Originally published 2017-03-19.

What actually happens when a whole family stops eating added sugar for twelve months? For writer Eve O. Schaub, her husband and their two daughters, the answer was a long shopping-list education, a slow change in taste, a few surprising physical reactions and a much calmer relationship with dessert afterwards. Their experience is one family's story, not a clinical trial, but it shows clearly how much sugar hides in ordinary food and what it takes to live without it.
Below is what the Schaubs tried, the rules they set, what they noticed, and what nutrition research says about cutting back, so you can decide whether a smaller version of their experiment makes sense for your own kitchen.
Why one family decided to give up sugar
Schaub has described herself before the experiment as someone who thought she was healthy, yet often ran out of energy by the afternoon and dreaded every winter cold season. Like many people, she assumed that tiredness was simply part of modern adult life.
That view shifted when she came across a wave of expert commentary arguing that sugar, rather than fat alone, lay behind much of the rise in obesity, type 2 diabetes and heart disease in the United States. The numbers she read about were stark, and they have not improved since: according to CDC survey data, about 42 per cent of American adults were living with obesity in 2017–2018, and heart disease remains the country's leading cause of death.
Rather than simply cutting down, she decided to find out whether a typical family could go a whole year with no added sugar at all, and what that would teach them about food, cooking and themselves.
The rules of a year without added sugar
The household taking part was Schaub, her husband and their daughters, then aged 11 and 6. Their rules were stricter than most "low sugar" diets:
- No added sweeteners of any kind. That meant white and brown sugar, but also honey, maple syrup, molasses, agave nectar and fruit juice used as a sweetener.
- No substitutes. Artificial sweeteners and sugar alcohols were out too, because the point was to reset taste rather than to fool it.
- Whole fruit was allowed. Sweetness that arrived in its natural package, such as an apple or a banana, stayed on the menu.
- One real dessert a month. The family shared one sugar-containing treat each month, and whoever had a birthday that month got to choose it.
The monthly dessert was a clever safety valve. It kept the year from feeling like punishment and, as it turned out, gave the family a regular test of how their reactions to sugar were changing.
Where the hidden sugar turned up
The first lesson came in the supermarket. Once the Schaubs began reading ingredient lists, they found sweeteners in foods most people would never think of as sweet: bread, tortillas, crackers, salad dressing, mayonnaise, chicken broth, sausages, bacon, deli meats and even some baby food.
Manufacturers add sugar to savoury products for practical reasons. It rounds out flavour, balances acidity and salt, helps browning, adds bulk and can extend shelf life. Each serving may contain only a little, but across a day of packaged food those small amounts add up.
The World Health Organization gives two useful reference points. A single tablespoon of ketchup carries about one teaspoon (4 g) of free sugars, while one can of sugar-sweetened soda can contain about ten teaspoons (40 g). That one can is already more than the 25 g a day the WHO suggests as an ideal lower target.
Names to look for on a label
Sugar rarely appears under one name. On ingredient lists it can show up as sucrose, glucose, dextrose, fructose, high-fructose corn syrup, malt syrup, cane or beet sugar, fruit juice concentrate, honey, molasses or various syrups. In the United States, nutrition labels have had to show an "added sugars" line since the FDA updated them, with most products complying by 2018, which makes the hunt far easier than it was for the Schaubs.
What changed over the twelve months
Schaub has said the most noticeable change was gradual: the longer the family went without added sugar, the steadier and more energetic she felt. By late summer, the family realised they were enjoying their monthly treat less than before.
The clearest moment came with her husband's birthday dessert in September, a rich, layered banana cream pie. Schaub found it so sweet that she could not finish her slice. She has described aching teeth, a pounding head and a racing heart, followed by about an hour on the sofa before she felt normal again. That made her wonder whether sugar had always affected her this way and she had simply never noticed because it was everywhere.
When the year ended she compared her daughters' school attendance with earlier years. Her older daughter, Greta, had missed 15 days the previous year and only two during the sugar-free year. The family also felt they caught fewer colds and recovered faster.
How to read those results
These observations are honest and interesting, but they come from one household, with no comparison group and many other things changing at the same time. Cooking from scratch, eating more vegetables, a different winter and simple chance could all play a part. Taste adaptation, on the other hand, is widely reported: people who cut back on sweet foods often find that very sugary desserts taste overpowering afterwards. A strong reaction to a large dessert after months without one is plausible, but it is not proof that sugar causes illness in everyone.
What the research says about cutting added sugar
The Schaubs went further than most health bodies ask, but the direction of their experiment matches mainstream advice.
- The WHO strongly recommends that adults and children keep free sugars below 10 per cent of daily energy, and suggests that going below 5 per cent, around six teaspoons a day, brings extra benefits.
- The American Heart Association suggests no more than about 6 teaspoons (25 g) a day for women and 9 teaspoons (36 g) for men.
- Evidence of harm is strongest for tooth decay and for weight gain through extra calories. Sugary drinks in particular have been linked with obesity, fatty liver disease and type 2 diabetes, and very high intakes have been associated with a higher risk of dying from cardiovascular disease.
Note what the WHO counts as "free" sugar: sugar added by a manufacturer or cook, plus the sugar naturally present in honey, syrups and fruit juice. Whole fruit, vegetables and plain milk are not included, which is exactly the line the Schaub family drew.
Common myths about quitting sugar
"Honey and maple syrup are healthy swaps." They contain small amounts of other compounds, but in the body they behave much like table sugar and count as free sugars.
"Fruit is just as bad as sweets." Whole fruit brings fibre, water, vitamins and a feeling of fullness. Health guidelines do not ask people to limit it the way they limit added sugar.
"Going sugar-free means never having dessert." The Schaubs still had a dessert every month. Many people find a clear, occasional treat easier to stick with than a vague promise to "eat less".
"Cutting sugar will cure illness." Less added sugar is good for most diets, but it is not a treatment for any disease. Anyone with diabetes, a heart condition or a child with special dietary needs should talk to a doctor before a major change.
Trying a lighter version at home
You do not need a full year to learn what the Schaubs learned. A few practical steps:
- Start with drinks. Swapping soda and sweetened juices for water, sparkling water or unsweetened tea removes the largest single source for many people.
- Audit five staples. Check the labels on your bread, breakfast cereal, pasta sauce, salad dressing and yoghurt, and look for lower-sugar versions.
- Cook one more meal from scratch each week. Home cooking puts you in charge of what goes in.
- Keep dessert, but make it deliberate. Choose when and what, and enjoy it properly.
- Give your taste buds a few weeks. Many people find plain yoghurt or unsweetened coffee easier to enjoy after a short adjustment.
After the year ended, the Schaubs did not swear off sugar forever. They kept it out of everyday foods where it does not belong, ate much smaller amounts, and saved sweet things for real celebrations, which is a sensible goal for almost anyone.
About Eve O. Schaub and her book
Eve O. Schaub tells the full story of the experiment, including recipes, family arguments and the funny side of reading every food label, in Year of No Sugar: A Memoir. She studied at Cornell University, where she earned a BA and a BFA, and holds an MFA from the Rochester Institute of Technology. Her personal essays have been broadcast many times on WAMC, the NPR station in Albany, New York.
Sources: Eve O. Schaub's first-person account in Everyday Health; World Health Organization: guideline on sugars intake (2015); Wikipedia: Added sugar; Wikipedia: Obesity in the United States.

COMMENTS