
Two versions of the same Madonna portrait: the edited image on the right has smoother skin, softer lines and brighter eyes.
Almost every celebrity photo you see in a magazine, on a billboard or on a film poster has been retouched, often heavily. Skin is smoothed, wrinkles and freckles vanish, waists are narrowed, legs lengthened and muscles sharpened. The before-and-after pairs below, which circulated widely online, show how far that editing can go, and why comparing yourself with a published image means comparing yourself with something that never existed.
Retouching is not new. Portrait painters flattered their sitters for centuries, and darkroom technicians airbrushed film negatives long before Photoshop. What changed is the scale and the ease: software can now reshape a body in minutes, and the results reach billions of people. Researchers, doctors’ organisations and some governments have become concerned about what that does to body image, especially among teenagers.
A word of caution before you scroll. Not every “unretouched” photo that goes viral is genuine. At least two of the pairs below were disputed by the people involved, and they are labelled as such. The broader point stands either way: the published image is a product, shaped by stylists, lighting and software, not a snapshot of a normal human body.
Faces: skin, wrinkles and eyes
Kim Cattrall

The Sex and the City actor’s smile lines and skin texture are softened in the edited version, and her skin tone is warmed and evened out. The changes are subtle at a glance, which is exactly what makes this kind of retouching so effective. The image pair was shared by the site Bright Side.
Beyoncé

Pores, fine lines and small blemishes disappear, and the lighting on the face is made more even and glowing. Close-up beauty shots like this are among the most heavily processed images in advertising, because the product being sold is flawless skin. The pair is credited to Elisa Zwingenberger.
Angelina Jolie

The before image shows ordinary skin with visible pores and texture; the after looks almost porcelain. The pair is credited to InfectiousPerfection, and is a typical demonstration of high-end “skin retouching”, a specialist trade in its own right.
Lindsay Lohan

Lohan’s freckles are almost entirely erased in the edited version, and her complexion is smoothed and brightened. Freckles, moles and other natural marks are often among the first things retouchers remove, even though many people consider them attractive.
Penélope Cruz

Shadows under the eyes are lifted and the skin around the mouth and chin is evened out. The pair is credited to the Chinese fashion site Haibao. Cruz has long been praised for her natural looks, which makes the amount of editing all the more telling.
Miranda Kerr

Even a model widely celebrated for her skin gets edited: the after image has fewer blemishes and a softer, more uniform tone. This red-carpet style shot shows that retouching is not limited to magazine covers; event and publicity photos are routinely touched up too.
Madonna (Steven Klein portrait)

This is the same pair shown at the top of the page, credited to the photographer Steven Klein, who has worked with Madonna on many shoots. The edited version removes lines around the eyes and mouth and makes the face look years younger. Pairs like this reportedly leaked from more than one Madonna shoot and fed a wider debate about how pop culture treats ageing women.
Madonna (with crucifix)

Credited to the photography duo Mert and Marcus, this striking image appears to belong to the visual style of Madonna’s MDNA era around 2012. The skin is lightened dramatically and nearly every line is removed, while contrast around the eyes is pushed up. It is a good example of retouching used as a deliberate artistic look rather than a quiet correction.
Bodies: waists, thighs and curves
Candice Huffine

Huffine is a well-known plus-size model, and the edited image smooths her stomach and thighs and subtly reshapes her waist. The pair is credited to V Magazine. Retouching curvy models to look slimmer undermines the very point of featuring a range of body types.
Cindy Crawford (disputed)

In February 2015 an “unretouched” photo of Crawford in lingerie, said to come from a Marie Claire Mexico shoot, went viral and was widely praised as an honest image of a woman in her late forties. Marie Claire said at the time that the leaked photo was real. Within weeks, however, the photographer, John Russo, said the image had been stolen or unlawfully accessed and then altered before it was distributed, and his lawyers threatened legal action.
Britney Spears (Candie’s campaign)

This pair is the most honest one here, because Spears released it herself. In 2010 she agreed to publish unedited images from her Candie’s campaign next to the retouched versions, to show the pressure placed on women to look perfect. The changes are clear: thighs and waist are slimmed, and skin is smoothed.
Britney Spears (magazine cover)

Here the before photo becomes a Marie Claire cover. Her face is subtly reshaped, her skin is evened and the hair is given more volume, while cover lines and colour are added around her. The image is credited to the photographer fabiofb.
Britney Spears (stage outfit)

