J35 (Tahlequah): The Orca Who Carried Her Dead Calf for 17 Days

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-09-17.

J35 the Orca and the Observations After Her Calf's Death

J35, also known as Tahlequah, is a Southern Resident killer whale who carried the body of her dead newborn calf for about 17 days in the summer of 2018, swimming an estimated 1,000 miles (1,600 km) through the waters between Washington state and British Columbia. The calf, born on 24 July 2018 off Victoria, lived for only about half an hour. Researchers watched J35 balance the small body on her head or snout, diving to retrieve it whenever it slipped away.

Her vigil became one of the most widely followed wildlife stories of the year. It also drew attention to a harder truth: the Southern Residents are an endangered population that had reportedly gone about three years without a calf surviving. Here is what was observed, what scientists can and cannot say about orca grief, and what has happened to J35 since.

What researchers saw in July and August 2018

The first reports, in late July, described a mother who simply would not let go. Over the following days whale watchers, researchers and boaters on the water kept spotting J35 with the calf. Taylor Shedd of Soundwatch, a Whale Museum programme that educates boaters about keeping their distance from orcas, told The Seattle Times: "It is just absolutely gut-wrenching to watch."

Early articles spoke of three days. In fact the vigil lasted far longer. By 8 August observers had counted 16 days, and around 11 August the Center for Whale Research confirmed that J35 had finally released the body and rejoined J pod. She looked thin during parts of the journey, which worried scientists, but afterwards she appeared to be in reasonable condition.


The circle of female orcas

On the evening the calf died, Lodie Budwill of the Center for Whale Research watched a group of female orcas gather around J35 and surface together in a tight ring near Eagle Cove, on the west side of San Juan Island. She told The Seattle Times the formation lasted at least two hours, continuing as the sun set and the moon rose over the water. She described it as a kind of ceremony and summed it up in one line: "It was no doubt a circle of family love and devotion."

Southern Resident orcas live in close-knit matrilineal groups. Sons and daughters typically stay with their mothers for life, and related females help one another with hunting and calf care. Seen in that light, the circle is not surprising, even if nobody can know exactly what the whales were experiencing.

Just heartbreaking.

— Tiffany Stahl (@TJoyStahl) July 26, 2018

(This post is no longer available on X.)


Do orcas grieve? What science can say

Mothers carrying dead calves has been recorded in many species of whales and dolphins, as well as in primates and elephants. Scientists sometimes use neutral terms such as "post-mortem attentive behaviour" to describe what they can measure: carrying, touching, staying close and guarding the body.

Whether this amounts to grief in the human sense is still debated. Some researchers argue that the behaviour reflects a strong bond and something like mourning; others caution that hormones, confusion or a lingering maternal drive could also play a part. Both views agree on the observable facts. What J35 did was physically costly: carrying a body slows a whale down and makes feeding harder, which is why her condition worried researchers. Reassuringly, telephoto images taken after the vigil showed her looking healthy.

A fair reading keeps the observations and the interpretation separate. We know she carried her calf for more than two weeks and that other females stayed close. Calling it grief is a reasonable, widely shared interpretation, not a measured fact.

Why the Southern Residents are in trouble

The Southern Residents are made up of three pods, known as J, K and L. They were listed as endangered in the United States in 2005 and are also protected as endangered in Canada. The population numbered 99 whales in 1995, but had fallen to 73 in the official census of July 2024.

Their history explains part of the decline. Between 1962 and 1977, dozens of orcas were captured or killed in the region for marine parks, and 48 of them were Southern Residents. That removed a generation of young whales.

Today scientists point to three main pressures:

  • Not enough food. Salmon make up almost all of their diet, and they depend especially on large, fatty Chinook salmon, several runs of which are themselves endangered.
  • Pollution. As top predators, orcas accumulate contaminants such as PCBs, DDT and flame retardants from the fish they eat. These chemicals are stored in fat and can affect immunity and reproduction, and mothers pass some of them to their calves through milk.
  • Vessel traffic and noise. Orcas hunt by echolocation, so busy shipping lanes and boats crowding around them make it harder to find prey.

The result shows up in the birth record. ScienceAlert, summarising research at the time, reported that about three-quarters of Southern Resident newborns over the previous two decades had failed to thrive, a pattern scientists linked largely to the salmon shortage.

Ken Balcomb, the founder of the Center for Whale Research, described J35's long vigil in very human terms at the time, as this widely shared clip shows.



What officials did next

Washington's governor, Jay Inslee, had already created a state Southern Resident orca task force by executive order in March 2018, a few months before J35's calf died. (Some early coverage dated the order to May; the task force was set up in March.) J35's story added public pressure to its work, and the group went on to recommend measures to increase Chinook numbers, reduce toxic pollution and limit disturbance from boats.

Ideas debated since then include restoring salmon habitat, changing hatchery and dam operations, cleaning up contaminated sediments, and requiring boats to keep a greater distance from the whales. Progress has been slow and some measures remain contested, but the orca's vigil gave the issue a face that people still remember.


J35's later calves

The story did not end in 2018. On 5 September 2020, J35 gave birth to a healthy male calf near the San Juan Islands. The Center for Whale Research named him J57, and the Whale Museum nicknamed him Phoenix.

In December 2024 she had another calf, a female designated J61. Observers reported the newborn on 20 December, but researchers were soon concerned about her condition, and she was declared dead on 31 December. On 1 January 2025 J35 was again seen carrying a dead calf, this time near Vashon Island in Puget Sound. That vigil lasted more than 11 days, and a sighting on 8 February 2025 confirmed she was no longer carrying the body.

J35 was born around 1998 to a female known as J17. Her first calf, J47, was born in 2010. Her life story reads almost like a summary of the population's struggles: some successes, painful losses and the constant question of whether there will be enough salmon.

How people can help

Most of the decisions that will determine the Southern Residents' future are made through salmon recovery, pollution control and shipping rules. Ordinary people can still play a part:

  • Support research and conservation groups such as the Center for Whale Research and the Orca Conservancy.
  • If you go whale watching in the Salish Sea, choose operators who follow the distance and speed rules, and respect them if you are on your own boat or kayak.
  • Keep chemicals, pesticides and plastics out of drains and waterways, since what washes into the sea ends up in the food chain.
  • Back salmon habitat restoration projects in your area; healthy rivers mean more food for the whales.

Sources: Wikipedia: Tahlequah (orca); Wikipedia: Southern resident orcas; The Seattle Times (July 2018); ScienceAlert (August 2018); original 2018 report via Upworthy.

COMMENTS