First published December 19, 2016.

In November 2016 Poland's Ministry of National Defence launched free self-defence training for women, taught by army instructors. The classes began on 19 November 2016, ran in around 30 cities and military units across the country, and were scheduled to continue until mid-2017. Any woman aged 18 or over who was in good enough health to train could sign up. The government described it as the first nationwide programme of its kind in Poland.
The idea drew both praise and suspicion. Supporters saw a practical answer to a real problem: many women feel unsafe in public spaces. Critics saw a public-relations exercise by an army trying to grow its ranks. Both reactions are worth understanding, along with what the numbers really say about harassment and fear in public.
What the Polish army offered
Instructors from the Polish Armed Forces ran the sessions at military sites in roughly 30 locations. Reports at the time described the content as basic unarmed combat, drawing on martial arts such as aikido and jiu-jitsu. Participants practised defensive stances, breaking holds, deflecting kicks, escaping from chokes, and responding when facing more than one attacker. Some reports also mentioned defending against an armed assailant.
The official framing was about personal safety and fitness. The government statement said the course was for women who wanted to prepare for situations that threaten their life or health. At the launch, Defence Minister Antoni Macierewicz said he hoped the classes would "increase the security of individuals and the state."
Macierewicz, who served as defence minister from November 2015 to January 2018, was a polarising figure in Polish politics, and his involvement shaped how many people received the initiative.
Why some people were sceptical
Poland ended compulsory military service in 2008. By 2016, with tensions with Russia rising after the annexation of Crimea, the government was keen to build up its forces and its image. Some commentators, quoted by the BBC and others, argued that the classes were partly about presenting the army in a friendly light and encouraging recruitment. Critics in the regional newspaper Dziennik Polski went further and called the lessons propaganda, arguing that the military was not the right body to teach civilians hand-to-hand combat.
The timing also mattered. A month earlier, in October 2016, mass protests and strikes by Polish women had pushed parliament to shelve a proposed near-total abortion ban. For some observers, an army programme aimed at women, launched by the same governing camp, looked like an attempt to win back goodwill.
None of that makes the classes useless, but it is a reminder that a training course is not a policy on violence against women. Experts generally stress that the responsibility for harassment and assault lies with perpetrators, and that prevention also depends on laws, policing, safe transport and education.
How common is street harassment? What surveys found
Coverage of the Polish programme often cited a figure that 45% of women worldwide do not feel safe walking alone at night. Gallup's global polling suggests a somewhat different picture. In 2011 data covering 143 countries, 62% of women said they felt safe walking alone at night where they live, compared with 72% of men. In Gallup's 2024 data, 67% of women felt safe versus 78% of men, with gaps of ten points or more in over 100 countries. So roughly one in three women, rather than nearly one in two, report feeling unsafe at night, and the gender gap is consistent and large.
Earlier campaigners, notably the US group Stop Street Harassment, collected national and city surveys on the issue. Methods vary a great deal: some are rigorous national samples, others are informal online polls where people who have been harassed are more likely to respond. With that caution, here is what those studies reported:
- Poland: An informal 2012 online survey by Hollaback! Poland of 818 people, most of them women, found 85% of women and 44% of men said they had been harassed in public.
- Afghanistan: A 2015 study by the Women and Children Legal Research Foundation, covering 364 women and girls in seven provinces, reported harassment in public spaces by 93%, in workplaces by 87% and in schools or universities by 89%.
- Australia: A 2015 Australia Institute survey of 1,426 women found 87% had experienced verbal or physical harassment on the street and 40% felt unsafe in their own neighbourhood after dark.
- Bangladesh: A 2014 survey of 12,600 women by the national statistics bureau and the UN Population Fund found harassment was a routine experience, with about 43% naming public places as where it happened most.
- Brazil: An opt-in survey of 7,762 people for the Think Olga campaign "Chega de Fiu Fiu" found 99.6% said they had been harassed.
- Canada: Analysis of a 1990s national sample of 12,300 women by sociologists Ross Macmillan, Annette Nierobisz and Sandy Welsh, published in 2000, found more than 80% had been harassed by male strangers in public, with a clear effect on how safe they felt.
- Beijing, China: A 2002 survey of 200 residents found 70% had faced sexual harassment, most often on public transport, including 58% on buses.
- Croatia: A 2012 Hollaback! Croatia online survey of 500 people found 99% of women had faced some form of street harassment, half of them before turning 18.
- Ecuador: A 2011 UN Women scoping study in Quito found 68% of women had experienced sexual harassment or violence in public spaces in the previous year.
- Egypt: A 2013 UN Women study reported that 99.3% of women had experienced some form of sexual harassment, with unwanted touching and verbal harassment the most common.
- Mumbai, India: A 2012 survey by the We the People Foundation found 80% of women had been harassed, mostly in crowded places such as trains and stations.
- United Kingdom: A 2016 YouGov poll for the End Violence Against Women Coalition found 64% of women had faced unwanted sexual harassment in public, rising to 85% of women aged 18 to 24.
- United States: A 2000 national telephone poll of 612 women found 87% had been harassed by a male stranger, with similar rates in rural, suburban and urban areas, and most said they adjusted their behaviour to avoid it.
What self-defence training can and cannot do
Good self-defence courses offer more than kicks and wrist escapes. Many focus on awareness, setting boundaries out loud, de-escalation and getting away rather than winning a fight. Participants often report greater confidence, and some research on women's empowerment programmes that combine physical skills with assertiveness training has found lower rates of sexual assault among participants. The quality of instruction and the content of the course matter a great deal.
A few common myths deserve a calm correction:
- "One technique will stop any attacker." No method guarantees safety. The aim is to create a chance to escape and get help.
- "Most attacks come from strangers." Street harassment is usually by strangers, but serious sexual and physical violence against women is more often committed by someone the victim knows.
- "If you take a class, it's your job to prevent harassment." Training is a personal choice, not an obligation. Harassment is the harasser's responsibility.
Choosing a course if you are interested
The Polish programme was a time-limited offer from 2016 to 2017, so anyone looking for training today should check what is currently available locally. When comparing options, look for instructors with recognised qualifications, a mix of awareness and physical practice, a supportive atmosphere for beginners and clear safety rules. Women-only classes, community centres, universities and some police forces run sessions at low or no cost in many countries.
If you have an injury, a heart condition or any doubt about your fitness for physical training, talk to a doctor before starting.
Whatever one thinks of the politics behind it, Poland's experiment put a spotlight on a problem that surveys in country after country confirm: a large share of women adjust how they move through public space because they do not feel safe. Classes can build confidence; safer streets require everyone.
Featured image: Polish Ministry of National Defence.
Sources: TIME: Women in Poland get free self-defense lessons; Euronews: Polish women get self-defence classes from army; Wikipedia: Antoni Macierewicz; Gallup (2012): Women feel less safe than men; Gallup: Global safety perceptions; country surveys as compiled by Stop Street Harassment; originally reported by The Mind Unleashed.

COMMENTS