Caroline Power's Sea of Plastic Photos Off Roatán, Honduras

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Caroline Power's Plastic-Pollution Photos Near Roatán

In the autumn of 2017, underwater photographer Caroline Power was out on a dive boat off Roatán, an island in the Bay Islands of Honduras, when the crew motored into a floating carpet of rubbish. Plastic bottles, bags, food containers, cutlery, flip-flops and tangled seaweed stretched towards the horizon. Her photos, posted on Facebook in October 2017, went viral within days and became some of the most widely shared images of ocean plastic of that year.

The pictures matter because of where they were taken. Roatán sits on the Mesoamerican Reef, the largest barrier reef system in the Western Hemisphere, and its clear water is the reason divers travel there. Seeing that water covered in waste made an abstract global problem very concrete. This article looks at what the photos show, where the rubbish came from, why it gathered there, and what the wider evidence says about plastic in the sea.

What Caroline Power photographed

Power lives on Roatán and photographs its reefs and marine life. According to her account and press reports at the time, the dive group came across the debris while heading out between Roatán and the nearby Cayos Cochinos islands. Reports described the patch as stretching for nearly five miles, with the worst of it about 15 miles off Roatán towards the Cayos Cochinos Marine Reserve; that length was never independently measured, so it is best treated as an estimate from the people on the boat.

Caroline Power's Plastic-Pollution Photos Near Roatán

A diver stands on the boat as it pushes through the debris. The surface looks almost solid, but it is a loose layer of floating objects mixed with brown sargassum seaweed, the kind of mat that forms where currents push surface material together.

Caroline Power's Plastic-Pollution Photos Near Roatán

Seen from below, the patch blocks the light like a ceiling. Bags, bottles and seaweed hang a short distance into the water. This view shows why floating plastic is a hazard to turtles, fish and seabirds, which can become entangled or mistake fragments for food.

Caroline Power's Plastic-Pollution Photos Near Roatán

A wider view shows the raft of rubbish running along the water in a long line. Floating debris often collects in bands like this where two water masses meet, which is why patches can look endless from a small boat.

Caroline Power's Plastic-Pollution Photos Near Roatán

Close up, the patch is full of everyday disposable items: plastic forks and spoons, cups and food packaging. These were the objects Power highlighted in her post. Photos: Caroline Power.

In the post that accompanied the photos, Power opened with “THIS HAS TO STOP” and asked readers to think about their own routines: the takeaway box, the plastic fork, the bags for fruit and vegetables, the toilet roll wrapped in film. Her point was not that one diver's photos could explain the whole problem, but that each of these items had to end up somewhere.

Where the rubbish came from

The patch was not a permanent island. It was a pulse of waste washed out to sea, mostly from the mainland. In November 2017, Power told the news agency AFP that she believed one of the main sources was rivers on the mainland of Honduras and Guatemala, while noting that some of it could have come from anywhere in Central America or the Caribbean. She also stressed that the patch she saw was “tiny compared to the ones in the Atlantic and Pacific oceans”.

At the same time, waste was washing ashore on Honduras's northern coast around the town of Omoa. Local officials blamed rubbish dumped into rivers on the Guatemalan side of the border. Omoa's mayor, Ricardo Alvarado, told AFP that the town had filled 20 dump trucks in a single day, which barely changed what was still on the beach.

The river most often named is the Motagua, which drains a large part of Guatemala, including areas near Guatemala City, and empties into the Gulf of Honduras close to the border. After the 2017 images, the issue became a diplomatic one. Guatemala's foreign minister, Sandra Jovel, met Honduran officials, and Guatemala's environment minister, Sydney Samuels, promised a waste-handling plant on the Motagua costing about 1.6 million dollars. A treatment plant on its own cannot stop this kind of pollution if rubbish is still dumped into streams upstream, which is why waste collection in the river basin remains the real issue.

The BBC also covered the story at the time, with Power's footage of the patch:

Why the Caribbean collects floating waste

The Gulf of Honduras is a natural trap. Rivers carry waste down from the highlands during the rainy season, especially after storms, and coastal currents and winds then hold the floating material in the bay. Plastic that would be widely dispersed in the open ocean can pile up close to shore.

Sargassum makes the patches more visible. This free-floating brown seaweed has arrived in the Caribbean in much larger amounts since about 2011, and it gathers along the same lines as floating rubbish. In Power's photos, much of the brown material is seaweed, with the plastic woven through it. The mix is a problem twice over: rotting sargassum releases gases and smothers beaches, while the plastic stays long after the seaweed breaks down.

For reef islands like Roatán the stakes are high. Tourism, fishing and diving depend on clean water. Plastic can scratch and smother coral, carry microbes, and break into tiny pieces that enter the food chain. A scene like the one in these photos is short-lived, but the fragments it leaves behind are not.

How big is the ocean plastic problem?

The scale is large but often misunderstood. A widely cited 2015 study led by Jenna Jambeck, published in Science, estimated that between about 5 and 13 million tonnes of plastic entered the ocean from coastal countries in 2010. Later studies have refined those numbers, but they agree that the main driver is mismanaged waste: rubbish that is never collected, or is dumped or burned in the open.

Rivers are the main route from land to sea. A 2021 study in Science Advances by Lourens Meijer and colleagues estimated that more than 1,000 rivers, many of them small and urban, carry about 80 percent of the plastic that rivers deliver to the ocean. The Motagua case fits that picture: a single river basin, with limited waste collection upstream, can send huge amounts of plastic to a coast many miles away.

Common myths about ocean plastic

There are solid plastic islands you can walk on. No. Even the Great Pacific Garbage Patch is, by count, mostly a thin soup of small fragments spread over a vast area, although larger items, above all lost fishing nets, make up most of its weight. The patch in Power's photos was unusually dense because it was close to a river mouth and freshly washed out.

Recycling will solve it. Only a small share of plastic waste worldwide is recycled; the OECD has put it at around 9 percent. Recycling helps, but reducing single-use plastic and collecting waste properly in the first place matter more.

Plastic in the sea is only one country's problem. Waste travels on currents and is traded across borders. The Honduras and Guatemala dispute showed how quickly a local waste problem becomes an international one.

What actually helps

Power's post focused on personal habits, and those do add up. Carrying a reusable bottle, bag and cup, refusing plastic cutlery with takeaway food, and choosing products with less packaging all cut down the amount of waste that needs managing.

But the evidence points to bigger levers too. Waste collection in places that lack it, barriers that catch rubbish in rivers before it reaches the sea, deposit schemes for bottles and cans, and limits on the most common single-use items have all been shown to reduce leakage. A number of Central American and Caribbean governments have introduced bans on plastic bags or foam food containers since 2017.

If you visit coastal places, beach and reef clean-ups organised by local dive centres and conservation groups are a direct way to help, and the data they collect on what is found is used by researchers. Power's photos were a snapshot of one bad day on one stretch of water. Their lasting value is that they made a lot of people ask where their own rubbish goes.

Sources: Photographs and post by Caroline Power on Facebook (October 2017); AFP via The Citizen, 24 November 2017: ‘Trash islands’ off Central America indicate ocean pollution problem; The Civil Engineer and Global Citizen (October 2017); Wikipedia on the Mesoamerican Barrier Reef, the Motagua River, the Great Atlantic Sargassum Belt, marine plastic pollution and the Great Pacific Garbage Patch; Meijer et al., Science Advances (2021); OECD (2022); video: BBC News on Facebook.

Related articles

COMMENTS