Originally published 2016-08-23.

Does pasta make you fat? Not on its own, according to a large Italian study. Researchers from the Neuromed Institute looked at the diets and body measurements of more than 23,000 adults and found that people who ate more pasta, as part of a traditional Mediterranean way of eating, tended to have a slightly lower body mass index (BMI) and a smaller waist, not a larger one.
That headline needs care. The study showed a link, not proof that pasta causes weight loss, and the people in it ate modest portions alongside vegetables, legumes, fish and olive oil. Here is what the research actually found, how it was done, its limits, and how to fit pasta sensibly into your own meals.
What the Italian study found
The paper, led by George Pounis with senior author Licia Iacoviello, was published in July 2016 in the journal Nutrition & Diabetes. It drew on two separate groups of Italians:
- Moli-sani: 14,402 randomly selected adults aged 35 and over from the Molise region in southern Italy. They completed a detailed food frequency questionnaire, and staff measured their weight, height, waist and hips.
- INHES: 8,964 adults aged 18 to 96 from across Italy, interviewed by telephone about what they had eaten in the previous 24 hours. Their height and weight were self-reported.
After adjusting for age, sex, total calorie intake, physical activity, education and other factors, the team found that higher pasta intake was associated with a lower BMI in both groups. In the Moli-sani group, it was also linked to smaller waist and hip measurements. The authors concluded that pasta, eaten as part of a Mediterranean diet, was associated with lower BMI and a healthier waist-to-hip ratio.
Iacoviello summed up the team's view in the institute's press release:
“In popular views, pasta is often considered not adequate when you want to lose weight.” (Licia Iacoviello, Neuromed Institute, 2016)
She added that, in light of the results, cutting pasta out completely was not the right approach for people in Italy, where it is a central part of the traditional diet.
The fine print: association, not cause
Both datasets were cross-sectional, meaning they captured a single snapshot in time. The authors themselves stress that this kind of study cannot show that pasta causes a lower weight. Several other points are worth knowing:
- The effect was small. The differences in BMI linked to pasta were modest, and in one of the statistical approaches the link held only for women.
- Raw numbers told a different story. Before adjustment, people who reported eating more grams of pasta actually had a slightly higher BMI. The researchers attributed this to under-reporting of food by heavier participants and used statistical methods to correct for it. Those methods are reasonable but add a layer of interpretation.
- Self-reporting is imperfect. Food questionnaires and single-day recalls rely on memory, and INHES used self-reported weight.
- The diet as a whole mattered. Pasta eaters in this population were often eating a broadly Mediterranean pattern, so it is hard to separate the effect of pasta from everything eaten with it.
None of this makes the study worthless. It is a large, careful piece of research that challenges the idea that pasta is automatically fattening. It simply cannot tell an individual that eating more pasta will make them slimmer.
Why pasta is not the villain it was made out to be
Pasta's poor reputation grew with the popularity of low-carbohydrate diets in the 2000s. Some of its qualities, though, work in its favour.
Pasta has a lower glycemic index than many other starchy staples, including white bread and potatoes. That means it tends to raise blood sugar more gradually. The dense structure of durum wheat pasta, formed when the dough is pressed and dried, slows digestion. Cooking it al dente, still slightly firm, helps preserve that structure, while overcooking breaks it down.
A cooked 100-gram portion contains roughly 160 calories, mostly from starch, with about 6 grams of protein and very little fat. The calories in a pasta dish usually come far more from what goes on top, such as cream, cheese, butter and fatty meat, and from the size of the bowl.
The Mediterranean context matters
The Mediterranean diet, which UNESCO recognised as part of the cultural heritage of several Mediterranean countries in 2010, centres on vegetables, fruit, whole grains, legumes, nuts and olive oil, with moderate amounts of fish, dairy and poultry and little red or processed meat. Research links this pattern with better heart health, although the strength of evidence varies between studies.
In southern Italy, pasta is often eaten as a first course in modest amounts, dressed with tomatoes, vegetables, legumes or seafood, followed by a lighter second course and fruit. That is very different from a large plate of pasta in a heavy cream sauce eaten as the whole meal. The study's conclusion applies to the first style of eating, not the second.
Myths about pasta and weight
Myth: carbs at dinner turn straight into fat. Body weight depends on total energy intake and expenditure over time, not the hour you eat a particular food.
Myth: the study proves pasta helps you lose weight. It found an association in people already eating a Mediterranean-style diet. It was not a weight-loss trial.
Myth: whole-wheat pasta is pointless because the calories are the same. Calories are indeed similar, but whole-grain pasta offers more fibre, which can help you feel full and supports digestive health.
Myth: you must give up pasta to eat healthily. For most people, there is no need to. Portion size and what you serve with it make a bigger difference.
How to enjoy pasta the Mediterranean way
- Keep portions moderate. A standard 500-gram packet of dry pasta is usually meant to serve about four people as a main course, and a first-course portion is smaller still.
- Cook it al dente and serve it soon after draining.
- Build the plate around vegetables, legumes or fish, with tomato or olive oil based sauces rather than cream.
- Try whole-grain or legume-based pasta for extra fibre and protein.
- Treat rich dishes such as carbonara or lasagne as occasional meals rather than daily ones.
If you are managing diabetes, a weight-related condition or any other health issue, talk to a doctor or registered dietitian before making major changes to your diet.
The bottom line
Pasta is not inherently fattening. In a large Italian population, eating it as part of a balanced Mediterranean diet went hand in hand with a slightly lower BMI. The study does not turn pasta into a weight-loss food, but it does suggest that a sensible bowl of spaghetti with vegetables and olive oil has a perfectly good place in a healthy diet.
Sources: Pounis, G. et al. (2016), Association of pasta consumption with body mass index and waist-to-hip ratio: results from Moli-sani and INHES studies, Nutrition & Diabetes; Wikipedia: Mediterranean diet; Wikipedia: Pasta; Wikipedia: Glycemic index.

nice
ReplyDelete