Originally published 2017-06-19.
Mild electrical brain stimulation can, under laboratory conditions, help some people crack puzzles that demand unusual thinking. In a 2017 study from Queen Mary University of London and Goldsmiths, University of London, volunteers whose left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex was briefly dampened with a weak current were more likely to solve hard "matchstick" problems. The same volunteers, however, did worse on puzzles that leaned on working memory. It is a fascinating result, but it is not a recipe for becoming more creative at home.

Illustration of transcranial direct current stimulation (tDCS), in which a weak current flows between electrodes placed on the scalp. Image adapted from the Queen Mary University of London news release via Neuroscience News.
What the study found
The paper, titled "Relaxing learned constraints through cathodal tDCS on the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex," appeared in the journal Scientific Reports on 7 June 2017. Its authors were Caroline Di Bernardi Luft, Ioanna Zioga, Michael J. Banissy and Joydeep Bhattacharya, and the work was funded by the European Commission through a project on creativity called CREAM.
Sixty volunteers solved a set of problems, received one of three treatments, then tried more problems. One group had the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex (DLPFC) suppressed, a second had it stimulated, and a third received sham stimulation, in which the device is switched on only briefly so participants cannot tell they are in the control group.
Volunteers in the suppression group were more likely than the other two groups to solve the hardest puzzles, the ones that require abandoning familiar rules. That was the creativity boost that made headlines. The catch came with a different type of problem: puzzles that require testing many moves in sequence and keeping track of them. Here the suppression group performed worse, which suggests that turning down this brain area loosens rigid habits but also weakens the mental workspace we use to juggle information.
Why quieting part of the brain might help
The DLPFC sits towards the front of the brain and is heavily involved in planning, rule-following and holding information in mind. Those are useful skills almost all the time. We learn from experience which approaches work, and the brain automates them so we do not have to think everything through from scratch.
The downside is mental fixation. When a problem needs a genuinely new approach, our learned rules can steer us back to the same dead ends. Psychologists have studied this for decades; in classic experiments, people who learn one method for solving a series of puzzles often keep using it even when a much simpler solution is available. Dr Luft described the DLPFC's rule-based shortcut as something that works well most of the time but "fails spectacularly when we encounter new problems."
The study's idea was that dialling down the DLPFC for a short time might relax those learned constraints, giving looser, less rule-bound thinking a better chance. The results fit that idea, at least for this type of task.
What matchstick puzzles test
Matchstick arithmetic problems are a favourite tool for studying insight. You see a false equation made of Roman numerals built from matchsticks, and you must make it true by moving a single stick. Some are fairly easy. For example, IV = III + III is false, but moving the vertical stick from the left of the V to its right gives VI = III + III, which is correct.
Harder versions break a deeper assumption. In III = III + III, no single change to a numeral works. The trick is to turn the plus sign into an equals sign by rotating one stick, giving III = III = III. Most people get stuck because they assume the operators are fixed and only the numbers can change. Solving it requires letting go of what you have learned about how equations normally look, which is exactly the kind of constraint relaxation the researchers wanted to measure.
Other matchstick problems are less about insight and more about search: you have to try many possible moves and remember which ones you have already checked. These lean on working memory, and that is where the suppression group lost ground.
How tDCS works, and what it is not
Transcranial direct current stimulation passes a very small, steady electrical current between two saline-soaked sponge electrodes placed on the scalp. It does not make neurons fire the way a seizure or electroconvulsive therapy does. Instead, it nudges how easily they fire. Broadly, the anodal (positive) electrode tends to make nearby neurons slightly more excitable and the cathodal (negative) electrode tends to make them slightly less excitable. In this study, cathodal stimulation over the left DLPFC was used to suppress activity there.
Typical side effects in research settings are mild: tingling or itching under the electrodes, skin redness, headache, occasional dizziness or nausea, and sometimes brief flashes of light at the start. People prone to seizures, including those with epilepsy, are usually excluded from tDCS studies.
Outside creativity research, tDCS is being studied mainly as a treatment for depression, and some devices have medical approval for that use in parts of Europe, the UK and Australia. That medical use is supervised and follows set protocols, which is very different from buying a gadget online.
Limits of the evidence
The QMUL team was careful about what their findings meant, and that caution is worth repeating. First, the effect was measured on one specific type of puzzle in a lab, not on creative work in the real world, such as writing, design or scientific discovery. Second, the same intervention made people worse at another important mental skill. A "creativity boost" that costs you working memory is not a free upgrade.
Third, the wider research on tDCS for boosting thinking in healthy people is mixed. Some reviews have found small effects; others, including a 2015 analysis of single-session studies, found no reliable overall benefit. Results also vary a lot from person to person, depending on skull thickness, electrode placement and current strength. Finally, sixty participants split across three groups is a modest sample, so the findings need repeating by other teams before anyone builds on them.
Dr Luft also warned against companies selling tDCS headsets to consumers on the promise of across-the-board brain enhancement. As she put it, "we are not yet in a position to wear an electrical hat" and expect a general cognitive gain.
Practical takeaways for creative thinking
The study's real lesson is less about electricity and more about how creativity works. Being stuck often means relying too heavily on what has worked before. You can loosen that grip without any device:
- Question the "fixed" parts of a problem. Ask which assumptions you are treating as rules, the way solvers assume the plus sign cannot move.
- Step away. A break, a walk or a night's sleep can let a fixed approach fade so a new one can surface.
- Explain the problem to someone outside your field. Their questions often expose hidden constraints.
- Separate the stages. Generate ideas loosely first, then switch to careful, detail-heavy checking, since the two modes draw on different strengths.
As for brain stimulation itself, it remains a research and clinical tool. Home devices are not a proven shortcut to creativity, and anyone thinking of trying one, especially with a health condition, should talk to a doctor first.
Sources: Luft, Zioga, Banissy and Bhattacharya, "Relaxing learned constraints through cathodal tDCS on the left dorsolateral prefrontal cortex", Scientific Reports (2017); Neuroscience News: Brain stimulation and creativity (QMUL release); Queen Mary University of London; Wikipedia: Transcranial direct-current stimulation.

COMMENTS