I Don't Want a Lover, I Want a Best Friend: Why Friendship Matters

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2017-12-25.

Wanting your partner to be your best friend is not asking for too much. For many people it is the whole point. Writer Cassie Fox put this feeling into words in a short essay for YourTango titled I Don't Want A Lover, I Want A Best Friend: physical chemistry is easy to come by, but what she really longs for is someone to share ordinary days, bad moods, silly jokes and a whole life with. Research suggests she is onto something. Couples who see each other as close friends tend to get more out of their relationship, not less.

Wanting Friendship at the Heart of a Romantic Relationship

What the essay is really saying

Fox opens by admitting that attraction and passion are not hard to find. Plenty of people want the thrill of a first touch and the rush of a new romance. She does not dismiss that at all. Her point is that it is not enough. Intimacy, for her, is about sharing who she is, not only sharing a bed.

The heart of the essay is a long list of small, specific wishes. They are worth retelling in plain terms, because their ordinariness is exactly the point:

  • Crying ugly, unflattering tears in his arms and still feeling beautiful.
  • Being pulled back into bed for one more lazy minute in the morning, bad breath and messy hair included.
  • Summer baseball games with expensive beer, and him grabbing her hand every time their team scores.
  • Travelling abroad together, laughing at each other's pronunciation and trying food that is wonderful or awful.
  • A whole weekend at home in pyjamas, watching good and terrible television, her feet in his lap.
  • Late-night talks about everything and nothing, from childhood triumphs to old family wounds.
  • Burning dinner and running out for pizza at nine at night, sitting on the same side of the booth.
  • Notes on a steamy mirror and inside jokes left in a coat pocket.
  • Meeting each other's families, and maybe one day building their own.
  • Fighting, storming off, and still going to bed hurt and waking up ready to forgive.

She ends by borrowing a phrase from the sitcom Friends: she wants someone who is her person, her lobster. In short, she wants to fall in love with her best friend and stay there.

Does friendship really make love last? What studies show

The idea is romantic, but it also has data behind it. In a 2014 working paper for the US National Bureau of Economic Research, economists Shawn Grover and John Helliwell looked at large British survey data on marriage and life satisfaction. After controlling for how happy people were before they married, they still found that married people were more satisfied with their lives. When they looked for the reason, friendship stood out: the wellbeing boost from marriage was roughly twice as large for people who said their spouse was also their best friend.

Relationship researcher John Gottman reaches a similar conclusion from a different direction. His work on couples suggests that everyday friendship, made of small moments of attention and responsiveness, is a better predictor of whether a relationship lasts than grand romantic gestures. Fox's list is, in effect, a list of those small moments.

None of this means passion is unimportant. It means passion seems to grow best in soil made of companionship, trust and plain enjoyment of each other's company.

The lobster line: a lovely idea, shaky biology

The lobster reference comes from the second season of Friends, in the episode The One with the Prom Video, first aired on NBC in February 1996. Phoebe argues that Ross and Rachel are meant to be together because lobsters supposedly fall in love and mate for life. Wikipedia notes that the idea came from writer Alexa Junge's husband.

As a metaphor, it has charmed millions of viewers. As biology, it does not hold up. Descriptions of the American lobster show that mating is tied to the moment when a female sheds her shell, and that she can store sperm for many months afterwards. There is no good evidence that lobsters form lifelong pairs. The feeling behind the line is real; the zoology is not.

What friendship inside a relationship looks like day to day

Saying you want your partner to be your best friend is easy. Describing what that means is more useful, because it gives both people something to work with. A few common ingredients:

  • Being able to be unpolished. Feeling free to be tired, grumpy, unglamorous or vulnerable without losing the other person's respect.
  • Shared fun. Having activities you both enjoy, whether that is sport, travel, cooking or a series you binge together.
  • Curiosity. Still asking questions about each other's past, worries and plans, long after the early dates.
  • Safe disagreement. Arguing without fearing that the relationship will collapse, and being able to apologise and repair.
  • Private language. Inside jokes, nicknames and small rituals that belong to nobody else.

Fox's list touches every one of these. What makes it ring true is that almost nothing on it costs much money. It is about time and attention.

A healthy caution: one person cannot be everything

There is a risk in taking the best-friend ideal too far. If a partner is expected to be the only source of fun, comfort, advice and company, the relationship can buckle under the pressure. Many therapists encourage couples to keep other friendships, hobbies and family ties alive, so that the relationship is one strong support among several rather than the only one.

It also helps to remember that friendship and romance can both go quiet in long relationships during stressful seasons, such as raising young children, caring for parents or dealing with illness. A slow patch does not mean the friendship is gone. It may simply need deliberate time to come back.

Practical ways to build the friendship

If Fox's essay describes what you want, these steps can help you move toward it, whether you are single, dating or long married:

  1. Name the specifics. Rather than saying you want more connection, mention one concrete thing, such as a weekly walk or a phone-free dinner.
  2. Protect small rituals. Morning coffee together or a goodnight conversation can matter more than an expensive night out.
  3. Try something new together. New experiences, even small ones, give you fresh stories to share.
  4. Keep talking about the past and the future. Childhood memories, dreams and fears are where deep friendship lives.
  5. Repair quickly. Good friends fall out and make up. The making up is the part that builds trust.

Lovers can come and go. A partner who is also a true friend is someone you can be ordinary with, and that ordinariness, repeated over years, is what many people mean when they talk about lasting love.

Sources: Cassie Fox, I Don't Want A Lover, I Want A Best Friend (YourTango; author page Cassie Fox); Shawn Grover and John F. Helliwell, NBER Working Paper 20794 (2014); The Gottman Institute, Turn Toward Instead of Away; Wikipedia, The One with the Prom Video and Homarus americanus. Earlier shared via Ideaspots.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 4
  1. I had that and it was amazing and beautiful and then he died. Its been several months and I'm still
    Feeling like someone punched me in the gut daily.

    ReplyDelete