
Jerome Kagan, a Harvard developmental psychologist who spent more than half a century studying how children's temperaments form, became one of the best-known critics of how ADHD is diagnosed in the United States. In a 2012 interview with the German magazine Der Spiegel, he argued that the diagnosis had become a catch-all for ordinary restless or struggling children, and that drug companies and his own profession benefited from the boom.
Viral headlines later turned this into "Harvard psychologist says ADHD is a fraud". That goes further than his argument. Kagan did not claim that no child has serious problems with attention; he claimed that the label was being stretched far beyond the children who truly need it. Here is what he said, who he was, and what the wider research shows.
Who Jerome Kagan was
Kagan was born in Newark, New Jersey, on 25 February 1929, and joined Harvard's faculty in the early 1960s, later holding the Daniel and Amy Starch professorship of psychology. Apart from a year spent studying children in a village in Guatemala in the early 1970s, he worked at Harvard for the rest of his career.
His most influential research followed babies into adolescence. He found that infants who reacted strongly to unfamiliar sights and sounds, crying and thrashing, were more likely to grow into shy, cautious children, while calm infants tended to become bold and sociable. He called these temperaments "inhibited" and "uninhibited", and argued that both genes and upbringing shape how they develop. In 2002 a survey led by Steven Haggbloom ranked him 22nd among the most eminent psychologists of the 20th century, one place above Carl Jung.
In later life he became increasingly critical of psychology and psychiatry, setting out his concerns in the 2012 book Psychology's Ghosts: The Crisis in the Profession and the Way Back. He died on 10 May 2021, aged 92.
What Kagan actually said about ADHD

The definition above summarises the three groups of symptoms clinicians look for: inattention, hyperactivity and impulsivity. Kagan's complaint was not with these descriptions but with how loosely they were applied.
In the Spiegel interview, he blamed rising diagnosis rates on what he called fuzzy diagnostic practices
. His example was a seven-year-old who is bored in class and disrupts lessons. Fifty years earlier, he said, that child would simply have been called lazy; today the same child is likely to leave the doctor's office with an ADHD label and a prescription for a stimulant such as Ritalin. In his view, the existence of a convenient drug encouraged doctors to diagnose the condition it treats.
He also worried about what the label does to a child's sense of self. Telling millions of children that something is fundamentally wrong with their brains, he argued, can be harmful in itself, particularly when the real issue is a mismatch with school or a temporary difficulty.
Kagan drew on his own childhood. He described himself as a restless boy who stuttered, and recalled his mother reassuring him that his mind was simply faster than his tongue. He suggested that a child like him today might well have been given a psychiatric diagnosis.

A child who drifts off over homework is not automatically a child with a disorder. That distinction, between ordinary variation and impairment, sat at the heart of Kagan's critique.
Depression and bipolar disorder in children
Kagan applied the same reasoning to other childhood diagnoses. He pointed to a steep rise in antidepressant use by American teenagers between the late 1980s and early 2000s, which he put at roughly tenfold, and said that doctors too often reached for pills before asking why a young person was unhappy.
He drew a sharp line between two groups: people who sink into low mood after a painful event such as a loss or a family crisis, and a smaller group with a lasting biological vulnerability to depression. Both deserve help, he said, but treating them as the same illness hides the cause. He also mentioned research suggesting that people with unusually high activity in the right frontal lobe respond poorly to antidepressants, and argued that tests such as an EEG could help guide treatment.

His strongest words were reserved for paediatric bipolar disorder, which was rarely diagnosed in children before the 1990s. He accused a group of doctors at Massachusetts General Hospital of starting to label children with severe tantrums as bipolar, and said drug companies welcomed the trend because the medicines involved were expensive. He likened the wave of diagnoses to a social fashion rather than a medical discovery. In his words, critics were up against an enormously powerful alliance
of profitable pharmaceutical companies and a self-interested profession.
For children whose main problem is falling behind at school, Kagan suggested starting with practical help, such as tutoring, rather than medication.
