Originally published 2018-02-21.

Jealousy is not a reliable sign of love. Decades of relationship research link frequent or intense jealousy far more closely to the jealous person's own insecurity, such as low self-esteem, anxiety and fear of being left, than to how much they care about their partner. The good news is that both partners can do practical things to calm it, and the most effective tools are reassurance and honest, non-accusing conversation.
Below, we look at where the "jealousy proves love" idea goes wrong, what tends to drive jealous feelings, and what to do whether your partner is the jealous one or you are.
Why "jealousy means love" is a myth
Social psychologist Gwendolyn Seidman, writing for Psychology Today, described seeing a tweet from an account with a psychology-sounding name that claimed people who are truly in love get jealous over small things. The fact that even someone interested in psychology believed this shows how widespread the idea is.
Popular culture often frames possessiveness as romantic: the partner who cannot bear you talking to anyone else must love you deeply. In reality, jealousy is a reaction to a perceived threat to a relationship, usually involving a real or imagined rival. It blends fear, anger, sadness and insecurity, and it can be strong in relationships where love is weak, and mild in ones where love is deep.
It is also a common source of real trouble. In a survey of marital and family therapists published by Gregory White in 2008, romantic jealousy was rated a serious problem for about a third of the couples they treated.
What drives jealous feelings
Researchers have looked at which personal traits make someone more prone to jealousy. A consistent picture has emerged, and it says more about the jealous person than about their partner.
- Low self-esteem. People who doubt their own worth find it easier to believe they could be replaced.
- Neuroticism. A general tendency towards worry, moodiness and emotional ups and downs is linked with more jealousy.
- Possessiveness and insecurity. Seeing a partner as something to hold on to, rather than a person who chooses to stay, feeds suspicion.
- Dependence. The more someone feels they have no good alternatives, the more threatening any rival seems. In one experiment, simply asking people to imagine they had few other options made them react more negatively to jealousy scenarios.
- Feeling inadequate. A nagging sense of not being good enough for your partner is a strong predictor.
- Anxious attachment. People with an anxious attachment style often worry that a partner will reject them or not love them enough, even when the relationship is stable.
An experiment by Dylan Selterman and Markus Maier in 2013 makes the point neatly. When participants were briefly encouraged to feel more secure, by recalling affection and support from someone close to them, they reacted less strongly to an imagined jealousy-provoking situation. Feeling safe reduced the jealousy, which suggests the feeling grows from insecurity rather than from the depth of love.
Jealousy versus envy, and normal versus harmful
The two words are often used as if they mean the same thing, but psychologists usually separate them. Jealousy is about fear of losing something you have, such as a partner's attention. Envy is about wanting something you do not have, such as a friend's success. They can overlap, but the solutions are different.
A brief flash of jealousy, for example when a partner's ex sends a friendly message, is a normal human feeling. What matters is what happens next. Mentioning it calmly is healthy. Checking their phone, demanding passwords, cutting them off from friends or punishing them with silence is not. Controlling behaviour driven by jealousy is a recognised warning sign of an abusive relationship, and if a partner's jealousy is making you afraid, talk to someone you trust or a support service.
If your partner is the jealous one
Start by remembering that unwarranted jealousy usually reflects your partner's fears rather than anything you have done. That does not make it pleasant to live with, but it can make it less personal.
The research supports a simple response: reassurance. A 1997 study by Virgil Sheets and colleagues found that people who answered a partner's jealousy by showing affection and commitment tended to have more stable relationships. In everyday terms, that can mean:
- Saying clearly that you are committed and that the other person is not a threat.
- Being open about plans and contacts without being pushed into constant reporting.
- Showing interest and warmth in small, regular ways, not only after an argument.
Reassurance has limits. You can offer comfort, but you cannot cure someone else's insecurity, and you should not have to give up friendships or privacy to keep them calm.
If you are the jealous one
Avoid feeding the suspicion
One of the best-known studies on this topic, by Amy Muise, Emily Christofides and Serge Desmarais in 2009, looked at Facebook. People who monitored a partner's profile came across ambiguous posts and photos that made them more jealous, which led them to check even more. The result was a loop of searching and worrying. Stepping away from that kind of monitoring often lowers anxiety rather than raising it.
Build your own sense of security
Because jealousy is so closely tied to self-esteem and attachment, working on those areas pays off. Invest in friendships, interests and goals that make you feel capable on your own. Attachment research suggests that a meaningful share of adults do become more secure over time, especially through supportive relationships and reflection.
Talk about it the right way
Silence tends to let jealousy grow, but so does an angry outburst. Studies by Jennifer Bevan and others found that direct, calm conversation about jealous feelings is linked to greater relationship satisfaction and less confusion for the partner, while sarcasm, hostility and accusations backfire. Try describing what you felt and what triggered it, then ask together what would help. If jealousy feels overwhelming or constant, a counsellor or therapist can help you understand where it comes from.
When jealousy is a fair signal
Not all jealousy is irrational. If a partner has cheated, broken an agreement or lied about contact with someone, feeling jealous is an understandable response to real events, and it deserves a serious conversation. Likewise, if one person wants a monogamous relationship and the other does not, jealousy may be pointing to a genuine mismatch, and the honest answer may be to find a partner whose expectations fit yours.
The aim, then, is not to never feel jealous. It is to tell the difference between a feeling rooted in what is actually happening and one rooted in old fears, and to respond to each with honesty rather than control.
Studies mentioned
- White, G. L. (2008). Romantic jealousy: Therapists' perceptions of causes, consequences, and treatments. Journal of Couple and Relationship Therapy.
- Selterman, D. F., & Maier, M. A. (2013). Secure attachment and material reward both attenuate romantic jealousy. Motivation and Emotion.
- Sheets, V. L., Fredendall, L. L., & Claypool, H. M. (1997). Jealousy evocation, partner reassurance, and relationship stability. Evolution and Human Behavior.
- Muise, A., Christofides, E., & Desmarais, S. (2009). More information than you ever wanted: Does Facebook bring out the green-eyed monster of jealousy? CyberPsychology & Behavior.
- Bevan, J. L. (2008). Experiencing and communicating romantic jealousy: Questioning the investment model. Southern Communication Journal.
Sources: Gwendolyn Seidman, "What's Really Behind Jealousy, and What to Do About It", Psychology Today, 2014; Wikipedia: Jealousy; Wikipedia: Attachment in adults.

COMMENTS