Originally published 2018-01-13.
In early December 2017, Steve Ecklund, host of the hunting programme The Edge on the Edmonton-based channel Wild TV, posted photos of himself holding a large cougar he had shot in northern Alberta. Within days the pictures had collected hundreds of angry replies, a few cheers, and criticism from animal-rights groups in Britain and the United States. Weeks later Laureen Harper, wife of former Canadian prime minister Stephen Harper, joined in on Twitter. Nothing reported at the time showed the hunt broke any law. The storm was about ethics, about hunting cougars with hounds, and about posting trophy photos for a public audience.

Below we set out what happened, what Alberta's rules actually allow, why hounds became the sharpest point of the argument, and what each side was really disagreeing about. A note before you scroll: every photo in this story shows a dead animal, so each one stays blurred until you choose to open it.
What Ecklund posted and when
According to Global News, the first post went up on 3 December 2017. Ecklund called the kill an "unreal ending to a fun-filled season" and was pictured grinning while holding the bleeding cat upright in the snow. A group shot followed, with Ecklund, three companions and two hounds gathered around the cougar's body.
Graphic photo: tap or click to view
The group photo: Ecklund, three companions and two hounds behind the cougar in the northern Alberta snow (Facebook).
He went on to share more images, including one of the animal's heart, cut open on a board, and another of himself preparing a meal with the meat. The day after the first post he answered critics on Facebook in a mocking tone, mentioning the hundreds of comments and the death threats he said he had received, and joking about a draw for a cougar cookbook.
Graphic photo: tap or click to view
The cougar's heart, the image that drew some of the strongest reactions (Facebook).
Ecklund thanked Brian and Claudette Chorney of the outfitter Big Cat Adventures for showing him the world of "houndsmen". That detail matters, because it tells us how the cougar was found: tracked and treed by dogs, the usual method for hunting mountain lions in western North America.
Who Steve Ecklund is
Ecklund and his wife Alison are both keen hunters, and his social media feeds have long been full of trophy photos: elk, Dall sheep, black bears and muskox, as well as cougars. His show's website describes him as coming from a hunting family, growing up in northern Ontario and holding a reputation as a "fair chase" hunter. The same site mentions an archery title and says hunting helped carry him through a cancer diagnosis and treatment. We have not independently checked those biographical details.

Ecklund at night beside a bull elk with a large rack of antlers, one of many trophy photos on his page (Facebook).
"Fair chase" has a specific meaning in North American hunting. The Boone and Crockett Club, which keeps big-game records, defines it as the ethical, sportsmanlike and lawful pursuit of free-ranging wild game in a way that does not give the hunter an improper advantage. In plain terms: no fenced enclosures, no shooting animals that cannot escape. Whether hound hunting fits that definition is exactly where critics and hunters part ways.

Ecklund with a white Dall sheep ram on a rocky mountain slope (Facebook).
Why the backlash grew so large
Trophy photos of deer or bears rarely make international news. This one did for a mix of reasons. Cougars are large, charismatic predators that many people only ever see in documentaries. The images were graphic, especially the heart. And Ecklund's playful reply to the anger read to many people as taunting.
The reaction split sharply. Some replies wished him harm; Global News quoted one commenter hoping he would "drop dead soon" and another calling him a coward. Others congratulated him on the hunt. Defenders argued that stalking and killing your own meat is more honest than buying beef raised in a feedlot. Critics answered that a cougar is not a food animal in the usual sense and that the smiling poses suggested sport rather than need.

Ecklund and a hunting companion in orange vests beside a black bear (Facebook).
British outlets picked the story up, which brought in UK campaigners. The Hunt Saboteurs Association, which opposes hunting with dogs in Britain, called his actions "morally reprehensible". PETA issued a long statement attacking trophy hunters in personal terms. Its spokesperson said that only someone "dead in heart and head" could fail to see such animals as "thinking, feeling individuals".

A Hunt Saboteurs Association post sharing Ecklund's cougar photo with its criticism (Facebook).

