The Starving Polar Bear Video: What Happened and What It Proved

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2018-01-12.

Heartbreaking Video Of Helpless Polar Bear Starving To Death

In December 2017, the photographer Paul Nicklen and the conservation group SeaLegacy released footage of an emaciated polar bear on Somerset Island in the Canadian Arctic. The bear, a large male, staggered across bare ground, its fur thin and dirty and its frame reduced to skin and bone, and searched old fuel drums for anything to eat. It became one of the most widely shared wildlife videos ever made, and National Geographic's version became the most-viewed video in the magazine's history.

It also became a lesson in how a single image can be stretched. National Geographic later said it had gone too far in presenting this one animal as proof of climate change. Both things matter: the bear really was starving, and polar bears really are threatened by the loss of sea ice, but no one can say for certain why this particular bear was dying.

What the team saw on Somerset Island

Nicklen and SeaLegacy co-founder Cristina Mittermeier had flown to the Inuit community at Resolute Bay and travelled by boat to an isolated cove. Older versions of this story online placed the encounter on Baffin Island; the team's own account says Somerset Island.

According to Mittermeier, the bear lay almost motionless for about an hour before getting up. Each step looked slow and painful. It nosed through empty fuel barrels, found nothing, and eventually slipped into the water and swam away. The team never saw it again, and Nicklen said he believed it died within hours or days.

The filmmakers described crying while they filmed. They have also explained why they did not intervene: they had no tranquilliser, no food suitable for a bear, and feeding or approaching a wild polar bear would have been dangerous and illegal, without any real chance of saving an animal that far gone.

The caption that went too far

Nicklen's own Instagram post was careful in one key line: "This is what starvation looks like." The post went on to argue that if the Earth keeps warming, many more bears would face a similar fate.

National Geographic's edit opened with a stronger claim, "This is what climate change looks like", with the words "climate change" highlighted. Headlines around the world went further still. In the magazine's August 2018 issue, Mittermeier wrote that the team had lost control of the narrative, and an editor's note said National Geographic had gone too far in drawing a definitive connection between climate change and this particular bear. As the note put it, "there is no way to know for certain why this bear was on the verge of death."

Bears can starve for many reasons: age, injury, disease, bad teeth, or a failed hunting season. A single animal cannot reveal which of those applied, and the footage cannot either.

(The Instagram post originally embedded here is no longer available.)

Why sea ice matters so much to polar bears

None of that means the wider concern is exaggerated. Polar bears hunt mainly ringed seals, which they catch on the sea ice by waiting at breathing holes or stalking seals resting at the ice edge. On land there is very little they can eat that comes close to the fat-rich diet they need.

Polar bears are built to fast. Their fat reserves let them survive for months without food. The problem comes when sea ice breaks up earlier in summer and forms later in autumn. Bears are pushed ashore before they have built up enough fat, and they have to wait longer before they can hunt again. Scientists identify malnutrition and starvation as the main way climate change threatens the species, with younger bears especially at risk.

How many polar bears are left, and what scientists project

The IUCN lists the polar bear as Vulnerable, with a 2015 estimate of roughly 22,000 to 31,000 animals. They live in at least 18 subpopulations around the Arctic. In 2021, the IUCN/SSC Polar Bear Specialist Group rated four subpopulations as likely stable, two as likely increased and three as likely decreased; the other ten lacked enough data to say.

Projections depend heavily on future emissions. A 2020 study found that under a very high emissions pathway most subpopulations would likely disappear by 2100, while an intermediate pathway would still eliminate some of them. In other words, the long-term outlook is serious and well documented, even though it rests on population and sea-ice data rather than on any one viral video.

Myths and half-truths around the video

"Climate change killed this bear"

Unknown. The bear was starving, but the cause in this case cannot be confirmed. The photographers and National Geographic both said so later.

"Polar bears will be extinct in a few years"

Not supported. Current numbers are in the tens of thousands, and the projected losses unfold over decades, depending on how much the Arctic warms.

"Grizzlies are taking over polar bear territory"

Partly true. Grizzly bears have been moving farther north, and in parts of Alaska the two species compete at whale carcasses, where polar bears usually give way. Hybrids exist but are rare in the wild. This overlap is real, but it is not why polar bears are in trouble; the loss of hunting time on the ice is.

"The filmmakers should have fed it"

Feeding wild polar bears is dangerous and generally illegal, and an animal in that state could not have been saved by a single meal.

What a single image can and cannot do

The Somerset Island bear did what powerful images do: it made a distant problem feel immediate to millions of people. The backlash that followed showed the cost of overstating what a picture proves, because critics used the correction to dismiss the underlying science.

The fairest reading is the one the team arrived at themselves. This is what starvation looks like. Whether this bear starved because of shrinking ice is unknown; that polar bears as a species depend on ice that is shrinking is not. If the video moves you, the most useful next step is to follow the research from groups that monitor polar bear populations, and to support efforts to cut the emissions that drive Arctic warming.

Sources: National Geographic, August 2018: Cristina Mittermeier on the starving polar bear photo, with editor's note; Wikipedia: Polar bear. Footage and photographs by Paul Nicklen and Cristina Mittermeier / SeaLegacy.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 4
  1. Is this proof that a God exist? Is this proof of God's love, kindness, mercy and compassion?

    ReplyDelete
  2. How about the's old and can't hunt any more. But right away it's climate change.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Society today. Take a picture rather than help. Smh.

    ReplyDelete