variable studied matters more than the viral stereotype

Is "Napoleon complex" real?

The "Napoleon complex", also called short man syndrome, is the popular belief that shorter men compensate for their size by being aggressive or domineering. Psychologists generally treat it as a stereotype, and the evidence is mixed:

  • Some support: a 2018 study by Mark van Vugt's team at Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam found that shorter men behaved more indirectly aggressively toward taller opponents in competitive laboratory games. Research by Abraham Buunk at the University of Groningen linked shorter height in men with more jealousy.
  • Some against: a 2007 experiment at the University of Central Lancashire had men take part in a stick-fighting exercise in which their knuckles were deliberately rapped. The taller men were the ones more likely to lose their temper. The long-running Wessex Growth Study found no height-related differences in personality or everyday functioning.
  • A useful twist: more recent work has suggested that unhappiness with one's height predicts antagonistic traits better than height itself.

That last finding brings the two lines of research together. In both cases, what seems to matter is how a man feels about falling short of an ideal, not the number on a measuring tape.

How tall was Napoleon, really?

The man who gave the complex its name was not especially short. Napoleon's height was recorded as 5 feet 2 inches in old French units, which translates to roughly 1.67 to 1.70 metres, or about 5 feet 6 or 7 inches in modern measures. That was around average, or slightly above, for a Frenchman of his time.

The myth owes a lot to British propaganda. Cartoonist James Gillray and others drew Napoleon as a tiny, tantrum-throwing figure to mock him during the wars with France, and the image stuck long after the facts were forgotten.

Watch: the viral video version

The claim spread widely through short videos like the ones below. They are worth watching with the context above in mind: the studies they draw on are real, but the conclusion that short people are more violent goes beyond what either study found.


What to take away

  • Height does not predict violence in any reliable way. Judging someone's temper by their size is a stereotype, not science.
  • Pressure to "be a man" can be harmful. Men who feel anxious about not living up to tough-guy ideals reported more violence in the CDC survey.
  • Surveys show links, not causes. The CDC data were self-reported and taken at one point in time, so they cannot prove that stress causes violence.
  • Change is possible. Broader, healthier ideas of what it means to be a man may reduce the stress that seems to fuel some aggression. Anyone struggling with anger or feeling unsafe can talk to a doctor or a qualified counsellor.

Sources: Reidy et al.: Masculine discrepancy stress, substance use, assault and injury in a survey of US men (PMC); Live Science, 26 August 2015: Insecure men may be more prone to violence; University of Oxford Department of Psychiatry: Short man syndrome; Lead Stories, October 2018 fact-check; Wikipedia: Napoleon complex.

COMMENTS