Thordis Elva and Tom Stranger: A TED Talk on Rape and Forgiveness

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
This Woman Was Raped & Forgave Him, So They Did A Ted Talk Together

In 1996 Thordis Elva, a 16-year-old in Reykjavík, was raped by her boyfriend, Tom Stranger, an 18-year-old exchange student from Australia. Twenty years later the two of them stood on the same stage at TEDWomen 2016 and told the story together: she as the survivor, he as the man who admitted what he had done. Their talk, “Our story of rape and reconciliation”, was released by TED in February 2017 and had passed 2.7 million views by mid-March 2017, according to press reports.

It is one of the most debated talks TED has published. Some viewers found it a powerful example of a perpetrator taking full responsibility. Others felt it gave a platform to a rapist and risked suggesting that forgiveness is what survivors owe. Here is what happened, what each of them said, and why the reaction was so divided.

What happened in 1996

Stranger had come to Iceland for a year-long student exchange. He met Elva through a theatre club at their school, and they dated for just over a month. After a school Christmas dance, where she had become heavily intoxicated, he took her home and raped her. Two days later he ended the relationship, and when his exchange year finished he returned to Australia.

Elva has described spending years blaming herself and keeping silent. In the talk she rejects that self-blame in plain terms:

“The only thing that could’ve stopped me from being raped that night is the man who raped me.” — Thordis Elva, TEDWomen 2016 (as widely quoted)

That sentence is the heart of the talk for many viewers, and it matches what support organisations stress: responsibility for rape lies with the person who commits it, never with what the victim wore, drank or did.

Eight years of letters and a week in Cape Town

About nine years after the assault, Elva wrote to Stranger, describing the harm he had caused. To her surprise, he replied with a full admission. Both later said that neither had properly spoken about that night with anyone in the years between.

They kept writing to each other for roughly eight more years. Eventually they agreed to meet in person to confront the past once and for all, choosing Cape Town, South Africa, roughly halfway between Iceland and Australia. They spent a week there talking through what had happened. That meeting became the basis of their joint book, South of Forgiveness, published by Scribe in 2017 and since published in fourteen countries.

What the talk argues

The talk alternates between the two speakers. Elva speaks about trauma, shame and her decision to forgive, which she describes as something she did for her own healing rather than a gift to him. In a later interview she called forgiving someone “the complete polar opposite” of handing them something.

Stranger’s part focuses on ownership. He describes how he had told himself a more comfortable story for years, and how admitting the truth plainly, using the word rape, felt like it might destroy him. He says instead that owning the act did not erase everything else about him. A frequently quoted line sums up his argument:

“Something you’ve done doesn’t have to constitute the sum of who you are.” — Tom Stranger, TEDWomen 2016 (as widely quoted)

Both speakers also question the labels “victim” and “rapist”, arguing that if people who commit violence are simply dismissed as monsters, it becomes harder to understand and prevent that violence. Their own story illustrates a pattern that victim surveys keep finding: sexual assault is very often committed by someone the victim knows, such as a partner or friend, rather than a stranger.

Why it divided opinion

When the Women of the World festival invited the pair to discuss their book at London’s Southbank Centre in March 2017, campaigners protested. The festival first dropped the event under pressure, then reinstated it, saying the debate mattered too much to silence. On the evening of 14 March protesters gathered outside. One of them, rape survivor Diane Langford, told reporters she did not believe a rapist could ever be granted impunity.

Critics raised several concerns:

  • That a man who had committed rape was being given a celebrated platform and book sales, although organisers said he was unpaid and the pair said profits would go to charity.
  • That the talk might be read as a template, putting pressure on survivors to forgive or to engage with the person who harmed them.

Supporters answered that Elva chose this path freely, that hearing a man name his own act as rape is rare and valuable, and that the conversation reaches men who would never attend a lecture on consent. Stranger himself acknowledged at the London event that he is a problematic messenger, while arguing that there is a real hunger for the discussion.

What the numbers say about reporting

A reason the talk resonated is how rarely sexual assault is reported or discussed. Statistics Canada’s 2014 General Social Survey found that only about 5% of sexual assaults were reported to police. In the United States, the Bureau of Justice Statistics found that 33.9% of rapes and sexual assaults were reported in 2019. Figures vary by country, survey and year, but every source points the same way: most assaults never reach the police.

Research on perpetrators is also sobering. In a widely cited 2002 study, psychologist David Lisak and colleague Paul Miller analysed surveys of 1,882 male students at a Boston-area college; around 5% reported having committed acts that met the definition of rape. The study’s claim that a small group of repeat offenders commit most campus rapes has since been debated, and later work has challenged parts of it. The broader lesson stands: people who commit sexual violence are often ordinary-seeming members of a community, which is one reason survivors find it hard to be believed.

Forgiveness is a choice, not a duty

The most important thing to take from this story may be what it does not say. Elva has been clear that her decision was personal. Survivors heal in many different ways: some forgive, some never do, many feel something in between, and all of those responses are valid. Anger after an assault is a normal reaction, not a failure.

What the talk does model well is accountability. Stranger did not explain away or soften what he did, and that kind of plain acknowledgement is what many survivors say they never receive.

If you need support

If you have been sexually assaulted, recently or long ago, you do not have to deal with it alone. In the US, RAINN runs the National Sexual Assault Hotline (800-656-4673) and an online chat. In other countries, local rape crisis centres and helplines offer confidential support, and a doctor can help with medical care and connect you with counselling. If you are in immediate danger, call your local emergency number.

Sources: TED: Our story of rape and reconciliation (TEDWomen 2016); Wikipedia: Thordis Elva; The Daily Star: Victim sharing stage with her rapist sparks outrage (March 2017); Statistics Canada: Criminal victimization in Canada, 2014; US Bureau of Justice Statistics: Criminal Victimization, 2019; Wikipedia: David Lisak; RAINN. Earlier coverage of the talk appeared on Collective Evolution.

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1