Originally published 2018-05-23.

Marianna Massey / Getty Images
Hawaii became the first US state to ban sunscreens containing oxybenzone and octinoxate, two common chemical UV filters that laboratory studies have linked to coral damage. Lawmakers passed the bill, SB 2571, in May 2018, Governor David Ige signed it on 3 July 2018, and the ban took effect on 1 January 2021. Since then, shops in Hawaii cannot sell or distribute sunscreen with either ingredient unless a licensed healthcare provider has prescribed it.
The law made headlines around the world and inspired similar rules elsewhere. It also sparked a lasting debate among scientists, dermatologists and manufacturers about how much sunscreen really harms reefs. Here is what the law does, what the evidence says, and how to protect both your skin and the ocean.
What the Hawaii sunscreen law covers
The ban applies to any “SPF sunscreen protection personal care product” that contains oxybenzone or octinoxate, and the definition is broad. Lotions, sprays, sticks, balms and mists are all included. According to legal analysis published when the law was signed, an estimated 70 percent or more of sunscreen products on the market at the time contained at least one of the two chemicals.
The law targets sale and distribution inside Hawaii. Visitors are not searched at the airport, and nobody is fined for wearing a banned product on the beach. In practice, though, many major brands reformulated or created Hawaii-friendly versions, and hotel shops switched their shelves to mineral sunscreens.
Governor Ige framed the law as protection for marine ecosystems, including the coral reefs that support fisheries, tourism and coastal defence across the islands.
Why oxybenzone and octinoxate worry reef scientists
Laboratory experiments have linked oxybenzone to bleaching in coral, damage to coral DNA and deformities in coral larvae. The US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) lists both chemicals among the sunscreen ingredients of concern and notes possible harm to other marine life too, including slowed growth in green algae, defects in young mussels and sea urchins, and reproductive effects in fish.
Much of the early attention came from research led by toxicologist Craig Downs of the nonprofit Haereticus Environmental Laboratory. A 2015 paper by his team in Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology reportedly estimated that between roughly 6,000 and 14,000 tonnes of sunscreen may enter coral reef areas each year, and reported harmful effects on coral larvae at very low concentrations in the lab. Haereticus later surveyed Hanauma Bay on Oahu, one of Hawaii’s busiest snorkelling spots, and reported that its daily crowds, averaging around 2,600 people, may leave hundreds of pounds of sunscreen in the water.

Hanauma Bay on the island of Oahu, Patrick Baz / AFP / Getty Images
Sunscreen does not only reach the sea from swimmers. It washes off in showers and travels through wastewater, which is why Hawaii state Senator Laura Thielen, one of the bill’s champions, told local TV station KHON2: “So really it’s damaging our corals no matter whether you’re wearing it on land or at the beach.”
How strong is the evidence?
The science is real but still developing, and it is fair to be precise about it.
- Lab versus reef. Many of the most alarming results came from laboratory tests using concentrations or conditions that may not match the open ocean. Some studies were criticised for lacking proper controls.
- Sunscreen is not the main cause of coral loss. Rising sea temperatures that trigger mass bleaching, pollution from land, overfishing and disease are considered far bigger threats. Sunscreen is at most one local stressor, mainly at heavily used beaches and bays.
- More study is needed. In August 2022 the US National Academies of Sciences, Engineering, and Medicine called on the Environmental Protection Agency to carry out a full ecological risk assessment of UV filters, focusing on crowded swimming areas and places where wastewater enters the sea.
Opponents of the Hawaii law, including sunscreen makers, retail groups and the Hawaii Medical Association, argued that the research was not yet strong enough and warned that fewer sunscreen choices could discourage people from protecting their skin. Supporters replied that local reef stress was serious enough to justify caution, especially when alternatives exist.
Other places with reef-safe sunscreen rules
Hawaii was the first US state, but not the only jurisdiction to act. The Pacific nation of Palau introduced its own restriction on reef-toxic sunscreens, in force from 2020. The US Virgin Islands brought in a ban the same year, and Aruba and Bonaire acted in 2019. Thailand has prohibited certain chemical sunscreens in its marine national parks.
Key West in Florida passed a similar ban due to start in 2021, but the Florida legislature then passed a law blocking local governments from regulating sunscreen, so the Key West rule never took effect.
In the US, oxybenzone remains legal at the federal level. The Food and Drug Administration has asked manufacturers for more safety data before it decides whether the ingredient is “generally recognised as safe and effective”, a separate question from its effect on reefs.
How to protect your skin and the reef
Sun protection still matters. Skin cancer is common and sunburn damages skin at any age, so the answer is not to skip sunscreen but to choose and use it wisely. If you have questions about the right product for your skin, talk to a doctor.
- Cover up first. Rash guards, sun shirts, hats and clothing with a UPF (Ultraviolet Protection Factor) rating block sun without washing into the water. Many outdoor and swimwear brands now sell UPF-rated clothing.
- Consider mineral sunscreen. Products based on non-nano zinc oxide or titanium dioxide sit on the skin and are generally considered to have fewer effects on marine life, although NOAA notes that nano-sized particles are still being studied.
- Seek shade at midday. NOAA suggests avoiding the strongest sun between about 10 a.m. and 2 p.m.
- Apply early. Putting sunscreen on well before swimming lets it bind to skin, so less rinses straight into the sea.
- Be wary of labels. “Reef safe” and “reef friendly” are not regulated terms in the US. Check the ingredient list rather than relying on the front of the bottle.
Hawaii’s law turned a niche scientific concern into a global consumer trend. Whatever the final verdict on individual chemicals, the simplest habits, covering up, choosing mineral filters and sparing the reef from a film of lotion, help both swimmers and corals.
Sources: Hunton Andrews Kurth: Hawaii governor signs law banning chemicals in sunscreen products; NOAA: Skincare chemicals and coral reefs; Practical Dermatology: National Academies call on EPA to study sunscreen effects; Wikipedia: Oxybenzone; Downs et al., Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology (2015); BuzzFeed (original report). Photos: Marianna Massey / Getty Images; Patrick Baz / AFP / Getty Images.

COMMENTS