
On the morning of 11 September 2001, hijackers flew two airliners into the World Trade Center in New York, a third into the Pentagon, and a fourth crashed in a field near Shanksville, Pennsylvania. The attacks killed 2,977 people, not counting the 19 hijackers, among them 343 New York firefighters. Few events have been photographed so heavily: news crews, office workers, tourists and residents all pointed cameras at the towers, and audiences around the world watched live.
The best-known images, such as the second plane's fireball or the dust-covered survivors, are familiar to almost everyone. The eighteen photographs below are less often seen. Some were taken by professionals, including James Nachtwey, Alex Webb and Patrick Witty; others by people who happened to be at a window, on a bridge or on the street with a camera. Many were collected by journalist David Friend for his book Watching the World Change, which tells the stories behind the photographs of that day. They are grouped here roughly in the order of the morning, with the photographer credited under each one.
8:46 a.m.: the first attack
American Airlines Flight 11 struck the North Tower at 8:46 a.m. For the first minutes, many New Yorkers assumed it was a terrible accident.
Wolfgang Staehle
German-born artist Wolfgang Staehle had a camera trained on lower Manhattan from Brooklyn for a gallery exhibition, taking a fresh frame every few seconds. His sequence caught American Airlines Flight 11 as a tiny speck in the upper right of the frame moments before impact. It is regarded as the only known still image of the plane taken that day before the crash. A time code is visible in the corner of each frame.
Photographer Patricia McDonough shot this through a fish-eye lens from an apartment window four blocks away, minutes after the first impact. The calm room, with its potted plants on the sill, makes the plume of smoke from the North Tower all the more jarring. It shows how close the disaster was to ordinary homes.
9:03 a.m.: the second plane
Seventeen minutes later, United Airlines Flight 175 hit the South Tower at 9:03 a.m. From that moment it was clear the city was under attack.
Rob Howard leaned out of his window near Rector Street and Broadway with a medium-format camera and caught Flight 175 a split second before it struck the South Tower, with the North Tower already pouring black smoke. The plane appears small and almost calm against the sky, which is what makes the frame so hard to look at.
Marc A. Garrett later wrote that the second plane passed directly over his head before hitting the South Tower, and that it took him a few seconds to collect himself before taking this picture. The fireball and debris are still spreading from the tower. He later shared the image on Flickr.
Seen from beyond the Brooklyn Bridge, the second tower erupts in flame while the first is already burning. Sara K. Schwittek's pair of frames for Reuters shows the bridge before and after the explosion. The distance and the familiar landmark in the foreground help explain how many people across the river witnessed the attack directly.
Architect and amateur pilot Isabel Daser, eight months pregnant, asked a co-worker to take her portrait as a record of the day, before anyone around her understood that this was a deliberate attack, according to the account published with the photo. The date stamp reads 11 9 2001. The smoking towers are visible in the background, small and distant above a street full of onlookers.
Street photographer Melanie Einzig captured a man in work clothes walking along the pavement with a long roll under his arm while the towers burn behind him. The picture has often been shared under the title "A man has a job to do." It records something that many people described afterwards: the strange way normal routines carried on for a while around the catastrophe.
Trapped above the impact zones by fire and smoke, more than 200 people fell or jumped from the towers. David Surowiecki's photograph shows several figures against the side of the building. Images like this were rarely published at the time out of respect for the victims and their families; it is included here as part of the historical record, and readers may wish to pause before scrolling on.
9:59 a.m.: the South Tower falls
The South Tower, hit second, collapsed first, at 9:59 a.m. after burning for 56 minutes. A huge cloud of dust and debris surged through the streets of lower Manhattan.
At the corner of Park Row and Beekman Street, Patrick Witty photographed a cluster of bystanders gazing upward as the South Tower began to come down. Their faces show disbelief rather than panic; most still had no idea the building could fall.
Photojournalist Bolivar Arellano was close to the towers when the South Tower started to break apart, and his frame shows the top of the building disintegrating in a burst of debris beside the still-standing North Tower.
War photographer James Nachtwey photographed the South Tower collapsing behind the cross on top of Trinity Church. The image, taken for Time, sets the old church against the falling skyscraper. Nachtwey had spent years photographing conflicts abroad; this time the war came to his own neighbourhood.
People sprint down Broadway as a wall of smoke and dust rolls up the street behind them. Kelly Price's photograph for Reuters captures the moment the collapse turned into a physical threat for everyone in the area. Many survivors later said they could not see their own hands inside the cloud.
In a second frame by Price, a single man runs alone down the middle of Broadway with the cloud filling the street behind him. The empty roadway, normally packed with traffic, shows how fast the area was cleared by fear.
10:28 a.m.: the North Tower falls
The North Tower came down at 10:28 a.m., 102 minutes after it was hit. The nearby 7 World Trade Center, damaged and burning, collapsed at 5:21 p.m.
Photographer Phil Penman got as close as he could before police set up a cordon, which left him right beside the towers when the first one fell. In this black-and-white frame, a church spire and an ornate street lamp stand in front of a tower dissolving into dust.
A small boy holds a pair of toy binoculars on a walkway beside the West Side Highway, with the burning towers behind him. Years later, the man in the picture recognised himself online and explained he had been four years old that morning. It is a reminder that a generation of New Yorkers has only childhood fragments of the day.
Seen from behind, a couple stands close together on a city street, a yellow cab at their side, as smoke rises from the towers in the distance. Photographer luke kurtis framed the scene so that we see only what they are looking at. The gesture of the two people says as much as any face.
The view from above and the day after
Early on 12 September, NASA's Landsat 7 satellite passed over New York and recorded a plume of smoke drifting from lower Manhattan across the harbour. Seen from orbit, the site is a small grey smudge on the tip of the island, yet the smoke would continue to rise for weeks as fires burned in the debris pile.
On a Brooklyn rooftop shortly after the towers fell, Magnum photographer Alex Webb photographed Jenna Piccirillo with three-month-old Vaughan as the smoke hung over Manhattan behind them. Webb saw the picture as a statement about resilience, saying, according to the caption published with it, that "life continues in the face of disaster . . . despite the horrors we inflict on one another."
Looking at these photographs today
Calling a photograph "rare" usually just means many people have not seen it. What matters more is what it records: a date, a street corner, a person's face, a photographer's choice of where to stand. Knowing who took the picture and where makes each frame a piece of evidence rather than a spectacle.
These images show real people on the worst day of many lives, and some of those pictured did not survive. They deserve to be looked at with care, not ranked by how shocking they are. If you want to go further, the National September 11 Memorial & Museum in New York holds a large archive of photographs and personal stories, and David Friend's book explains how many of these pictures came to be taken. For more archive photography on this site, see Photographs Remembering People Near the End of Their Lives.
Sources: Wikipedia: September 11 attacks (timeline and casualty figures); Wikipedia: Wolfgang Staehle; David Friend, Watching the World Change; photographers as credited under each image, including Phil Penman and David Surowiecki; Bored Panda (original reference).

COMMENTS