
Deep under the oldest parts of the continents there may be far more diamond than anyone once imagined. In July 2018 a team that included MIT research scientist Ulrich Faul reported that the deep “roots” of ancient continental blocks could be roughly 1 to 2 percent diamond. Multiplied across the huge volume of that rock, the figure comes out at about 1016 tons of diamond, sitting some 90 to 150 miles (about 145 to 240 km) below our feet.
The short answer for anyone hoping for a diamond rush: nobody can reach it. The study is a model of what the deep Earth is made of, built from earthquake data and laboratory measurements. Nobody drilled down and found a hoard of gems, and the result says nothing about stones you could cut, polish or sell.
What the researchers actually claimed
The work was published in 2018 in the journal Geochemistry, Geophysics, Geosystems under the title “Multidisciplinary constraints on the abundance of diamond and eclogite in the cratonic lithosphere.” Its authors came from a long list of institutions, among them MIT, the University of California campuses at Santa Barbara and Berkeley, Harvard, the Carnegie Institution of Washington, the Institut de Physique du Globe de Paris, École Polytechnique, the University of Bayreuth, University College London, the University of Melbourne and the University of Science and Technology of China. Part of the funding came from the US National Science Foundation.
Their central claim is modest in wording and huge in scale. If a small fraction of diamond explains how seismic waves behave beneath old continents, then diamond is not a freak of nature but a fairly ordinary ingredient of the deep mantle. In MIT’s own announcement Faul put it plainly: “We can’t get at them, but still, there is much more diamond there than we have ever thought before.” The team suggested this means at least a thousand times more diamond than earlier expectations.
One detail is worth correcting. Some headlines, and MIT’s write-up itself, described the total as “a quadrillion” tons while printing the number as 1016. In the short-scale counting used in English, a quadrillion is 1015, so 1016 is closer to ten quadrillion tons. Either way, the figure is an order-of-magnitude estimate, not a precise count.
Cratons: the ancient keels of the continents
To see where this diamond is supposed to be, it helps to know what a craton is. Cratons are the oldest and most stable pieces of continental lithosphere, the rigid outer shell made of crust plus the top of the mantle. Most formed in the Archean eon, between about 4 and 2.5 billion years ago, and they usually sit in the interior of tectonic plates, away from the busy, mountain-building edges. The Kaapvaal craton in South Africa, the Superior craton in Canada and the Siberian craton are well-known examples.
What makes cratons special is depth. Ordinary lithosphere is around 100 km thick, but cratons have roots, sometimes called keels, that reach two or more times deeper into the mantle. Geologists often compare them to upside-down mountains: most of the mass lies hidden below. Those cold, thick roots have survived billions of years of plate tectonics, which is why they hold some of the oldest rock on Earth.
How sound waves pointed to diamond
Nobody can visit the mantle, so geophysicists listen to it. Every large earthquake sends seismic waves through the planet, and networks of instruments, including those run by the United States Geological Survey, record when the waves arrive. Because waves travel at different speeds through rocks of different temperature, density and composition, the timing works like a giant medical scan of Earth’s interior.
For years one result did not fit. Waves sped up noticeably when they passed through craton roots. Some extra speed was expected, since the roots are colder than the surrounding mantle, and cold rock carries seismic waves faster. But the measured speeds were higher than temperature alone could explain.
The team attacked the puzzle in two steps. Seismologists first built a three-dimensional model of wave speeds beneath the major cratons. Mineral physicists then used laboratory data on how fast sound moves through individual minerals to assemble “virtual rocks” with different recipes, and calculated the wave speed for each. Only one family of recipes matched the observations: mostly peridotite, the main rock of the upper mantle, with a little eclogite (a dense rock made from old ocean crust pushed down into the mantle) and 1 to 2 percent diamond.
Diamond made the difference because it is extraordinarily stiff. Faul explained that sound moves through it at more than twice the speed it travels through olivine, the dominant mineral of the upper mantle. A pinch of something that fast is enough to lift the average speed of the whole rock.
Why a little diamond would not sink a continent
A second test was density. Cratons survive because they are slightly lighter than the mantle around them, so they ride on top instead of being dragged down. Any proposed recipe had to keep that buoyancy. A few percent of diamond barely changes the overall density, so the roots stay light enough. Faul compared cratons to “pieces of wood, floating on water,” a simple way to picture why these blocks have lasted so long and preserved such old rock.
That fits a broader picture. Diamond forms under high pressure and temperature, conditions found roughly 150 km down and deeper. Diamonds that originate in craton roots are almost always more than 2 billion years old, and often more than 3 billion. Finding that the roots themselves hold a small share of diamond is, in that sense, less surprising than the headline number suggests.
How diamonds reach the surface
If diamond lives so deep, why can we buy it at all? The answer is a rare and violent kind of volcano. Kimberlite is an igneous rock that forms deep in the mantle, roughly 150 to 450 km down, and rises very fast, driven by carbon dioxide and other gases. As it punches upward it carries pieces of the mantle, sometimes including diamonds, and leaves behind carrot-shaped vertical “pipes.” The rock takes its name from Kimberley in South Africa, where the 1869 discovery of the Star of South Africa diamond set off a diamond rush.
Kimberlite eruptions are rare in geological time, and the known pipes tend to cluster on or near cratons, in places such as Canada, Australia, Siberia and southern Africa. By one count, around 6,400 kimberlite pipes are known, about 900 of them contain diamonds, and only around 30 have been mined. That is a useful reminder that even where nature has done the lifting, diamond worth recovering is scarce.
Common misreadings of the study
“Diamonds will become cheap”
No. The proposed diamond lies about 145 km down or deeper. The deepest hole ever drilled, Russia’s Kola Superdeep Borehole, stopped a little past 12 km. Jewelry prices depend on mines, supply chains and demand, none of which this research touches.
“Scientists found a diamond deposit”
Not in the mining sense. A deposit is a body of rock that can be located, measured and extracted. This is a composition estimate spread through enormous volumes of rock, and the study does not say whether the diamond would be in tiny grains or larger crystals.
“The number is settled”
It is one team’s best fit to the data. Seismic models carry uncertainty, and other combinations of temperature and composition may yet explain part of the speed-up. The value of the study lies in a testable idea: under deep-Earth conditions, a mineral we treat as precious may simply be common.
The short video below, shared by a science page on Facebook, illustrates the story for readers who prefer to watch.
Sources: MIT News, “Sound waves reveal diamond cache deep in Earth’s interior” (July 2018); Wikipedia: Craton; Wikipedia: Kimberlite; earlier coverage credited to techgear.gr.

COMMENTS