George Land's Creativity Test: Does School Kill Creative Thinking?

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-12-29.

George Land’s Creativity Test: Does School Shrink Creative Thinking?

Featured image: Shutterstock.

The story goes like this: a test designed for NASA found that 98% of five-year-olds were "creative geniuses", but only 2% of adults were. The figures come from systems theorist George Land and his co-author Beth Jarman, and they are real in the sense that Land reported them. What they actually measured, though, is narrower than the viral headline suggests. The test looked at divergent thinking, the knack of producing many different ideas, and the results say nothing directly about intelligence. They also cannot prove on their own that school is the culprit.

Here is where the numbers come from, what they mean, what other research says about creativity and schooling, and how adults can get some of that childhood idea-generating ability back.

Where the famous numbers come from

George Land described the study in Breakpoint and Beyond: Mastering the Future Today, a business book he wrote with Beth Jarman in the early 1990s, and later in a TEDx talk. According to Land, he had developed a test to help NASA pick innovative engineers and scientists. He then wondered whether creativity was something people were born with or something they learned, so in 1968 he gave the same test to 1,600 children aged three to five enrolled in a Head Start programme.

The results he reported were:

  • Age 5: 98% scored in the highest category.
  • Age 10: the same children retested, 30%.
  • Age 15: 12%.
  • Adults: about 2% of some 280,000 adults tested.

Land's own summary, as quoted in accounts of the book, was that "non-creative behavior is learned."

A few cautions apply. The NASA connection rests on Land's account; no NASA publication describing the test is widely available. The study was never published in a peer-reviewed journal, so independent researchers have not been able to check the method, the scoring or how "genius level" was defined. The adult figure comes from a different group of people, not from the same children grown up. And the oft-repeated claim that the results were "replicated more than a million times" is not supported by any published data that we could find.

What divergent thinking is, and is not

The psychologist J. P. Guilford popularised the distinction between two styles of thinking in the 1950s. Convergent thinking narrows down to a single best answer, the kind of thinking a maths test rewards. Divergent thinking spreads outward, generating many possible answers to an open question, such as "How many uses can you think of for a paper clip?"

Tests of divergent thinking, including the Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking that grew out of Guilford's work, usually score answers on fluency (how many ideas), flexibility (how many different categories), originality (how unusual the ideas are) and elaboration (how much detail). Young children do well on several of these because they are uninhibited. They will happily suggest using a paper clip as a tiny sword for an ant.

That is a real and valuable ability, but it is only one ingredient of creativity. Producing something genuinely new and useful also requires knowledge, skill, judgement and persistence, which children are still developing. Divergent thinking is also not the same thing as intelligence. A five-year-old who scores highly is wonderfully imaginative, not a hidden genius in the everyday sense of the word.

Does school really shrink creativity?

The idea that schooling squeezes imagination out of children is popular and not without support. Educator Ken Robinson's 2006 TED talk "Do schools kill creativity?" became one of the most watched talks ever. Researcher Kyung Hee Kim reportedly found that average scores on the Torrance tests among American schoolchildren had been falling since about 1990, and earlier studies identified a "fourth-grade slump" in creative test scores.

Still, several factors besides school could explain why scores drop with age:

  • Normal development. As children learn how the world works, they naturally filter out ideas that are impossible or impractical. That is a gain in judgement, even if it lowers an idea count.
  • Social awareness. Older children become sensitive to looking foolish and start censoring unusual answers.
  • Test design. A test that rewards quantity and oddness will favour the least self-critical group.
  • Wider culture. Screens, scheduling and less free play may matter as much as classrooms.

The original version of this story went further and argued that schools were deliberately designed by a ruling elite to dull children's minds, citing John Taylor Gatto's The Underground History of American Education (2000). Gatto, a former New York teacher, was a sharp critic of compulsory schooling, and his book is worth reading as a polemic. But it is an argument, not evidence from Land's data, and many teachers work hard to encourage exactly the curiosity the test rewards. A fairer conclusion is that classrooms built around single right answers, rigid timetables and fear of mistakes do little to nurture divergent thinking, and some can discourage it.

How adults can rebuild creative thinking

Land's practical advice was simple: judge less, stay curious, and notice how fear and anxiety shut down the flow of ideas. Research on creativity broadly agrees, and offers some concrete habits.

  • Separate generating from judging. In brainstorming, write down every idea first and evaluate later. Mixing the two kills fluency.
  • Practise on purpose. Set a timer and list as many uses as you can for an everyday object. Like any skill, divergent thinking improves with practice.
  • Sleep well. Sleep, and especially dreaming, seems to help the brain recombine memories in new ways. A 2010 review by neuroscientists Yuval Nir and Giulio Tononi in Trends in Cognitive Sciences describes the brain activity behind dreaming.
  • Move. Regular exercise reduces stress and anxiety. In animal studies it also boosts the growth of new neurons in the hippocampus, a process called adult neurogenesis; how much this happens in adult humans is still debated.
  • Calm the mind. Meditation, yoga and walks in nature are commonly used to lower stress, which makes playful thinking easier.
  • Question your assumptions. Many of our beliefs come from culture and habit rather than careful thought. Asking "What if the opposite were true?" is a classic creative prompt.
  • Mix with different people. Ideas often come from combining knowledge across fields.

Myths to set aside

"NASA proved we are born geniuses." The figures come from Land's own reports in a business book, not from a NASA study, and they measure divergent thinking rather than genius.

"School makes us dumber." Intelligence test scores generally rise with schooling. The claim, at most, is that one particular kind of creative thinking tends to fall with age.

"Creativity is a fixed trait." Land's own conclusion was the opposite: if non-creative habits are learned, they can be unlearned.

"Adults cannot become creative again." Creative output in many fields peaks in adulthood, when imagination is combined with expertise. Children have the raw material; adults have the tools to use it.

Why the story still matters

Even with all the caveats, Land's numbers resonate because most people recognise the pattern in themselves: the young child who saw a castle in every cardboard box becomes the adult who worries about saying something silly in a meeting. The lesson is not that schools are a conspiracy, but that imagination needs room, encouragement and permission to be wrong, at every age. Parents and teachers can make space for open-ended play and questions with no single answer, and adults can give themselves the same freedom.

Sources: Creativity at Work: George Land's creativity test; Wikipedia: Divergent thinking; Wikipedia: Torrance Tests of Creative Thinking; Nir & Tononi (2010), Dreaming and the brain; The Mind Unleashed (original reference).

COMMENTS