Wattway Solar Roads: What France's Normandy Test Road Showed

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗
Wattway Solar Roads: What the Early Test Sites Were Designed to Learn

Wattway is a solar road surface made by the French road builder Colas: thin, tough photovoltaic panels glued directly onto an existing road so cars and trucks can drive over them while they generate electricity. In late 2016 Colas opened a 1 km test road in Normandy and announced plans for around 100 trial sites worldwide. The results were disappointing. The Normandy road produced roughly half the electricity expected, and parts of it wore out fast. The idea still has niche uses, but flat panels under traffic have so far struggled to compete with ordinary solar installations.

How Wattway panels are built

Colas, part of the Bouygues group, developed Wattway with France's National Institute for Solar Energy (INES) over about five years. Each panel is only a few millimetres thick. Standard silicon solar cells sit inside a sandwich of tough resins and plastics, and the top layer has a gritty, glass-based texture so tyres can grip it in the wet.

Instead of rebuilding the road, crews bond the panels to the existing asphalt or concrete, and cables run to the roadside. Colas said the panels could carry heavy-goods vehicles, including articulated trucks. The pitch was simple: roads already cover a huge area, so why not use them to harvest sunlight?

The 2016 announcement: 100 trial sites

In November 2016 Bloomberg reported Colas's plan to roll out Wattway at about 100 test sites across four continents in 2017, with a commercial launch to follow in 2018. The company also said it hoped costs would fall far enough by around 2020 to compete with conventional solar farms. Those were company targets, and they did not come true on that timeline.

Suggested uses were modest and local: feeding power into the grid, running street lights, traffic signals or electric signs, charging electric vehicles, and powering small installations close to the road.

The Normandy test road

The showcase project opened in December 2016 in the village of Tourouvre-au-Perche in Normandy, inaugurated by Ségolène Royal, then France's minister for the environment and energy. About 2,800 panels, covering roughly 3,000 square metres, were laid along a 1 km stretch of a departmental road, at a cost of around €5 million paid by the French state.

Early coverage reportedly quoted a peak output of about 280 kilowatts and said the road could supply electricity for around 5,000 people. That comparison mixed up two different things. Kilowatts measure power at a single moment; what a town uses over a year is energy, measured in kilowatt-hours. Later reports made clear the target was more limited: about 150,000 kWh a year, meant to cover the village's street lighting.

What went wrong

In 2019 the French newspaper Le Monde reported that the road had produced about 80,000 kWh in 2018, against an expected 150,000 kWh. Reporting since then has pointed to several causes:

  • Flat panels. Rooftop and solar-farm panels are tilted towards the sun. A road is flat, so it catches less light, especially in a northern region in winter.
  • Normandy's weather. The area gets relatively few days of strong sunshine each year.
  • Dirt and shade. Leaves, mud and the vehicles themselves block light, and nobody washes a road the way a solar farm can be cleaned.
  • Wear and damage. Storms caused electrical faults in some modules, heavy tractors damaged joints and surfaces, and about a tenth of the road was reported to be beyond repair.
  • Noise. Residents complained about road noise, and the speed limit on the stretch was cut to 70 km/h.

Étienne Gaudin, who led the Wattway programme at Colas, conceded that the technology was "not mature for inter-urban traffic." The company shifted towards smaller, lower-traffic sites.

Other solar road experiments

France was not alone. The Netherlands opened SolaRoad, a 72-metre solar cycle path in Krommenie, in 2014; bike paths carry far lighter loads than motorways, which suits the idea better. In the United States, the Solar Roadways project raised about $2.2 million on Indiegogo in 2014 and opened a small grant-funded pilot walkway in Sandpoint, Idaho, in 2016; its 30 panels averaged only about a quarter of a kilowatt-hour a day in their best month, and the pilot was shut down in December 2018. China opened a solar expressway section in Jinan in 2017, and local media reported that part of it was stolen within days (we could not confirm this independently). Each trial ran into the same issues of cost, durability and low output.

Wattway Solar Roads: What the Early Test Sites Were Designed to Learn
Tesla promotional image of its Solar Roof tiles, unveiled in October 2016.

Context: clean energy news from 2016

The original 2016 story also mentioned other clean-energy headlines from that year. Three of them need a closer look.

Tesla's Solar Roof. Tesla showed its glass solar tiles in October 2016, and Elon Musk suggested they could cost about the same as a normal roof once electricity savings were counted. Real installations later turned out to be considerably more expensive than many buyers expected, so treat that early claim as a sales pitch.

The "Asian Super Grid". In 2016, power companies from China, South Korea, Russia and Japan's SoftBank signed a memorandum of understanding to study a grid linking northeast Asia with wind and solar power. That was an agreement to investigate the idea, not a working network, and it has not been built.

Solar overtaking coal in the UK. Analysis by Carbon Brief found that British solar panels generated more electricity than coal plants over the six months from April to September 2016. That was a seasonal comparison during a rapid coal phase-out, not a year-round result.

Where solar along roads makes more sense

None of this means roads are useless for solar power. The lesson from Normandy is that panels work best when they are tilted, clean, shade-free and away from wheels. That points to options that are already common:

  • solar canopies over car parks, which also shade parked cars;
  • panels on noise barriers along motorways, as tested in the Netherlands and Germany;
  • solar on depot, rest-area and service-station roofs;
  • small Wattway-style tiles for low-traffic uses such as cycle paths, pavements and powering a single sign or bus shelter.

When you see a new solar-road headline, ask a few simple questions. What is the measured annual output in kilowatt-hours? What did it cost per kilowatt-hour compared with a rooftop system? How does it handle trucks, frost, dirt and repairs? Normandy shows why those numbers matter more than the launch-day photos.

Sources: Wattway by Colas: product information; Bloomberg, 24 November 2016: solar panel roads to be built across four continents; Gardner Web, August 2019: gloomy results for French solar road (reporting Le Monde); ScienceAlert, August 2019: the world's first solar road has turned out to be a disappointing failure; Motoring Research, August 2019: the world's first solar road is a failure; Wikipedia: Solar road; Wikipedia: Solar Roadways; Wikipedia: SolaRoad; Original story: The Mind Unleashed, December 2016.

COMMENTS