What the research says about ADHD today
Kagan's warning about overdiagnosis has some support. Studies in several countries have found that the youngest children in a school year are noticeably more likely to be diagnosed than their oldest classmates, which suggests that normal immaturity is sometimes mistaken for a disorder. Researchers have also raised concerns about racial and socioeconomic differences in who gets diagnosed and treated.
At the same time, the mainstream view is that ADHD is a real and often serious condition. Key points from current evidence:
- It is strongly heritable. Twin studies put heritability at roughly 70 to 80 percent, similar to height.
- Diagnosis has rules. Under the DSM-5, a child needs at least six symptoms of inattention or hyperactivity-impulsivity, lasting six months or more, appearing in at least two settings such as home and school, beginning before age 12 and clearly impairing daily life.
- It often persists. Around half of children with ADHD still have some symptoms in adulthood, and untreated ADHD is linked to problems with work, relationships, accidents and substance use.
- Treatment works for many. Reviews find that medication combined with behavioural or psychological support is the most effective approach for school-age children and adults.
In other words, both things can be true: some children are diagnosed too quickly, and other children with genuine ADHD go unrecognised, especially girls whose symptoms are mostly inattentive rather than disruptive.
Common myths, on both sides
- "ADHD is just bad parenting." Family environment matters for how any child copes, but the research points mainly to genetic and neurodevelopmental causes.
- "ADHD was invented by drug companies." Descriptions of children with these traits go back more than a century. Kagan's criticism was about how widely the label is used, not about the existence of attention problems.
- "Children grow out of it." Some do, many do not.
- "If a child can focus on video games, it can't be ADHD." Intense focus on highly stimulating activities is common in ADHD; the difficulty is with tasks that are dull or demanding.
- "Every distracted child needs a diagnosis." Boredom, poor sleep, anxiety, hearing or vision problems, learning difficulties and stress at home can all look like ADHD.
What parents can take from the debate
Kagan's legacy is a reminder to ask why a child is struggling before settling on a label. If you are worried about a child's attention, behaviour or mood, talk to a doctor, ideally one who will gather information from home and school and look at other possible explanations. A careful assessment protects children from both an unnecessary diagnosis and a missed one.
Sources: Der Spiegel, 2012: interview with Jerome Kagan on overprescribing drugs to children; Wikipedia: Jerome Kagan; Harvard Gazette: Jerome Kagan, 92 (memorial minute); Wikipedia: Attention deficit hyperactivity disorder; the earlier English summary by Simon Segal appeared in Curious Mind Magazine via The Mind's Journal.

I have a feeling this guy is a little behind on the times. It says the 20th. century, hmmm, add a one to that please.
ReplyDeleteLOL. The article only said 20th when talked about how Kagan had been found to be "the 22nd most eminent...". It was the 20th century before 2000, you know that right? :DD
Delete-DD
I think the point is valid, though. I'm not a grammar nazi, and in my English degree, in applied Linguistics for teaching ESL, we looked at language in a descriptive rather that prescriptive way, looking at the ways English evolves, & how people communicate in real life--not harping on the use of "whom" in the objective case.
DeleteBut like a fake email I got from "Apple" yesterday asking me to click here to fix my passwords and attempted log-on from unknown devices--one of the reasons I instantly know it was fake is the language. Words left out, and used improperly are a tell in the cyber world. As people sit in Internet cafes around the world 24 hours a day sending a million emails, they mostly cut and paste, and many do not speak English in Nigeria, Ghana, parts of Russia, and every country who partake in cybercrime.
I've become sensitized to mistakes because of all the phishing scams I get each day saying "give us all your information so that we can send you $7 million dollars" for no reason; things like that. PS I forwarded yesterday's email to reportphishing@apple.com
The first sentence in this article makes it sound like it was written by a hacker; that's why I believe Rob's mention of the date is a valid concern. Although I agree that Big Pharma is a problem, and I am against prescribing pills/or taking pills, without consistent, regular talk therapy about the cause of the symptoms being treated (so I agree with most ideas in this article), they need to edit and rewrite if they want us to take this article seriously. Here's the first sentence:
Jerome Kagan is the most influential psychologists of the 20th century, who has the expertise and moral authority to compare psychology to a rotten piece of furniture.
