25 Crappy Design Fails: Signs, Stalls, Packaging and Placement

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Twenty-Five Design Mistakes Involving Layout, Placement and Context

Bad design is rarely about ugliness. Most of the photos below show objects that look perfectly normal on a drawing board and then fail the moment they meet the real world: a sign that is read from the wrong distance, a cake seen from the wrong angle, a toilet stall that offers everything except privacy. That is why they are funny, and also why they are useful.

The collection comes largely from r/CrappyDesign, a Reddit community where people post everyday objects that let their users down. We have grouped the 25 pictures by the kind of mistake they show, added a short explanation of what went wrong in each, and credited the person who shared it. A few may be staged or edited, as is common with viral photos, so treat them as illustrations of a design problem rather than as reports about a particular company.

Three questions explain almost every fail here. Who will use this, and where will they stand? What else will sit next to it? And what will it look like once it is folded, lit, mounted or photographed from an angle nobody planned for?

Signs and words that say the wrong thing

Text is the cheapest part of a design to change and the easiest to get wrong. Spacing, lighting and context can turn an honest message into a joke.

This Car Dealership Form

A paper "I'm not a robot" checkbox. The online CAPTCHA box exists to separate people from automated scripts. Printing it on a car-dealership form, to be ticked with a pen, keeps the look of the check and loses its whole purpose. Twitter user Marci Robin posted the form in May 2018 and the tweet was widely shared. Shared by MarciRobin.

I Felt Quite Lost In China, But Fortunately, I Found This Sign

"You are here", and nothing else. A locator sign is only useful next to a map or a list of destinations. This one, photographed in a large Chinese transit hall, announces the obvious in Chinese and English while the corridor stretches away with no clue about where it leads. Shared by 123Erik123.

I Just Wanted Some Gas

A fuel station that says DIE. When part of an illuminated sign fails, the letters that stay lit decide the message. Here "DIESEL" has lost its last three letters at night, which is a strong argument for checking signs after dark and for lighting words as single units. Shared by a Reddit user in r/evilbuildings.

Little Caesars Serves What?

"We serve people." The slogan was meant to say the restaurant cares about its customers, but splitting the second line from the first lets it read as a menu item. Short slogans need to be tested out loud, by someone who did not write them. Shared by googhosty.

That's A Wasp

Just bee yourself, says the wasp. The pun depends on a bee, yet the illustration shows the black and yellow bands, narrow waist and smooth body of a wasp. Insect-lovers spotted it at once; a quick look at a reference photo would have saved the joke. Shared by Ferosso.

Stopped In Wisconsin Today...and I’d Rather Not

EAT Jessica's. A vertical "EAT" sign stacked directly above a family restaurant name turns an invitation into an instruction about Jessica. The poster photographed it while passing through Wisconsin. Separating the two signs, or adding a single word, would have fixed it. Shared by Skwonkie_.

Packaging and print that undercut their own message

Printed matter travels. It gets wrapped, laid out next to other pages and seen in contexts the designer never imagined.

Twenty-Five Design Mistakes Involving Layout, Placement and Context

A plastic warning in plastic. National Geographic's June 2018 "Planet or Plastic?" cover showed a plastic bag floating like an iceberg. Subscribers then received the issue, here the Spanish edition, sealed in plastic film. The magazine said that year that it would move to paper wrapping, so the photo captures a real gap between message and logistics. Shared by dumbomb.

This News Paper From The Dominican Republic Used A Picture Of Alec Baldwin As Trump

Alec Baldwin as the president. On 10 February 2017 a Dominican newspaper illustrated a story about Donald Trump and Israeli settlements with a photo of Alec Baldwin in his Saturday Night Live impression. Image search makes this kind of mix-up easy, which is why picture desks check every portrait against a trusted source. Shared by Papa_pepper_513.

Happy Father's Day

A knife sale beside a tragedy. A newspaper page carries a court report about a man who killed his son and, directly underneath, a cheerful Father's Day advert for chef's knives. Ads and stories are usually placed by different teams, and this is what happens when nobody looks at the finished page together. Shared by KROXON.

I'm Really Sure There Must Be A Better Choice Of Dog Breed For This

A Dalmatian colouring page. Dalmatians are defined by their spots, and the spots are already printed. That leaves a child with almost nothing to colour except white dogs, a gentle reminder to think about what the user actually does with a product. Shared by TheJamster95.

Super Penetrate

The cartoon on a penetrating oil can. Lubricants that free rusted bolts are an honest product, but the brand name and the smiling bolt mascot on this can invite a very different reading. Product names deserve the same out-loud test as slogans. Shared by C0II1n.

This Gray-Scale Pie Chart

A grey pie chart with forty grey slices. Pie charts work only with a handful of clearly different categories. Printed in grayscale with dozens of nearly identical shades, this chart from a computer-security textbook cannot be matched to its legend at all. A sorted bar chart or a table would have shown the same data. Shared by g0jirasan.