A further share of the cougar photo as the criticism spread online (Facebook).
Laureen Harper and the question of hounds
The story got a second wind on 20 December 2017, when Laureen Harper tweeted about it. She called Ecklund a creep and said the cougar had been chased by dogs until it was exhausted and then shot. In a follow-up she explained that she comes from a family of hunters and anglers, and wrote: "Killing for fun makes me sick."
Her intervention shifted the argument. She was not objecting to hunting as such. She was objecting to a specific method. Hound hunting works by releasing trained dogs on a fresh track. The dogs follow the cat until it climbs a tree to escape them, and the hunter then walks in and shoots it at close range. Supporters say it lets hunters check the animal's sex and size before deciding whether to shoot, which helps avoid killing females with young. Opponents say a treed cat has no realistic chance of escape, and that chases can injure or kill dogs as well.

Ecklund and two companions beside a light-coloured bear taken in a spring hunt (Facebook).
What Alberta's cougar rules actually say
Earlier write-ups of this story claimed that Alberta bans hunting big game with dogs, which would have made the hunt illegal. That is not right for cougars. Alberta's official cougar regulations allow holders of a resident, non-resident or special cougar licence to use dogs from 1 December to 31 March, but only in a Cougar Management Area where the season is open. Dogs are banned in the fall cougar season and outside those areas.
Other rules are strict. It is illegal to shoot a spotted kitten or a female travelling with spotted kittens, so hunters are expected to check tracks and markings first. Each kill must be reported within one business day and registered at a Fish and Wildlife office, with the skin, skull and a tooth for ageing. Quotas are set for each management area, and the hunter must salvage the hide or the meat. At the time of the 2017 hunt, Global News reported that the cougar season ran from 1 September for residents and from 1 December for non-residents, through to the end of February.
Global News did not report whether this particular hunt met every condition, and no wildlife authority commented. What can be said is that nothing reported suggested a breach. The dispute was moral, not legal.
Cougars, conservation and the bigger argument
The cougar is not endangered as a species. The IUCN lists it as Least Concern, and it has the widest range of any wild land mammal in the Americas, from the Yukon to the southern Andes. Hunting is regulated in Canada, Mexico, Peru and much of the western United States. California has banned sport hunting of cougars since 1990, and the Florida panther population is federally protected.
Hunters often argue that licence fees and quotas pay for wildlife management and keep predator numbers in balance. That argument is not as simple as it sounds for big cats. Research summarised on Wikipedia notes that heavy hunting can sometimes increase livestock losses and human conflicts, because removing older, settled cats opens territory to young dispersing males. Cougar attacks on people remain rare: confirmed attacks in North America numbered in the dozens across more than a century.

Ecklund and a companion with a muskox on open tundra (Facebook).
That leaves the question many readers were really asking: is it wrong to post this kind of photo? Wildlife agencies and many hunting groups now encourage hunters to share images respectfully, without blood on show and without gloating, because trophy pictures do more to turn the public against hunting than almost anything else. Whatever your view on killing a cougar, this case shows how quickly a single photo can turn a legal hunt into a public argument about values.
Sources: Global News, 20 December 2017; My Wild Alberta: Cougar hunting regulations; Wikipedia: Cougar. Photos from Steve Ecklund's public Facebook posts; reactions first compiled by MEAWW.

The SCUM slaughtering these beautiful beings, are so much less worthy of life, than what THEy have DESTROYED. Hopefully, KARMA will return the favor to them all and very soon!
ReplyDeleteI disagree with this so called ethical hunting. If something is called ethical - other feel an ethical duty. Still it is true that hunting lies in the nature of humans. Having accomplished a hunt - deserves a smile.
ReplyDeleteI find it more cruel to post things likes the heart and such other pictures. I find it more cruel to not recognise the value of wildlife.
There needs to be a change and social discrimination has always been a way to punish those that do not fit in some societies.
can I have just 5 minutes alone with this neandertal? Just 5 minutes, please...
ReplyDeleteYou can find him in Canada...
Delete*Neanderthal
DeleteYou can hit him with your keyboard.......
DeleteRemélem megdöglötök nyomoronc vadászok!
ReplyDeletewanker .hope you rot in hell
ReplyDeleteHe is a serial killer. This is the fault of the law why he is not in jail. I hate these kind of people.
ReplyDeleteCurse you! You will have to pay for this. You are a terrorist and you and your supporters should be hanged as soon as possible.
ReplyDeleteYou must be soo cold hearted to kill this beautiful animals.
ReplyDeleteAwesome trophys, Should come to nz and do your part for conservation and reduce the deer,tahr and chamois numbers (yes they are pests)
ReplyDelete