By using the plural instead of "psychologist" with "the most" it sounds like bullshit. And it's just odd that the first sentence talks about rotten furniture, just as a non-sequitur. The rest of the article says nothing about furniture, nor does it end in summary by reminding us back to the kicker, so that's why a pharmaceutical company is like a sofa, or something. This writing has detracted from the article, to the point where it's lost any power to convince. I feel like they're going to ask for my Apple password at the end, so they can send help.
Shawn: Maybe I should apply your concept to your own post. Who, in this day and age, still uses the term "Internet Cafe". That is quite an old and outdated concept in the age of "free wireless" at every coffee shop, restaurant, hotel, grocery store and big box store, let alone, the use of cellular. At the least, this is true in the United States.
DeleteYour wording also could easily lead one to believe that you would, in fact, fall for a $7m giveaway if only it is grammatically correct. Personally, I would like to believe common sense would lead you to that conclusion either way.
Should I assume you are actually a Nigerian hacker trolling us due to your outdated syntax? Of course not. Sorry to troll, I just found your critique to lack credibility due to your failures being equivalent to that which you are criticizing. It is YOUR position this makes one unbelievable...not mine. lol
I agree with Shawn, and disagree with "Unknown" who hasn't enough courage to use his own name while insulting someone.
DeleteUnknown, when considering how short a time we have been using the internet, Shawn's used of the term "Internet cafe" is completely acceptable and reasonable. We all recognize that term...a term that may be outdated, but not so far in our rear view mirror.
DeleteAlso, his wording in no way leads anyone to believe he would fall for a grammatically correctly written giveaway. He was pointing out valid, red flags to look for in an unreliable document...and that was only one point.
You are correct about one thing...you are a troll. Shawn took the time to thoughtfully analyze the article, give his humble opinion, and enlightened some of us. You were simply rude.
Absolutely true, another label to control anxious children. Children need structure and discipline to feel safe and its too easy to say they have some chemical imbalance its a behavioural problem and was never heard of a 100 years ago also putting children on drugs to make them more manageable is for the adults sake and also you can get extra money from the state to care for a child who has it. This is why so many are been diagnosed and turned into zombies and chemically controlled.
ReplyDeleteI would disagree. As a child, I had structure, discipline and a safe and loving home environment. As an adult, I've been diagnosed with ADHD (primarily inattentive, I was never hyperactive). I was also told, as a child, I was a daydreamer, and lacked ambition. That I needed to get my head out of the clouds and work harder, have some drive. 100 years ago, these were the names of the "behavioural problems" now known as ADHD.
DeleteYes, there are absolutely millions of misdiagnoses due to the push from Big Pharma to get their pills out there, and by teachers who do not want to deal with children who are acting out or not paying attention. But there are some in that statistic who legitimately have something wired just a little bit differently in their brains and have varying degrees of difficulty focusing.
What I'd like to know, as one who has been diagnosed ADHD-PI, what Kagan thinks about the tendency of the ADHD mind to also hyper-focus on a stimulus or stimuli?
Thank you dreamkeeperarts! I had ADD as kid and I was told the same thing. When you are a kid and in the 1st to 3rd grade and you daydream, you are not doing it on purpose like a high school kid would. I really did want to focus but my attention span was low. Pharmaceuticals are a problem but its the people who like me that needed help when they were/are a kid are getting screwed!
DeleteI agree that there are cases of over-diagnosis. However, as a parent of a child diagnosed with ADHD, he clearly struggles. The issue is there are other options for support. Drugs are NOT always the answer. We work with a Naturopathic doctor and engage in behavioral therapy and my son is thriving as a result. Never once have we given him Ritalin or the like. The CDC recently issued an article indicating behavioral therapy can be just as successful as drugs. So, I think the issue really is the method of treatment. There is no doubt that ADHD exists, but the question is why and how to do deal with root causes versus shoving a drug down the kiddos throat.