Confused Bunny

The confused bunny. An "End Animal Testing" graphic places a small rabbit holding a "No" placard right under the slogan, so it seems to be protesting against its own rescue. When an image and a headline sit together, viewers read them as one sentence. Shared by NotRenton.

Bathrooms: where privacy is part of the job

Restroom design looks simple, but it has one non-negotiable requirement, and several of these fixtures miss it.

Class Stalls In Bathroom

Frosted glass stalls. Frosted glass looks modern and lets light through, which is exactly the problem: the silhouette of the person inside is perfectly visible. The poster's on-screen caption used a censored swear word, a fair summary of how users felt. Shared by Shiawase.

And You Really Thought The Other Glass Stall Was Bad

Clear glass stalls. If frosted glass was bad, these transparent partitions are worse. Some real installations use "smart glass" that turns opaque when the door locks, but if that is the idea here, the photo shows what happens when the trick is not working or not obvious. Shared by Queenbach.

The Paint In This Public Restroom

An unfortunate paint finish. A sponged, swirled brown effect may have looked rustic on a sample card. On a restroom wall, directly above the toilet, it reminds every visitor of exactly the wrong thing. Colour and texture always borrow meaning from the room they are in. Shared by Xuhale.

Hmmm

Stall doors that stop halfway. Some gap under a partition helps cleaning and ventilation, yet these short doors leave most of each cubicle exposed. Partitions, like all building elements, have to be checked against the people who will use them, not just the floor plan. Shared by house_monkey.

I Don't Even Have Words For This

An accessible toilet up a flight of steps. The wheelchair symbol on the door promises step-free access, and the stairs in front of it take that promise back. Accessibility rules in most countries require a level or ramped route to any facility labelled this way. Shared by BirbCabbage.

Placement problems in public and at home

Many fails are not bad objects at all, but good objects put in the wrong spot or combined with the wrong partner.

Best Seat In The House

The best seat in the house. In this sports hall, a row of seats has been installed facing a solid red wall, so the spectator sitting there sees paint while the game goes on to his left. The short clip pans to the court to show what he is missing. Shared by instanteffect.

You Had One Job...

An outlet with no room for a plug. The clip shows someone trying to plug a charger into a wall socket fitted right under a bulky wall-mounted dispenser. The plug only goes in at an angle, because the two fixtures were installed without checking each other's clearance. Shared by Aero-Space.

Uh... How Would I... Know

Your own expiration date. An online form asks for a date of birth and, right below it, an "Expiration Date". It probably refers to an ID document, but with no label saying so, the form appears to ask when the user will die. Every field needs a clear subject. Shared by 9986000_minutes.

Pool Got A New Sunshade For The Kiddie Pool. A New Yellow Sunshade

A yellow sunshade over the kiddie pool. The shade itself is useful. Its colour, reflected onto the water of a pool used by small children, makes the whole pool glow the one shade of yellow parents dread. Shared by tangleduplife.

Kids Love Pandas!

A panda print that pairs up oddly. The pink sweater is covered in black-and-white pandas, but many are drawn stacked on top of each other in pairs, so adults looking closely may read them as something other than play. Small repeat patterns should always be checked at full size before printing. Shared by TenFootLoPan.

A Friend’s Two-Year Old’s Birthday Cake

A cake that changes with the angle. The swirly topper on this pink birthday cake reads "TWO" from the front. Seen from another angle, the looping letters spell a very rude word instead. Decorations made of cursive letters should be looked at from every side of the table. Shared by randyfloyd37.

Twenty-Five Design Mistakes Involving Layout, Placement and Context

A thermostat that controls nothing. A tenant discovered that the dial on the wall was simply hanging on a nail, with no wiring behind it. Placebo controls do exist in some offices and on some crossing buttons, but a fake thermostat in a rented home is more likely a sign of a botched or abandoned installation.

What these fails teach about good design

Almost every photo above could have been prevented by a simple check in the real setting. Designers call this testing in context: printing the sign at full size and looking at it from across the street, standing where the visitor will stand, turning the cake around, or switching off half the letters of a neon sign to see what remains.

A second lesson is that nothing is seen alone. A slogan is read with the line beneath it, an advert with the story above it, a rabbit with the headline on top. Good layout groups things that belong together and separates things that do not, using space, size and alignment.

The third lesson is about people. Accessible toilets, privacy in bathrooms and clear form labels are not decoration; they decide whether a design works for everyone who has to use it. If you are building anything, from a menu to a website, a fresh pair of eyes and a quick walk-through with a real user will catch most of these problems before they end up on Reddit.

Sources: r/CrappyDesign on Reddit; Marci Robin on Twitter, 20 May 2018. Photos were shared by the Reddit, Imgur and Twitter users credited under each picture.

COMMENTS