In this third Spears pair, the waist and stomach appear to have been narrowed and smoothed in the edited version. Placing the two side by side shows how small changes in silhouette can create an entirely different impression of a body.
Fergie

The singer’s arms and waist look slimmer in the edited version, and her skin tone is brightened. The pose and lighting are identical, which makes the reshaping easy to see once you compare the outline of her arms against the background.
Kim Kardashian

This pair, credited to Complex magazine, shows Kardashian’s waist pulled in and her thighs and hips smoothed. Kardashian later became famous for carefully controlled images of her body, and her photos remain among the most scrutinised for editing online.
Katy Perry

The before image comes from the shoot for Perry’s 2010 Rolling Stone cover story. On the finished cover her skin is smoothed, her waist slightly narrowed and the bedroom background softened. Music magazines are not exempt from the same beauty standards as fashion titles.
Miley Cyrus

This is a red-carpet photograph, credited to Frederick M. Brown, taken at an Elton John AIDS Foundation event. In the edited version her arms and waist look slimmer and her skin is evened. Event photos like this are often re-edited by websites and fans, not only by magazines.
Jennifer Lawrence

This cover of the Canadian magazine Flare, shot by Max Abadian, drew criticism because Lawrence’s waist and hips appear noticeably narrower than in the original frame. Her figure in the unedited frame is already slim, which shows that even very thin bodies are routinely made thinner.
Men are retouched too
Justin Bieber (disputed)

In January 2015 Bieber’s Calvin Klein underwear campaign was quickly followed by an alleged “before” image, published by the blog BreatheHeavy, suggesting his muscles and body had been enhanced. Bieber denied that the photo was real, his team sent a cease-and-desist letter, and the site retracted the story on 8 January 2015. Whatever the truth of this particular image, male models are routinely given sharper abs and bigger arms, and men are increasingly affected by body-image pressure.
Film posters: the Keira Knightley case
Keira Knightley

The poster for the 2004 film King Arthur, produced by Jerry Bruckheimer, was altered to make Knightley’s bust appear larger. Knightley has since said her body has been manipulated many times for different reasons. In 2014 she posed topless for Interview magazine on the condition that the image was not enlarged or retouched, to make the point that body shape should not matter.
What retouching does to how we see ourselves
Surveys consistently show the impact. In one UK survey for the retailer New Look, only 15 percent of people believed magazine cover images accurately showed the model, and a third of women said they were aiming for a body they could not achieve. A survey by Dove and People found that 80 percent of women felt insecure when looking at celebrity photos. The American Medical Association has formally opposed extreme photo manipulation in advertising, warning that it fuels unrealistic expectations among children and teenagers.
There has been some pushback. Seventeen magazine pledged in 2012 to stop altering its models’ bodies after a petition by a 14-year-old reader gathered more than 84,000 signatures. France introduced rules requiring commercial images with retouched bodies to be labelled, and Norway made such labelling mandatory for advertising in 2021. Britain’s advertising regulator has banned cosmetics adverts whose airbrushing made results look too good to be true. Several stars, from Cate Blanchett to Kate Winslet, have also spoken out or posed without retouching.
How to spot a heavily edited photo
- Skin with no texture. Real skin has pores, fine hairs and small marks, even on young people under good lighting.
- Warped backgrounds. Bent door frames, wavy tiles or curved horizon lines next to a waist or thigh are a classic sign of reshaping.
- Impossible proportions. Very long legs, a tiny waist and full hips all at once, or arms with no visible joints, often point to editing.
- Viral “before” photos with no clear source. As the Crawford and Bieber cases show, the supposedly honest image can be the doctored one. Check whether the photographer or publication has confirmed it.
The next time a cover or an advert makes you feel inadequate, remember these pairs. Real people have pores, curves, lines and freckles. The polished version is a commercial image created by a team of professionals, and nobody, including the celebrity on the cover, looks like that in everyday life.
Sources: Wikipedia: Photograph manipulation; ABC7 News, 2015: Cindy Crawford “un-retouched” photo is a fake, says photographer; Christian Post, 2015: Bieber Calvin Klein photo retraction; Fox News: Keira Knightley explains her 2014 unretouched shoot; Wikipedia: Keira Knightley. Image pairs credited as shown in each caption; collection originally published by True Activist.

COMMENTS