Man Found Himself in Wife's Holiday Photo, 11 Years Before They Met

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-03-13.

A Couple Found Their Earlier Paths Crossing in a Holiday Photo

Left: Xue at May Fourth Square in Qingdao in July 2000, with the boy who would become her husband circled in the background. Right: Ye's own photo of the same landmark from that day. Photos: AsiaWire.

In March 2018, a man from Chengdu named Ye was looking through his wife Xue's childhood photos at his mother-in-law's house when he spotted a familiar figure in the background of one of them: himself, as a teenager. The picture had been taken in July 2000 at May Fourth Square in Qingdao, on the east coast of China, more than a decade before the couple met. Both families had travelled there separately, and both had stopped at the same giant red sculpture at almost the same moment.

The couple met through mutual friends in 2011, married the following year and, by the time of the discovery, had twin daughters. Their accidental photo together spread quickly on Chinese social media and then around the world. Here is the story, the place where it happened, and why coincidences like this are both rarer and more common than they feel.

How Ye found himself in the picture

The discovery came from an ordinary family question. Ye wanted to know whether the couple's twin girls looked more like their mother or their father, so he went looking for pictures of Xue as a child. One holiday snapshot showed her as a teenager in a white dress, sitting in front of the landmark sculpture at May Fourth Square. In the bottom right corner, small and slightly out of focus, stood a boy in a dark top.

Ye recognised the scene immediately because he had his own photo from that trip, taken in front of the same sculpture. He told Sina News that his pose in his own picture matched the figure in Xue's: "it was the same posture, just from a different angle." The two images line up, with the same overcast sky and the same corner of the square, which is what convinced the couple that the boy was really him.

A Couple Found Their Earlier Paths Crossing in a Holiday Photo

The two holiday photos side by side: Xue's snapshot with the background figure circled, and Ye's own picture in front of the sculpture. Photos: AsiaWire.

Two families, one sculpture

Neither trip was planned with the other in mind, and both happened partly by chance. According to reports at the time, Xue's family took the holiday to help her mother relax after an operation a few months earlier. Ye was there on a tour group almost by accident: his mother had booked the trip, fell ill before it, and sent him in her place.

Both families came from Chengdu, the capital of Sichuan Province in south-western China, which is more than 1,800 kilometres (about 1,100 miles) from Qingdao. The teenagers did not know each other, and they returned home without ever speaking. Xue later remembered that she had been to Qingdao as a child, and Ye knew it too, but neither had any reason to think they had been there at the same time.

A Couple Found Their Earlier Paths Crossing in a Holiday Photo

Left: the couple's two old photos displayed on phones. Right: Ye and Xue back at the same sculpture as adults. Photos: AsiaWire.

May Fourth Square and the "May Wind" sculpture

The red spiral in both photos is one of Qingdao's best-known landmarks. The sculpture, known as May Wind, was designed by Huang Zhen. It stands about 30 metres tall, is about 27 metres across and weighs more than 500 tonnes. Its twisting red bands are meant to suggest a gust of wind.

The square takes its name from the May Fourth Movement of 1919, a wave of student-led protests that began after the Treaty of Versailles handed Germany's former concessions in Shandong Province, including Qingdao, to Japan rather than returning them to China. The city named the square in 1997, and it sits between the municipal government buildings and Fushan Bay. It is a standard stop for visitors, which is an important clue to how this coincidence could happen at all.

A Couple Found Their Earlier Paths Crossing in a Holiday Photo

Ye and Xue in a seaside portrait session. The couple later recreated parts of their story in new photos together. Photo: AsiaWire.

How likely is a coincidence like this?

It feels astonishing, and for the couple it is. But it helps to look at the numbers. Qingdao is a popular summer destination, July is peak season, and May Fourth Square is on almost every itinerary. On any busy day, thousands of families stand in front of that sculpture and take nearly identical pictures. Every one of those photos has strangers in the background.

Statisticians sometimes call this the law of truly large numbers: when there are enough chances for something unusual to happen, it eventually happens to someone. Millions of people have background strangers in their holiday photos, and a tiny fraction of those strangers will later become their friends, colleagues or partners. Almost nobody ever finds out, because nobody looks closely. What makes Ye and Xue's case special is not only that it happened, but that two matching photos survived for 18 years and someone thought to compare them.

None of that takes away from what the discovery means to them. A coincidence can be explained by probability and still be a lovely, meaningful part of a family's story. Many people who shared the photos online called the couple's relationship destined. That is their story to tell, and a good one.

Look again at your own old photos

Stories like this one usually surface by accident, while sorting albums or scanning prints. If you have boxes of old holiday photos, a few habits make them easier to enjoy and to search:

  • Scan or photograph your prints. Paper fades and gets lost; a digital copy lets you zoom into backgrounds, as Ye did.
  • Write down where and when. A date and a place on the back of a print, or in a file name, can be the detail that connects two pictures decades later.
  • Compare trips with your partner and friends. Couples often find they visited the same city, concert or event years apart, or even on the same day.
  • Keep both versions. If you find a match, keep the original prints together. Ye said he planned to treasure both photos as keepsakes.
A Couple Found Their Earlier Paths Crossing in a Holiday Photo

Ye holding up the two photographs on his phones, the pictures that turned an ordinary holiday into a family legend. Photo: AsiaWire.

A keepsake for the next generation

Ye joked that his wife complains he does not know how to be romantic, and suggested that this discovery might change her mind. The real winners may be their daughters, who now have a family story better than most: their parents stood a few metres apart by the sea in Qingdao, eleven years before they were introduced, and a camera caught it.

Sources: PetaPixel (March 2018): Married couple discover themselves in photo shot 11 years before they met, citing Channel NewsAsia and Sina News; Wikipedia: May Fourth Square. Photos: AsiaWire.

COMMENTS