Originally published 2018-05-31.
On 27 April 2018, European Union member states voted to ban all outdoor use of three neonicotinoid insecticides, clothianidin, imidacloprid and thiamethoxam, because the EU's food safety agency had found they pose a high risk to honeybees and wild bees. From the end of 2018, these chemicals could only be used inside permanent, closed greenhouses. The decision turned a partial restriction from 2013 into a near-total ban on the world's most widely used class of insecticides.

Here is what neonicotinoids are, why scientists worried about them, what the ban did and did not change, and how the rules have held up since.
What neonicotinoids are and why farmers used them
Neonicotinoids, often shortened to "neonics," are nerve poisons chemically related to nicotine. Scientists at Shell and Bayer developed them in the 1980s, and imidacloprid, patented by Bayer in 1985, became the first commercial product. By the late 1990s they were in use around the world.
Their appeal to farmers is that they are systemic. Instead of being sprayed on leaves, they are usually coated onto seeds or added to soil. As the plant grows, the chemical spreads through its tissues, so insects that chew or suck on it are killed. They bind far more strongly to insect nerve receptors than to those of mammals, which made them look safer for people and livestock than older insecticides. Farmers relied on them to protect crops such as oilseed rape, maize, cereals and sugar beet from pests like aphids and flea beetles.
Why bees are at risk
The same systemic action is the problem for pollinators. Because the chemical moves throughout the plant, traces end up in pollen and nectar. Much of a seed coating also never enters the crop: it washes into soil and water, where wildflowers and later crops can take it up.
Most of the concern is not about bees dying instantly. Researchers have found that chronic low-level exposure can impair bees' ability to navigate back to the hive, learn and forage, weaken their immune responses and shorten the lives of queens. For a colony, losing foragers and producing fewer new queens can be as damaging as an outright poisoning. Field results have been more mixed than laboratory studies, especially for managed honeybees, but evidence of harm to wild bees, including bumblebees and solitary species, has been stronger.
In February 2018, after reviewing the available research, the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) concluded that most uses of the three neonicotinoids represent a high risk to wild bees and honeybees. That assessment was the scientific basis for the vote two months later.
From a 2013 moratorium to the 2018 ban
The EU had already acted once. In 2013, a majority of member states agreed to restrict the same three chemicals on crops attractive to bees, such as flowering oilseed rape, starting that December. That earlier step left many uses in place, including on winter cereals and sugar beet.
The 2018 decision went much further. It removed all outdoor uses, leaving only greenhouse cultivation, where treated plants stay indoors for their whole life cycle. The European Commission had proposed the measure months earlier. Vytenis Andriukaitis, the commissioner for health and food safety, welcomed the vote, saying that "bee health remains of paramount importance for me" because it affects biodiversity, food production and the environment.
Who supported the ban, and who opposed it
Public pressure was considerable, The Guardian reported. A petition organised by the campaign group Avaaz gathered close to five million signatures calling for a ban, and environmental organisations and many beekeepers backed the move. Antonia Staats of Avaaz described the outcome as "a beacon of hope for bees."
Pesticide manufacturers and several farm organisations argued that the EU was being overly cautious and that crop losses would rise without effective seed treatments. Guy Smith, then deputy president of the UK's National Farmers' Union, warned: "There is a real risk that these restrictions will do nothing measurable to improve bee health." Some farmers worried that they would have to spray older insecticides more often instead, which could carry its own risks to wildlife.
What happened next: loopholes and court rulings
The ban was not quite the end of the story. Several member states used "emergency authorisations" to let farmers sow neonicotinoid-treated seed for particular crops, most often sugar beet, which is vulnerable to aphids carrying yellows virus. France, which had introduced its own ban on these substances, granted such exemptions for sugar beet in 2021 and 2022.
That route was closed by the Court of Justice of the European Union on 19 January 2023. The court ruled that once the Commission has expressly banned a product for seed treatment, a member state cannot use a temporary derogation to allow treated seeds to be sold or sown. In May 2023, France's highest administrative court, the Conseil d'État, cancelled the French exemptions as unlawful.
Outside the EU the picture is uneven. After Brexit, the United Kingdom repeatedly authorised a thiamethoxam seed treatment for sugar beet in England on an emergency basis. In the United States, regulation has shifted back and forth: a 2014 ban on neonicotinoids in national wildlife refuges was reversed in 2018, while several states have introduced their own limits.
Does banning neonics save the bees?
Restricting these insecticides removes one important pressure, but it is not a cure-all. Pollinator decline has several causes acting together: loss of flower-rich habitat and nesting sites, pesticides of many kinds, parasites and diseases such as the viruses spread by Varroa mites, and a changing climate that can put bees and flowers out of step. Measuring whether bee populations recover because of the ban requires years of monitoring.
The stakes are real, though perhaps not in the way slogans suggest. Around 60% of crop plant species benefit from animal pollinators, including most fruits and many vegetables, though staple grains such as wheat, rice and maize are wind-pollinated. Losing pollinators would not starve the world outright, but it would make diets poorer and many foods scarcer and more expensive.
Anyone can help in small ways: plant a mix of flowers that bloom from spring to autumn, leave some corners of a garden a little wild, avoid insecticides on flowering plants, and support farmers and councils that protect hedgerows and meadows.
Sources: Wikipedia: Neonicotinoid; Wikipedia: Pollinator decline; Conseil d'État: Neonicotinoids, no exemptions to the European ban (2023). Quotes as reported by The Guardian in April 2018. Photos: Flickr, Pxhere.

COMMENTS