Dolphins, Pufferfish and a Documentary's Intoxication Claim

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published April 7, 2017.

Dolphins, Pufferfish and a Documentary's Intoxication Claim

Documentary footage shows dolphins handling pufferfish; the suggestion that they were seeking intoxication was an interpretation, not a demonstrated finding about their intent.Original source

The pufferfish, when in trouble, balloons and discharges a neurotoxic chemical. The account does not establish what dose, if any, the dolphins absorbed or show that their behaviour resulted from intoxication.

Dolphins, Pufferfish and a Documentary's Intoxication Claim

No safe dose or deliberate dose control by the dolphins is demonstrated here.

Produced for BBC One by the award-winning wildlife documentary producer John Downer, the images show an interaction whose meaning should not be inferred from human descriptions of pleasure. The footage's interpretation should not be treated as evidence that intoxication occurred before the pufferfish was released.

Rob Pilley, a zoologist working as a producer on the show, said “this was a case of young dolphins purposely experimenting with something we know to be intoxicating.

“After chewing the puffer gently and passing it round, they began acting most peculiarly, hanging around with their noses at the surface as if fascinated by their own reflection.

“It reminded us of that craze a few years ago when people started licking toads to get a buzz, especially the way they hung there in a daze afterwards. It was the most extraordinary thing to see.”

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)


Source: Minds, The Mind Unleashed

An intriguing observation is not proof of intoxication

Footage of dolphins handling a pufferfish does not by itself establish a chemical dose, an intoxicating effect or a deliberate search for that effect. The producer's interpretation should remain attributed rather than becoming a settled finding about dolphin behaviour. There is no demonstrated safe dose in this account, and handling wildlife or toxins is not a way to investigate it.

COMMENTS