Originally published 2017-10-05.
In October 2017, officials in Antalya, southern Turkey, said that radar and scanning work beneath the Church of St Nicholas in Demre had revealed an intact older structure and a possible burial area. They suggested the body of Saint Nicholas, the fourth-century bishop behind the Santa Claus legend, might still lie there. That has never been proven. The bones venerated in Bari, Italy, since 1087 remain the best-documented candidate, and a sarcophagus found at Demre in 2024 had not been identified when it was announced.

The interior of the Byzantine Church of St Nicholas at Demre, ancient Myra, in Antalya Province. Photograph: Anadolu Agency/Getty Images
The story travelled fast because of its festive angle: headlines spoke of "Santa's tomb". Behind the headlines is a more interesting question about a real bishop, a medieval relic raid and two towns, one Turkish and one Italian, that both care deeply about where he rests.
What the Antalya officials actually said in 2017
The announcement came from Cemil Karabayram, head of Antalya's office for surveying and monuments, in interviews with the Turkish press. According to Hürriyet Daily News, the team had spent about three months studying the church with geo-radar and a CT-style scan. They reported a well-preserved earlier temple under the present floor and a "special section" that some hoped might be a tomb.
Nobody could simply dig down. The floor above the space is covered with decorated stones and mosaics that conservators must document and lift one by one before anyone can enter. Karabayram was hopeful but careful, telling the newspaper: "We will reach the ground and maybe we will find the untouched body of St. Nicholas."
His case rested on a local reading of history. He said records showed that the church had been damaged and rebuilt, and that the bones taken by merchants from Bari during that period may have belonged to another priest. Professor Yıldız Ötüken of Hacettepe University, who led excavations at Demre for about two decades, was reported to share the view that the saint could still be in a special part of the building. An interdisciplinary team of eight academics was assigned to the project.
Who Saint Nicholas was
Very little about Nicholas can be documented with certainty. Tradition says he was born in Patara, on the coast of Lycia, to a wealthy Christian family, became bishop of nearby Myra and died there on 6 December in the mid-fourth century, around 343. His feast day is still 6 December in churches using the Gregorian calendar and 19 December in those following the Julian calendar.
Most of his famous stories are later legends. The best known has him secretly throwing purses of gold through a poor man's window so that the man's three daughters would have dowries and escape prostitution. The earliest full version of that story dates from the ninth century. Another, in which he slaps the heretic Arius at the Council of Nicaea in 325, first appears around a thousand years after the event, and the main contemporary writers on the council never mention him.
What is certain is his reach. Nicholas became one of the most widely venerated saints in both the Greek East and the Latin West, patron of sailors, children, merchants and whole cities. He was a Greek-speaking bishop of the Roman Empire, which is why many Orthodox Christians, especially Greeks and Russians, see a visit to Myra as a pilgrimage.

A fresco of Saint Nicholas of Myra, venerated in Bari as "Saint Nicholas of Bari". Photograph: F Dagli Orti/De Agostini/Getty
How the bones reached Bari and Venice
By the late eleventh century, Byzantine control over Anatolia had collapsed after the Battle of Manzikert in 1071, and Myra was exposed. In spring 1087, sailors from Bari landed, overcame the objections of the Greek monks guarding the tomb and carried off the main bones. The relics arrived in Bari on 9 May 1087, a date the city still celebrates. Two years later Pope Urban II placed them in the crypt of the new Basilica di San Nicola, where they lie today.
Venice did not want to be left out. According to a single chronicle written by an anonymous monk, a Venetian fleet stopped at Myra around 1100 and collected the fragments the Bari sailors had left behind. These went to the church of San Nicolò al Lido. Later studies concluded that the Bari and Venice bones are compatible with a single skeleton, which supports the idea that both came from the same grave.
Demre's church also holds a damaged ancient sarcophagus, found in excavations that began in 1988 under Professor Ötüken, which was long taken to be the tomb the sailors broke open. That is part of why the 2017 claim was controversial: it implied that the medieval raiders had emptied the wrong grave.
The church at Demre, ancient Myra
The modern town of Demre sits on and around the ruins of Myra, which also has a large Roman theatre and Lycian rock-cut tombs. The church dedicated to Nicholas was built in the sixth century on the site of an older church associated with him, and was repaired several times, including with support from the Byzantine emperor Justinian I. Over centuries floods and silt partly buried it, which is one reason archaeologists believe earlier levels may survive beneath it.
In the nineteenth century Russia funded a restoration that added a bell tower and changed parts of the Byzantine design. Orthodox worship there largely ended in the early 1920s, when the Greek Orthodox community of Demre had to leave under the population exchange between Greece and Turkey. Today the building is a museum on UNESCO's tentative list for World Heritage status, and an Orthodox liturgy is held there on some feast days.
Excavations and the 2024 sarcophagus
Excavation work under Turkey's Ministry of Culture and Tourism continued after 2017, with drilling starting in 2022. In December 2024 the expedition leader, Professor Ebru Fatma Fındık, announced that a sarcophagus had been found in a two-storey structure on the south side of the church courtyard. She described it as the first sarcophagus uncovered inside the church complex and suggested that gravel and sand left by a flood or tsunami had helped preserve it.
The catch, as the National Catholic Register noted, is that its contents had not been examined and identified when the news broke. Fındık said she believed it might hold the saint, but geologists and other specialists still had to study it. Turkish officials have also been open about the tourism value a confirmed tomb would bring.
Why the claim is hard to prove either way
Archaeology can show that a space is a burial, date the structure, and sometimes date bones by radiocarbon. It cannot easily put a name on a fourth-century skeleton. There is no known living descendant to compare DNA with, and no detailed written description of Nicholas's body. Even the Bari relics have been studied mainly to show they are ancient and consistent with an elderly man, not to prove identity.
In 2017, researchers at the University of Oxford radiocarbon-dated a fragment of pelvis kept in Lyon, France, to the fourth century, the right era for Nicholas. Whether it belongs to the same person as the Bari and Venice bones would need DNA comparison. Relics of Nicholas are also claimed by churches in Russia, Germany, the United States and elsewhere, many of them small fragments given away over the centuries.
So a find at Demre, however beautiful, will most likely raise the probability of one story rather than close the case. A good rule when you see "saint's tomb found" headlines: look for the words "may", "possibly" and "will be examined", and check later reports before treating the identification as settled.
From Myra to Santa Claus
The jump from a Lycian bishop to a man in a red suit took more than a thousand years. In the Low Countries, Nicholas became Sinterklaas, who brings children gifts around 5 and 6 December. Dutch settlers carried the custom to New Amsterdam, later New York, and in nineteenth-century America the figure merged with other winter traditions into Santa Claus, the name itself a version of Sinterklaas.
That is why the Demre story caught the world's imagination. Whether or not the saint's bones lie under that floor, the place where he served as bishop is real, and you can visit it: the church is an easy stop on the Lycian coast between Kaş and Antalya.
Sources: Hürriyet Daily News, 5 October 2017: Body of St Nicholas buried in Demre, claim officials; The Guardian, October 2017 (original report); National Catholic Register / CNA, December 2024; Wikipedia: Saint Nicholas; Wikipedia: St. Nicholas Church, Demre. Photographs: Anadolu Agency/Getty Images; F Dagli Orti/De Agostini/Getty.

COMMENTS