Trump's Mental Health Debate: What Psychologists Said in 2017

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Psychologists Say: Donald Trump Shows Signs of Mental Illness, 'Malignant Narcisissm'

In the first weeks of Donald Trump's presidency in early 2017, a number of psychologists and psychiatrists publicly argued that his behaviour suggested a serious personality disorder, with some using the term "malignant narcissism." Others in the same professions pushed back hard, saying that diagnosing someone you have never examined is unreliable and, for psychiatrists, against their ethics code. This page sets out who said what, what the terms mean, and why the debate mattered.

What was claimed in early 2017

The most quoted voice was John D. Gartner, a psychotherapist who had taught psychiatric residents at Johns Hopkins University Medical School. Speaking to U.S. News & World Report in January 2017, he said Trump "is dangerously mentally ill and temperamentally incapable of being president." Gartner went on to lead a group called Duty to Warn, which argued that clinicians had an ethical responsibility to alert the public.

(Click bottom right corner to enlarge)

Gartner's label for what he believed he was seeing was "malignant narcissism," a mix of narcissistic traits with antisocial behaviour, aggression and sadism. The video above, shared widely at the time, covers the same arguments.

The letter to Obama and the therapists' manifesto

Even before the inauguration, three professors of psychiatry from Harvard Medical School and the University of California wrote to President Barack Obama in December 2016. They listed traits they said had been widely reported, among them grandiosity, impulsivity and sensitivity to criticism, questioned whether the president-elect was fit for office, and asked that he undergo a full medical and neuropsychiatric evaluation.

Around the same time a group of therapists published a public manifesto under the name Citizen Therapists Against Trumpism. Its focus was slightly different. Rather than offering a diagnosis, it criticised what it called "Trumpism" as a political style: blaming and excluding groups seen as threats, such as immigrants and religious minorities; mocking critics; presenting a strong leader as the answer to fear and anger; and showing little concern for truth.

What "malignant narcissism" means

The phrase was coined by the psychoanalyst Erich Fromm in 1964 and later developed by Otto Kernberg. In Kernberg's description it combines four elements: narcissistic personality disorder, antisocial behaviour, aggression or sadism, and a strong paranoid streak.

It is important to know that malignant narcissism is not a formal diagnosis. It does not appear as a separate disorder in the American Psychiatric Association's DSM-5 or in the World Health Organization's ICD-11. The DSM-5 alternative model for personality disorders mentions it only as an example of extra antagonistic traits that can be added to a diagnosis of narcissistic personality disorder.

The narcissistic personality disorder checklist

Many articles in 2017 printed the DSM criteria for narcissistic personality disorder and invited readers to tick them off. In plain words, the nine criteria describe a person who:

  • has an inflated sense of their own importance and expects to be seen as superior;
  • is absorbed by fantasies of limitless success, power, brilliance, beauty or ideal love;
  • believes they are special and should mix only with other special or high-status people;
  • needs excessive admiration;
  • feels entitled to favourable treatment or automatic compliance;
  • exploits others to reach their own goals;
  • lacks empathy for other people's feelings and needs;
  • is often envious, or believes others envy them;
  • behaves in an arrogant or haughty way.

Two points are often left out. First, a diagnosis requires at least five of the nine, and the traits must be long-lasting and cause significant impairment or distress. Second, the list is meant for qualified clinicians who have assessed a person directly, not for judging public figures from television clips. Estimates of how common the disorder is in the general population range from close to zero to about 6 percent.

The Goldwater Rule

The strongest objection came from within psychiatry itself. In 1964 Fact magazine surveyed psychiatrists about whether the Republican candidate Barry Goldwater was psychologically fit to be president, and published colourful diagnoses from people who had never met him. Goldwater sued and won $75,000 in damages in 1969.

In 1973 the American Psychiatric Association added a principle to its ethics guidance, now known as the Goldwater Rule: it is unethical for a psychiatrist to give a professional opinion on someone's mental state without examining them and having authorisation. On 16 March 2017, amid the Trump debate, the association reaffirmed the rule. Its president, Maria A. Oquendo, said: "It was unethical and irresponsible back in 1964 to offer professional opinions on people who were not properly evaluated."

The rule binds psychiatrists who are members of that association. Psychologists follow a different ethics code without an identical clause, which is partly why many of the 2017 warnings came from psychologists and therapists.

Experts who disagreed

Disagreement did not come only from the rule book. Allen Frances, a psychiatrist who chaired the task force for DSM-IV and wrote its criteria for narcissistic personality disorder, wrote to The New York Times in February 2017 that Trump did not meet those criteria. In his view, unpleasant or dangerous behaviour is not the same as mental illness, and treating political conduct as a psychiatric problem risked stigmatising people who genuinely have mental disorders. He argued that the answer to Trump was political, not psychiatric.

On the other side, clinicians such as Gartner and the Yale psychiatrist Bandy Lee argued that a professional "duty to warn" could outweigh the Goldwater Rule when a leader's behaviour appeared to threaten public safety. The argument continued throughout Trump's first term.

How to read claims like these

  • Check who is speaking. An individual clinician's opinion, a campaign group's statement and a professional association's position are very different things.
  • Separate behaviour from diagnosis. It is possible to criticise a politician's conduct strongly without claiming a medical label.
  • Look for direct assessment. No diagnosis made at a distance has the weight of a clinical examination.
  • Be wary of armchair checklists. Applying diagnostic criteria to people we dislike, or to people we know, tends to confirm what we already think. If you are worried about your own mental health or someone close to you, talk to a doctor.

Sources: American Psychiatric Association, 16 March 2017: APA reaffirms support for Goldwater Rule; Wikipedia: Goldwater rule; Wikipedia: Malignant narcissism; Wikipedia: Narcissistic personality disorder; original report via The Independent and Expanded Consciousness.

Related:

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1