Humpback Whale and Diver Nan Hauser: Was It Really a Rescue?

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Nan Hauser’s Humpback Encounter: A Rescue Interpretation and Its Limits

In 2017 the whale biologist Nan Hauser was snorkelling off Rarotonga, the main island of the Cook Islands, when a humpback whale spent more than ten minutes nudging her, lifting her on its head and trying to tuck her beneath one of its huge pectoral fins. A tiger shark was cruising nearby. Hauser filmed much of the encounter, and when the footage went viral in January 2018 it was presented as a whale "rescuing" a diver. Hauser herself believes the whale was shielding her. Whether that is what was really happening is a harder question, and the answer says a lot about how scientists study animal behaviour.

What happened in the water off Rarotonga

Hauser has studied whales for close to three decades and runs the Center for Cetacean Research and Conservation in the Cook Islands. On the day of the encounter she was in the water near the reef when an adult humpback approached her directly. Rather than passing by, it stayed with her, pressing against her and pushing her through the water with its head and mouth.

She has described the contact as relentless. In her account to The Independent she said she had never met a whale so tactile, and that it kept trying to place her on its head, belly or back. The physical risk was real: an adult humpback typically measures 14 to 15 metres and can weigh around 40 tonnes, so even a gentle flick of a flipper or tail can break bones. Hauser later said she came out of the water bruised.

Her instinct was to stay calm. She has said she did not want the animal to sense panic, while privately expecting the encounter could end badly. A second humpback was also active nearby, slapping its tail, and only later did Hauser and her team conclude that a large tiger shark had been close by during the episode.

Nan Hauser’s Humpback Encounter: A Rescue Interpretation and Its Limits

Nan Hauser / Caters News Agency

The shark and the size estimates

Hauser estimated the tiger shark at around 17 feet (about 5 metres). She also said local fishermen and divers had seen a very large tiger shark around the same reef and described it as being the size of a pickup truck, with some claiming 20 feet. Those figures come from eyewitness estimates, not measurement, and sizes judged underwater are notoriously unreliable. Tiger sharks commonly reach 3 to 4 metres, and large individuals beyond that are well documented, so a big animal is plausible even if the exact length is not confirmed.

What the footage clearly shows is a whale in prolonged, close contact with a swimmer. It does not, on its own, show the whale and the shark interacting, or the whale tracking the shark's movements.

Nan Hauser’s Humpback Encounter: A Rescue Interpretation and Its Limits

Nan Hauser / Caters News Agency

Why Hauser thinks the whale was protecting her

Hauser's interpretation is not a random guess. She pointed to published research by the marine ecologist Robert Pitman of the US National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, which documented humpbacks charging into killer whale attacks on other species.

Pitman's team, writing in Marine Mammal Science in 2016, compiled 115 recorded encounters between humpbacks and mammal-hunting killer whales spanning about six decades. According to National Geographic's report on the study, only around 11 percent of those attacks were aimed at humpbacks; the rest targeted seals, sea lions, porpoises and other animals. In one widely shared case a humpback rolled onto its back with a Weddell seal resting on its chest, apparently keeping the seal out of reach of the orcas. Humpbacks were also seen interfering when killer whales hunted gray whale calves in Monterey Bay.

Hauser saw a parallel. If a humpback will hide a seal under its flipper, she reasoned, it may treat a small, vulnerable swimmer in a similar way when a predator is around. In a statement after the video spread she described the behaviour Pitman recorded as genuine altruism.

What the research can and cannot tell us

Pitman himself was cautious about motive. His starting point, as he told National Geographic, is that animals generally act in their own interest, even when the reason is not obvious to us. The study suggested that humpbacks may simply react to the calls of hunting killer whales and charge in without knowing which species is under attack. Because calves return to their mothers' feeding and breeding grounds, humpbacks in one area are often related, so mobbing killer whales can protect kin. Rescuing a seal may be a side effect of a strategy that evolved to protect humpback calves.

That matters for Rarotonga. Tiger sharks are not known as serious predators of adult humpbacks, and the encounter is a single event filmed from one point of view. Other explanations remain possible: the whale may have been curious, may have been reacting to the shark for its own sake, or may have been showing a kind of social or play behaviour that happened to involve a person. None of these can be ruled out from the video.

The honest summary is that a very experienced observer felt protected, that there is solid published evidence of humpbacks interfering with predators on behalf of other species, and that the whale's actual intention in this case cannot be proven. Calling it the first documented rescue of a human, as many 2018 headlines did, goes further than the evidence allows.

Humpbacks in the Cook Islands

Humpback whales migrate between cold, food-rich polar waters in summer and warm tropical breeding grounds in winter, sometimes travelling up to 8,000 kilometres in one direction. The Cook Islands host one of the breeding subpopulations of the South Pacific (Oceania) stock, and the whales arrive roughly between July and October to mate and give birth.

The species is a conservation success story. Commercial whaling pushed the global population down to roughly 5,000 animals by the 1960s. Today the IUCN estimates about 135,000 humpbacks worldwide and lists the species as Least Concern, although some isolated groups, such as the small Arabian Sea population, remain endangered. Hauser's own work has focused on tracking these migrations and pushing for protection of the region's whales.

Why you should not try this yourself

The most useful lesson from the video is not that whales will save you. It is that close contact with a 40-tonne animal is dangerous for both sides. Hauser has pointed out the irony herself: she drafts rules against whale harassment and never touches the animals she studies unless they are sick or stranded, yet here she was being handled by a whale.

Wildlife agencies are consistent on this point. NOAA advises boaters to stay at least 100 yards from whales, and US federal law requires that distance around humpbacks in Hawaii and Alaska. It also asks people never to touch, feed, ride or swim with wild marine mammals, to limit viewing to about 30 minutes, and to leave slowly if animals seem disturbed. Rules differ by country, and the Cook Islands have their own whale-watching guidelines, so check locally before getting in the water.

If a whale approaches you while swimming, experts generally recommend staying calm, avoiding sudden movements, not reaching out to touch it, and moving away gently when you can. Hauser's calm reaction is probably one reason she came out with bruises rather than worse.

Common myths about whale "rescues"

Myth: whales understand that humans are in danger. There is no evidence that whales assess danger the way people do. They react to cues such as sounds, movement and the presence of predators.

Myth: the video proves altruism. It shows close contact and a nearby shark. Altruism in the scientific sense requires showing that one animal pays a cost to benefit another, and that cannot be established from one clip.

Myth: friendly whales are safe to touch. Even well-meant contact can injure a swimmer or stress the animal, which is why touching is discouraged or illegal in many places.

The encounter remains a remarkable piece of footage and a reminder of how much is still unknown about humpback behaviour. Treating it as a question rather than a proof is what keeps it interesting.

Sources: Video and photos by Nan Hauser (via Caters News Agency); Hauser's account as reported by The Independent (January 2018); National Geographic on Pitman et al. (2016); Wikipedia: Humpback whale; NOAA Fisheries: marine life viewing guidelines.

COMMENTS