ReplyDeleteI like what you said. How do you go about finding a "Naturopahic" doctor...then maybe it's too late. My child is already 18 and a product of huge amounts of medication that don't seem to have had any affect on his behavior. Instead he has been labeled by classmates since the 3rd grade and struggles today with very low self-esteem and has been disregarded when he should have been included in sports and other activities at school.
DeleteAs a woman with a successful career over 20 years, being diagnosed by psychiatrist at age 50, I am grateful for the diagnoses. I know have medication that will help me focus and not spend time trying so hard to concentrate and focus. I wish I had this drug while in my school years. Most days were hell. I no longer blame or beat myself up, well most days. I am not zoned out, but able to do what needs to be done without the fight in my brain. Articles as such do more damage and cause stigma for those who truly have this condition. I agree there must be professionals who make these diagnoses. I am sure many are given the meds when it is not appropriate and in the best interest of the child. There may be other issues at play that is causing the child to not understand, or be hyper, inappropriate. Also the condition presents itself differently in girls than boys.
DeleteSame story here. I was lazy and a slacker, but really smart. I was a C student because i did no work but made As on all the tests. I was quiet and was not a behavior problem so i never got any help. In high school i was an A student, but i was able to do the minimal amount. College was a nightmare because it required the attention focus and drive that i didn't need to get by in high school. After failing and changing majors a few times, i becamE a mental health practitioner. Still i struggled to remain at the same job. As a licensed clinical therapist i was pretty successful, still it was time to make official what i already knew and was diagnosed at 32. Being on medication, has made a huge difference. I wonder what would have been had i been diagnosed in high school or college, but i don't regret how things turned out because i would have an engineering degree instead of a social work degree
Delete“Let’s go back 50 years" Right. 50 years ago GMOs, massive vaccination of children, plastics and other toxins were not being dumped into our environment.
ReplyDeleteI believe Kagan is wrong, I dont think he's taking into account the advancement of technology and the rate at which we receive information and its effect on our brains neural network especially in todays children. try watching an action film from 50 years ago compared to one now, the action film from 50 years ago is going to feel like a soap oprea because were accustomed to a higher rate of stimulus (sorry about grammar and spelling)
ReplyDeleteWell the first thing wrong with this article is it says "renowned Harvard PSYCHOLOGIST" Not psychiatrist!! He is not a trained medical doctor and doesn't have the knowledge of how the brain works. So this guy is full of crap. Yes pharmaceuticals are preying on people to take medicine, some people really do have an issue with being able to focus. Doctors and scientists have been studying the brain for years and with all of the technology they still cant figure how the brain works!
ReplyDeletePlus the guy is almost 90 years old so apparently the guy is senile in his old age and not keeping up with the times and the fact that you have more synthetic hormones in food now which causes all these problems you didn't have years ago and especially when he was a kid!!
DeleteInteresting comments, y'all. My belief is simply that we need less electronic stimuli from our cell phones, TV's, computers, video games. 50 years ago I behaved in a manner that would have gotten me labeled ADHD today. Today, I don't have those issues. My wife is taking a prescription for ADHD right now, but I don't see any benefits to the drug. She spends hours attached to her cell phone, trolling facebook, texting our kids about every anything. When I take her on vacation and we go on a week long cruise, she is better by the third day and does well the rest of the trip. When she gets home and can get her cell phone again, things go sour. Psychologists need to look very hard at the impact video games and electronic gadgets have on the behavior of our children.
ReplyDeleteNow that is a very badly written or edited article. ADHD is never classed as a mental illness. If you are looking into certain behavioural issues, the right support will help you to work with your child (if they have issues at school), not as one that has a "mental ilness", but one that is "wired differently". Information is absorbed and understood in a different way by some kids for varied reasons. If you have a totally "regular" kid, then lucky you! This article does not help, as this is what some teachers, coaches love to trot out or think the minute you try to explain that certain approaches work better for your child than others... God forbid if you try to explain why you might think your child has a difficulty. It is assumed you are indulging in excuses. I have a child for which old-fashioned drill and rote learning works best due to some difficulties and teachers/coaches hate being asked to consider extra time or more explanation... they assume you are a label lover because of articles like this.
ReplyDelete