The Miss Iraq and Miss Israel Selfie That Prompted Debate in 2017

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-11-21.

The Miss Iraq and Miss Israel Selfie That Prompted Debate in 2017

“Beauty will save the world” ―Fyodor Dostoyevsky


As contestants for Miss Universe 2017 are gathering in Las Vegas, it isn't surprising that many have been grabbing selfie opportunities together.


Nevertheless, when Miss Iraq, Sarah Idan, posted a selfie with her fellow contestant Miss Israel, Adar Gandelsman, they might not have expected the mixed reaction that followed on social media.


Ms. Gandelsman shared a similar picture on her Instagram calling Miss Iraq "amazing". Her post received almost 3,000 'likes'. However, as one could guess, there were many negative comments, as Israel and Iraq don't maintain diplomatic ties.


Miss Iraq replied to the comments, saying that miss Israel's idea for the selfie aimed to send a powerful message for world peace.


Peace and Love from Miss Iraq and Miss Israel ❤️❤️💕💕 #missuniverse

A post shared by Sarah Idan (Sarai) سارة عيدان (@sarahidan) on

A personal gesture meets a public argument

The selfie was presented by the participants as an expression of peace, while viewers brought a much wider political context to it. Those two scales help explain the reaction: an ordinary act between individuals can acquire meanings far beyond the moment in which it was made. Their stated intention deserves to be distinguished from interpretations added by an audience.

People are not substitutes for governments

The photograph does not resolve a conflict or make either woman responsible for every action associated with her country. It can still invite a conversation about the space for personal contact across political divisions. Keeping the 2017 setting and the participants' own captions visible makes that conversation more grounded than treating the image as proof of a sweeping political conclusion.

What happened after the selfie

Idan, who holds both US and Iraqi citizenship, posted the photograph on Instagram on 13 November 2017. She later said she woke to “calls from my family and the Miss Iraq Organization going insane” and described the online death threats as “so scary”. Iraqi government officials reportedly warned that she would lose her national title if she did not remove the photo. She agreed to post a follow-up message saying it did not endorse the Israeli government or its policies, but the pressure continued, and her family left Iraq. By December 2017 she said she was afraid to go back, as renewing her Iraqi passport would mean returning to obtain a new national ID card. As of December 2017 the post was still on her account.

Sources: CBS News, 18 December 2017: Miss Iraq Universe threatened for selfie with Miss Israel

COMMENTS