An illustration can turn a broad concern into one memorable arrangement of figures and objects. Its power comes partly from compression: a complex issue becomes visible at a glance.
This collection brings together different visual arguments and the captions attached to them in the 2017 feature.
The images invite interpretation and disagreement. A strong metaphor can be effective without supplying a complete explanation of the issue it addresses.
“The true terrorists of our world do not meet at the docks at midnight, or scream “Allahu Akbar” before some violent action. The true terrorists of our world wear 5000 dollar suits and work in the highest positions of finance, government and business.” — Peter Joseph/Artist Credit: Gunduz Agayev
Got milk?/Artist Credit: Unknown
A critical image about judgment in online interaction; the caption should not assign the same behaviour to every Facebook user. Artist credit: Unknown.
An image contrasting outward confidence with an imagined inner condition. Appearance and speech do not establish a mental-health diagnosis. Artist credit: Unknown.
Addicted…/Artist Credit: Asaf Hanuka
An illustration raising questions about labour and the supply chains behind consumer goods. A specific trafficking allegation requires evidence beyond the image. Artist credit: John Holcroft.
If you aren’t careful, other people’s opinions and labels will not only stick to you, they will start to drain the life out of you too/Artist Credit: Brecht Vandenbroucke
Santa’s real little Elves…/Artist Credit: Asaf Hanuka
A critical illustration about food and health; equating medical conditions with terrorism is an editorial metaphor, not a factual or clinical explanation./Artist Credit: Gunduz Agayev
“Only when the last tree has been cut down, the last fish been caught, and the last stream poisoned, will we realize we cannot eat money.” — Attribution unresolved; the earlier label “Native Prophecy” did not identify a source/Artist Credit: Unknown
After Snow White ate the poison apple, from the evil witch, she fell asleep and became unconscious… think about that/Artist Credit: Cinismo Ilustrado
The modern day slave/Artist Credit: Gunduz Agayev
“… How do we consume as much of your time and conscious attention as possible?” — Former Facebook president explaining how Facebook was designed (Source)/Artist Credit: Makkah Newspaper
“We were all humans until race disconnected us, religion separated us, politics divided us and wealth classified us.” — Unknown/Artist Credit: Brecht Vandenbroucke
Perspective/Artist Credit: Vin Paneccasio
More perspective…/Artist Credit: Vin Paneccasio
Sometimes a mother has to be a father, and sometimes a father has to be a mother. #singleparents/Artist Credit: Igor Morski
An illustration inviting discussion of money, coercion and sexual exploitation. Consensual adult sex work and trafficking are distinct, and a picture cannot establish anyone’s motives or justify a moral judgment about a whole group./Artist Credit: Luis Quiles
Inspired by Gavin Nascimento, Founder of A New Kind of Human
The image and its caption make different claims
An illustration can connect wealth, consumption, technology or power in a single forceful image. Its compression is useful for expression, but it may leave out distinctions that would matter in a factual account. A metaphor is an invitation to examine an idea, not independent proof that every part of it is true.
Read the caption and image separately first. Which claim comes from the artwork, and which was added by the person sharing it? Several credits and quotations in this archive have unresolved attribution. Those limits should remain visible. A thoughtful response can agree with a concern while questioning a sweeping caption, especially when it assigns motives to whole groups or equates different experiences without evidence.
Continue with a related feature: Asaf Hanuka's The Realist: Everyday Life Through Visual Metaphor.
Reading the caption separately
A caption may have been written by someone other than the artist. It can narrow an open metaphor into a particular accusation or attach a quotation whose source remains unresolved. Reading those layers separately gives the artwork room while keeping factual responsibility clear. Agreement with a concern does not require endorsing every phrase added during the image’s circulation.
COMMENTS