Do People Who Like Dark Humour Have Higher IQs? What a Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-11-11.

Only Highly Intelligent People Will Laugh At These Jokes

Is there a link between enjoying dark jokes and being clever? One often-cited study suggests there is, at least in part. In 2017 researchers at the Medical University of Vienna found that people who both understood and enjoyed grim, morbid cartoons tended to score higher on IQ tests, were better educated, were in a better mood and reported less aggression. That does not mean laughing at a sick joke proves you are a genius, but it does tell us something interesting about what our brains do when a joke crosses a line.

Here is what the research actually measured, what it can and cannot tell us, and a few dark jokes so you can test your own reaction.

Start with a joke

Try this one, an old bar-room classic in our own retelling. Two men are drinking on the terrace of a rooftop bar. One of them swears his beer is magic, takes a big gulp, steps off the edge, loops around the building in mid-air and lands gently back on his stool. The other man is amazed, grabs the glass, drinks the lot and jumps. He drops straight to the pavement fifteen floors below. The barman wipes the counter, sighs, and says that Superman really is unbearable after a few drinks.

Did you laugh, wince, or both? That split second of hesitation is exactly what psychologists are interested in. To "get" the joke you have to hold several things in your head at once: the setup, the hidden identity of the first drinker, the reversal at the end and the fact that someone has just died. Then you have to decide whether you find that funny.

What the Vienna study found

The research was led by Ulrike Willinger with a team of colleagues and published in the journal Cognitive Processing in 2017. They recruited 156 adults, 76 of them women, with an average age of 33.

Each volunteer looked at 12 cartoons from The Black Book (Das schwarze Buch) by the German cartoonist Uli Stein. The drawings made light of death, illness, disability and similar grim topics. In one, a pathologist is seen rummaging deep inside a body while a nurse explains that the autopsy is over and he is only looking for his watch.

Participants rated how well they understood each cartoon and how much they enjoyed it. They then took verbal and non-verbal intelligence tests and filled in questionnaires about their mood, aggressive tendencies and education.

Three broad groups

When the researchers sorted people by their answers, three patterns stood out:

  • High understanding, high enjoyment: this group had the highest verbal and non-verbal IQ scores, more years of education, the best mood and the lowest aggression.
  • Moderate understanding, lowest enjoyment: average IQ, but the most negative mood and the highest aggression scores.
  • Moderate understanding and moderate enjoyment: average IQ, generally positive mood and moderate aggression.

Age and gender did not seem to matter. One notable detail, reported by the British Psychological Society's Research Digest, is that the data gave no support to the stereotype that people who love black humour are grumpy or hostile. If anything, the reverse was true.

Why intelligence might help you "get" dark humour

The authors described processing black humour as a complex information-processing task. To find a dark cartoon funny you need to spot the incongruity, work out the hidden logic that resolves it, and at the same time keep enough emotional distance from the grim subject that you can treat it as play rather than as a real tragedy.

That combination of quick reasoning and emotional control is probably why the link showed up. Puns and wordplay also demand mental agility, since you have to juggle two meanings of the same word, but they rarely ask you to step away from something upsetting. Dark humour asks for both skills at once.

Mood seems to matter too. People who are already feeling low or irritable may simply not be in a state to enjoy a playful take on death and disease. That fits wider research showing that bad mood dampens appreciation of most kinds of humour, not just the dark kind.

What the study does not show

It is easy to turn a modest finding into a viral headline, so a few cautions are worth keeping in mind.

  • It is a correlation. The study found that certain traits tend to appear together. It did not show that liking dark jokes makes you smarter, or that being smart makes you like them.
  • One sample, one set of cartoons. 156 Austrian adults and 12 drawings by one cartoonist are a narrow base. Different jokes, cultures or age groups might give different results.
  • Self-reported mood and aggression. Questionnaires capture how people describe themselves, which is not always how they behave.
  • Not liking a joke is not failing to understand it. Plenty of people understand a dark joke perfectly well and still find it unkind, especially if it touches on a loss they have lived through.

So if you groan instead of laugh, that says nothing about your intelligence. Taste, timing, culture and personal history all shape what we find funny.

Myth check: "Only highly intelligent people will laugh"

Headlines that promise only geniuses will laugh at a list of jokes are a staple of viral websites. They are flattering and shareable, but they twist the science. The Vienna results describe averages across groups. Many people with high IQ scores dislike black humour, and many people who love it would not stand out on an intelligence test. Treat such claims as a fun hook, not a diagnosis.

A line often attributed to Tina Fey captures the difference between audience comedy and the darker taste of comedy writers: "If you want to make comedy writers laugh, you push an actual old lady down the stairs." It is a joke about jokes, and it makes the same point as the study in a single sentence: the darker the material, the more the listener has to bring to it.

A few dark jokes to test yourself

Here is a short selection. Some are well-known one-liners from stand-up comedians, others are anonymous riddles that have circulated for decades, retold in our own words.

  • Comedian Demetri Martin: "'I'm sorry' and 'I apologize' mean the same thing. Except at a funeral."
  • Why do cannibals avoid eating clowns? Because the meal would taste a bit funny.
  • Comedian Steven Wright: "If at first you don't succeed, then skydiving definitely isn't for you."
  • A comedian once observed that his vest would turn into a jacket if he ever lost both arms. (Usually credited to the late Mitch Hedberg.)
  • At the funeral of Muppets creator Jim Henson, what did Kermit say? Not a word.
  • Cats famously have nine lives, which, as one British comic has put it, makes them the perfect lab animal. (A line associated with Jimmy Carr.)

If several of these made you smile, you are in good company. If none did, you are also in good company. Either way, it is kind to think about who is listening before you share them: a joke about death lands very differently with someone who is grieving.

The takeaway

Dark humour is a mental workout. Enjoying it seems to draw on reasoning, emotional distance and a reasonably good mood, and the 2017 Vienna study found that people who do all three well also tend to score higher on intelligence tests. That is an interesting finding about how humour works, not a test you pass or fail. Laugh at what you find funny, skip what you do not, and leave the IQ claims to the viral headlines.

Sources: BPS Research Digest, January 2017: If you like sick jokes, maybe it's because you're just so smart (on Willinger et al., Cognitive Processing, 2017); joke selection originally compiled by Reader's Digest and shared by Mystical Raven.

COMMENTS