How to Pick a Ripe Watermelon, Pineapple, Cantaloupe and Strawberries

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Choosing Fruit: Practical Questions Behind Popular Tips

The quickest way to pick good fruit is to use the checks that growers themselves rely on. For a watermelon, look for a creamy yellow ground spot and a melon that feels heavy for its size. For a cantaloupe, smell the blossom end and check that the stem came away cleanly. For a pineapple, ignore the colour and the leaf-pulling trick, and choose one that looks fresh and gives slightly when pressed. For strawberries, buy fully red berries, because they will not ripen further, and store them unwashed with their caps on.

Many popular tips, however, are folklore. Below we go fruit by fruit, explain why each test works or fails, and point out the myths.

Watermelon: look, lift, turn

The US National Watermelon Promotion Board sums up its advice in three words: look, lift, turn. Look for a firm, symmetrical melon without bruises, cuts or dents. Lift it: a ripe watermelon is about 92% water, so it should feel heavy for its size. Turn it over and check the underside.

Picking The Perfect Watermelon

The ground spot. The pale patch where the melon rested on the soil is called the field spot or ground spot. On a melon that ripened in the sun on the vine, it turns a creamy yellow, sometimes with an orange tint. A white or very pale greenish spot suggests the fruit was harvested early. In the photo above, the deeper the colour of the patch, the better the odds of a sweet melon.

Picking The Perfect Watermelon

Webbing and brown "sugar" marks. Some melons carry rough, brown, web-like scarring on the rind. A popular claim says this shows heavy bee pollination and therefore a sweeter fruit. Bees really are essential, since every female flower has to be pollinated for a melon to form, but the link between the scars and sweetness is anecdotal rather than established. Treat webbing as harmless, not as a guarantee.

Picking The Perfect Watermelon

Round or long: no "male" and "female" melons. Another common tip sorts watermelons into "boys" and "girls" by shape. Watermelons have no gender. The plant carries separate male and female flowers, and only female flowers become fruit, so every melon grew from a female flower. Shape mostly reflects the variety and growing conditions. If you prefer one shape, choose by variety, not by gender.

Picking The Perfect Watermelon

Size. Bigger is not automatically better. What matters is weight relative to size: compare two melons of similar size and pick the heavier one. A small but heavy melon is usually a better buy than a large, light one.

Picking The Perfect Watermelon

The stem and the tendril. A shrivelled, brown stem or the dried curly tendril closest to it is often read as a sign the melon finished ripening on the vine, while a fresh green stem suggests early picking. This is a reasonable clue but not a guarantee. On thumping, the Board is honest: it does not promote it, but says a ripe melon tends to give a deeper, duller sound and an unripe one a clearer ring. Once picked, a whole watermelon keeps for roughly three to four weeks.

Pineapple: forget the old tricks

Choosing Fruit: Practical Questions Behind Popular Tips

Pineapple advice is full of myths, and Dole, one of the largest growers, addresses them directly. The most important fact is that a pineapple does not keep ripening once it is cut from the plant. Growers measure sugar content with a refractometer and harvest at peak sweetness. Leaving a pineapple on the counter may soften it, but it will not make it sweeter.

Choosing Fruit: Practical Questions Behind Popular Tips

Colour. A common tip says to choose a golden pineapple over a green one. Dole says ripe fruit ranges from green to gold depending on growing conditions, so shell colour tells you little about ripeness. A green pineapple can be perfectly sweet.

Choosing Fruit: Practical Questions Behind Popular Tips

Pulling a leaf. The idea that a leaf which comes out easily signals a ripe fruit is, according to Dole, a myth. Instead, look for fresh green leaves, a plump body that gives very slightly when you press it, and no soft, wet or mouldy spots.

Choosing Fruit: Practical Questions Behind Popular Tips

Smelling the base. A pleasant sweet smell is fine, but stronger is not better. Dole warns that a very strong, boozy smell means the fruit has begun to ferment. Because pineapples do not improve after harvest, eat one soon after buying it.

