18 Cartoons About Perspective and Seeing the Other Side

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-02-05.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Two people can watch the same event and walk away with different stories, and both may be describing something real. That is the idea behind the cartoons collected here. Each one shows a situation from two or more angles, from the famous six-or-nine argument to a dog who believes he is the one running the experiment.

Seeing another point of view is not the same as deciding that every view is equally correct. Psychologists call the mental effort of imagining someone else's position perspective-taking, and studies link it to fewer stereotypes and better negotiations. Yet a large 2018 set of 25 experiments by Tal Eyal, Mary Steffel and Nicholas Epley found that simply imagining another person's view did not make people more accurate about what that person thought. What did help was asking them. Keep that in mind as you scroll: a cartoon can open your eyes to a second angle, but a conversation tells you whether you have it right.

Most of these drawings travel around social media without names attached. Where a signature or watermark shows the artist, we credit them in the caption.

Same situation, different stories

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

A man stranded on a tiny island shouts "Boat!" at the same moment a man in a small boat shouts "Land!" Each sees rescue in the other. The joke is that neither has what the other is hoping for: the island is barely a sandbar and the boat is a dinghy. It is a neat reminder that the thing we envy in someone else's life may look very different from inside.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

A sketch signed by Danish illustrator Frits Ahlefeldt shows a man up to his chin in water saying "It's deep", while a much taller man standing in the same water insists it is not. Both are reporting their own experience accurately. The water is shallow for one and dangerous for the other, which is why "it was easy for me" is rarely useful advice.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Seen from one side, the shape looks like four bars; from the other, it looks like three. The figure is a cousin of the famous "impossible trident" illusion, where the drawing itself does not settle the answer. Two stick figures point and argue, each confident, and each right about what is in front of them.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Perhaps the most shared perspective cartoon of all: a large digit lies on the ground between two people, one calling it a 6 and the other a 9. It is often used to argue that both sides are right. A sharper reading is that both are describing their view correctly, and the real answer depends on information neither has, such as which way the number was meant to face.

Choosing what to look at

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Two prisoners share one cell and one window. One paints the iron bars on his canvas; the other paints the green hills and houses beyond them. The cartoon, whose artist we could not confirm, is a gentle argument about attention: our circumstances may be fixed for now, but what we choose to focus on is not.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Cartoonist Forest Taber's 2014 panel shows a father holding his child upside down in front of a cake that has also been flipped. The boy's defence, "Well, yeah, it's upside down now...", is pure child logic and very funny. It also makes a point: sometimes physically turning a problem around is the quickest way to see it as someone else does.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Two men stand at the bottom of the same deep pit. One sits with his head in his hands, while the other digs steps into the wall with a small tool and climbs out. The original artist's signature is too small to read. It captures a familiar idea from psychology: people who feel some control over their situation tend to look for actions, not just reasons.

Who is studying whom?

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

In this classic cartoon a dog tells another animal: watch, as soon as I drool, Pavlov will smile and write in his little book. Ivan Pavlov really did study conditioned reflexes in dogs, although his 1904 Nobel Prize was for research on digestion, and historians doubt he ever used the famous bell; his papers describe metronomes, buzzers, whistles and other signals. The joke flips the experiment to show that every observer is also being observed.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Several people in lab coats each touch a different part of an elephant and announce that it is a fan, a wall, a rope, a spear, a snake or a tree. The drawing retells one of the oldest parables in the world, found in early Jain and Buddhist texts and later in John Godfrey Saxe's 19th-century poem. Every person is partly right, and every person is wrong to think their piece is the whole animal.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

A man flies through the sky beside a flock of geese, looking delighted, above a scattering of city buildings. The caption reads, "Sometimes it's good to get a different perspective." The stock watermark shows it was licensed through iStock. Literally rising above a problem rarely happens, but stepping away, sleeping on it or talking to an outsider often has a similar effect.

Money, knowledge and what we value

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Two stone heads in the style of Easter Island's moai stand side by side. Coins dropped from one pair of hands fall like drops of blood and the plant on that head wilts, while books in the other pair of hands release water and a seedling grows. The image argues that what we feed our minds shapes what grows there. It is a moral rather than a measurement, and money obviously matters to wellbeing, but the picture makes a fair case for investing in curiosity as well as income.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

A poor man in patched clothes presses against a shop window full of smiles, each one sold for a dollar price. It is a dark joke about whether happiness can be bought. The cartoon cuts both ways: it mocks the idea that joy has a price tag, yet the man outside the glass reminds us that poverty itself makes smiling harder.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

A young woman walks past absorbed in her phone, while an elderly man in a wheelchair reads, his head stacked with a tall bookcase. The picture contrasts quick scrolling with deep reading. It is a little unfair to phones, which can hold whole libraries, but it asks a fair question about what we do with our attention.

Truth, crowds and the other side of the fence

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Two stalls stand side by side, one labelled "Comforting Lies" with a long queue, and one labelled "Unpleasant Truths" with a bored clerk and no customers. It is one of the most widely shared cartoons on the internet and a good summary of confirmation bias, our habit of favouring information that agrees with what we already believe.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

A sea of identical vessels fills the frame, all the same shape and size, with a single, taller and different one standing out at the front. The drawing is about conformity and individuality. Being noticed in a crowd often starts with how we see ourselves before anyone else can see us differently.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

A small cottage with a lush garden sits squeezed between grey apartment blocks, while dozens of faces peer down at it from tiny windows. The neighbours clearly envy the house, but we never learn how its owner feels about them. The idiom "the grass is always greener on the other side" captures the trap: we compare our inside to other people's outside.

Heart, head and the people caught between

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

This is the work of Nick Seluk's webcomic The Awkward Yeti, whose "Heart and Brain" characters have a large online following. Brain grimly shovels snow and says he hates it; Heart, building a snowman, replies that he is using it wrong. The same snowfall is a chore or a gift, depending on which part of you is in charge.

Eighteen Images That Invite a Different Perspective

Two well-dressed adults stand on separate cliffs, each pulling one arm of a frightened child who hangs over the gap. Below, in the shadows, figures are sharing drugs. The cartoon is about children caught in parental conflict, and a reminder that from the child's point of view, a fight between adults can feel like being pulled apart.

How to use a second perspective well

Cartoons like these work because they freeze two views in a single frame. Real life is messier, but a few habits help:

  • Describe before you judge. Say what you actually see, then ask what someone standing elsewhere might see.
  • Ask, don't just imagine. As the Eyal, Steffel and Epley research found, asking people what they think beats guessing.
  • Separate views from facts. Two people can both be honest about what they see while one of them is still mistaken about the facts.
  • Look for the missing piece. In the elephant parable, nobody was lying; they just needed to compare notes.

Sources: Eyal, Steffel and Epley, "Perspective mistaking", Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2018; Perspective-taking, Wikipedia; Ivan Pavlov, Wikipedia; Blind men and an elephant, Wikipedia. Cartoon credits as shown in the images: Forest Taber, Frits Ahlefeldt, The Awkward Yeti (Nick Seluk), iStock; other artists unknown. Images were previously shared via the University of Washington, Fulcrum People, Genalice, Quora, Pinterest and Facebook.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1
  1. Trump to offer the Dems a compromise of accepting whelps for $5 Billion for he wall?

    Crap !!!
    .

    ReplyDelete