
The story of an old arborist who took revenge on Redondo Beach, California, by secretly planting giant sequoias all over town is fiction. It began as a Reddit post in June 2017, the city said it never happened, and the biology in it does not hold up. It is still a very good story, and the reasons it spread so widely say a lot about how people feel about the trees on their own street.
The story in brief
The narrator introduces himself as a tree professional who loves trees. Three years earlier, he says, the city of Redondo Beach ordered the removal of the 30-year-old pepper tree in front of his house because its roots were lifting the pavement. Worse, the city billed him for the sidewalk repair and the removal.
He had named the tree Clyde and had cared for it since it was a sapling, staking it when it was young and watching its canopy fill out. Losing it felt, in his telling, like losing a child.
So he plotted a slow revenge. He claims that, a few months after Clyde came down, he quietly planted 45 coast redwoods and 82 giant sequoias in parks, yards and public land around the city. Now, he warns the mayor by name, their roots are spreading, the trees are about to shoot upward, and each one will be costly to remove. The letter signs off by wishing that the city be overrun by trees.

A mature California pepper tree (Schinus molle) beside a suburban driveway. Pepper trees are common street and garden trees in coastal California, and their surface roots can crack nearby paving. The photo illustrates the species and is not the tree from the story.
Where it came from and how it spread
According to the fact-checking site Snopes, the tale was posted on 16 June 2017 to the r/trees community on Reddit by a user whose earlier posts described a college dorm room and a biology major, rather than a long career in arboriculture. From there it was copied to revenge-themed forums, then to viral story sites and Facebook pages, often with stock photos of an elderly bearded man added to make it feel like a real profile.
When Snopes asked the city, Redondo Beach's public works director Ted Semaan said the story was untrue. He also made a practical point: a city would notice 127 unexplained trees appearing on its own property. The mayor named in the post, Steve Aspel, was a real person, which helped the letter look authentic to readers who did not check further.

Pixabay
Giant sequoias in a natural grove in California's Sierra Nevada. Their thick, fire-resistant red bark and fluted bases make them instantly recognisable. Trees like these took many centuries to reach this size.
Why the science in the letter does not work
The fun of the story depends on the trees becoming a giant problem within a few years. Real sequoias and redwoods do not cooperate with that plan:
- Wrong climate. Giant sequoias grow naturally only in about 80 scattered groves on the western slopes of the Sierra Nevada, roughly 1,400 to 2,150 metres above sea level, with snowy winters and plenty of soil moisture. Coast redwoods depend on the fog belt of Northern California and southern Oregon. Coastal Los Angeles County is far warmer and drier.
- Drought. Southern California had just come through a severe multi-year drought that killed many established trees. Unwatered saplings planted in secret would struggle to survive at all.
- No sudden growth spurt. Young sequoias can grow briskly where conditions are ideal, but they do not hit an explosive phase after two or three years, and they need many decades to become tall trees. Heights of 50 to 85 metres take centuries.
- Removing a sapling is cheap. A two-year-old tree can be pulled out by one worker in an afternoon. Snopes also spoke to a local contractor who said cities usually prune encroaching roots rather than remove a whole street tree.
The real record-holders show the time scale involved. The General Sherman Tree in Sequoia National Park, the largest single-stem tree on Earth by volume, stands about 84 metres tall with a base nearly 11 metres across. The oldest giant sequoias dated by tree rings are more than 3,200 years old.
Why so many people wanted it to be true
The letter works because it gives shape to a frustration many homeowners recognise. A tree you planted and watched grow carries memories. A city sees a liability: a cracked sidewalk, a trip hazard, a possible lawsuit. When those two views collide, the resident often feels powerless, and sometimes, as in the story, is handed the bill.
The revenge is also unusually gentle. Nobody is hurt; the punishment is more trees. That lets readers enjoy the mischief without feeling bad about it. The narrator's voice, part grief and part comic menace, does the rest. One line captures the tone that readers loved:
"You killed Clyde, but I have replaced him with over 100 living giants." (from the 2017 Reddit post)
Stories like this travel because they feel like justice. That is exactly the moment to slow down and check, since an emotional pay-off is what makes people share before they read the details.

MaxPixel
A free stock portrait of an elderly man with a walking stick. Images like this were attached to copies of the letter online, but the man pictured has no connection to the story or to Redondo Beach.
If a city wants to remove a tree near you
Real tree disputes are common, and there are better tools than secret planting. If you are in a similar position:
- Find out who owns the tree. Trees in the strip between sidewalk and road are often city property, even when residents planted or watered them.
- Ask for the reason and the alternatives. Root pruning, root barriers, ramping or rerouting a sidewalk, and replacing slabs with flexible paving can sometimes save a healthy tree.
- Get an independent opinion. A certified arborist can assess the tree's health and the real risk, which gives you something concrete to bring to the city.
- Use the public process. Many cities have tree boards, heritage-tree lists or appeal rules. Neighbours speaking together at a council meeting carry weight.
- Plan the replacement. If removal goes ahead, push for a suitable species, planted with enough room and with water during its first years.
And if you want more trees in your town, volunteer with a local planting group. Right tree, right place is less dramatic than the letter, but it is how urban forests actually grow.
Clyde never existed, yet the attachment the story describes is real. That is why it keeps resurfacing every few years, and why it is worth knowing both the tale and the facts behind it.
Sources: Snopes: Did an arborist get revenge by planting giant sequoias?; National Park Service: The General Sherman Tree; Wikipedia: Sequoiadendron giganteum; story first shared on Reddit's r/trees (June 2017) and later on Newsner; photos: Pinterest, Pixabay, MaxPixel.

COMMENTS