Cantaloupe: let your nose and the stem decide

Picking The Best Cantaloupe

"Cantaloupe" means different melons in different places. In North America it usually refers to a muskmelon with a heavily netted, beige rind and orange flesh. In Europe, true cantaloupes such as the French Charentais have smoother, often ribbed rinds. The advice below fits the netted North American type, though smell and weight work for all of them.

Picking The Best Cantaloupe

Rind and netting. Look for raised, corky netting spread evenly over the melon, in a buff or light tan colour over a background that may be green, yellow or grey depending on the variety. A strongly green background often means early picking. Skip melons with cracks, mould or soft, sunken patches.

Picking The Best Cantaloupe

The stem end. This is the most useful clue. A cantaloupe harvested at the right time separates from the vine by itself, leaving a clean, smooth, shallow dip, which growers call a "full slip". A rough or torn stem scar suggests the fruit was pulled off before it was ready.

Picking The Best Cantaloupe

Weight and the blossom end. A ripe cantaloupe feels heavy for its size, and the end opposite the stem should give slightly under your thumb. If it feels mushy, the melon is past its best.

Picking The Best Cantaloupe

Smell. Ohio State University's food advice column puts it simply: your nose knows. A ripe cantaloupe has a sweet, musky aroma at the blossom end. No smell suggests an unripe fruit, while an overpowering smell can mean it is overripe. Tapping is less reliable than smell, weight and the stem end.

Picking The Best Cantaloupe

Do not expect it to sweeten at home. An underripe cantaloupe will soften and get juicier on the counter, but it will not become sweeter, because melons do not store starch that could later turn into sugar. One food safety point matters too: the netted rind can carry bacteria such as Salmonella, so scrub the melon under running water just before cutting, and keep cut pieces in the fridge.

Strawberries: choose ripe, store dry

Keeping Strawberries Fresh

Like pineapples, strawberries do not ripen after picking. North Carolina State Extension advises choosing berries that are firm, plump, fragrant and a glossy, even red, with fresh green caps. Pale shoulders or white tips will stay that way.

Keeping Strawberries Fresh

Leave the caps on and wait to wash. Removing the green caps or washing the berries early lets them lose moisture and bruise more easily. Store them unwashed in a shallow container, loosely covered, in the crisper drawer of the fridge. In ideal conditions they keep up to about a week, though berries bought very ripe last less. Take them out an hour or two before eating for the best flavour, and rinse them just before serving.

Keeping Strawberries Fresh

Remove damaged berries quickly. The fuzzy grey growth in this photo is grey mould, caused by the fungus Botrytis cinerea, a common problem in strawberries. Spores spread easily to neighbouring fruit, so sort through the box when you get home and throw out any mouldy, bruised or leaking berries.

Myths at a glance

  • "Watermelons can be male or female." False. All fruit develops from female flowers.
  • "A green pineapple will ripen on your counter." False. Pineapples do not get sweeter after harvest, and green can already be ripe.
  • "If a pineapple leaf pulls out easily, it is ripe." Called a myth by Dole.
  • "A hard cantaloupe will sweeten at home." It will soften, but not sweeten.
  • "Wash strawberries as soon as you get home." Better to wash them just before eating.

Plan around when you will eat it

A simple habit makes all of these tips more useful: decide when you will eat the fruit before you choose it. Strawberries and pineapple are best eaten within a few days. A whole watermelon can wait a couple of weeks. A slightly firm cantaloupe can sit on the counter for a day or two to soften. No single visual trick predicts sweetness every time, but combining weight, smell, the stem end and a quick check for damage will steer you to good fruit far more often than chance.

Sources: National Watermelon Promotion Board: Facts and FAQs; Dole: How to tell when a pineapple is ripe; Ohio State University CFAES: Your nose knows ripe cantaloupe; Wikipedia: Cantaloupe; NC State Extension: Strawberry season; Wikipedia: Garden strawberry. Tips originally compiled by Goodfullness.

COMMENTS