Is High Intelligence Linked to Bipolar Disorder? What a Study Found

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

First published August 13, 2016.

An Essay Linking Childhood Intelligence With Later Mood Traits

Is a sharp mind more prone to mood swings? There is some evidence for a link, but it is smaller and more careful than the headlines suggest. A 2015 British study followed children from the age of eight into their early twenties and found that those with higher childhood IQ scores reported somewhat more features of hypomania, the milder form of the “high” phase in bipolar disorder, as young adults.

That is a real and interesting finding. It is not proof that intelligence causes mental illness, and it does not mean that suffering is the entry fee for talent. Most bright children never develop bipolar disorder, and most people with bipolar disorder are not defined by their test scores. Below we look at what the research actually measured, why scientists think the two might be connected, and what the idea of the “mad genius” gets wrong.

What the 2015 IQ and bipolar study measured

The research was led by psychiatrist Daniel Smith, then at the University of Glasgow, with colleagues Jana Anderson, Stanley Zammit, Thomas Meyer, Jill Pell and Daniel Mackay. It appeared in the first issue of BJPsych Open, a journal of the Royal College of Psychiatrists, under the title “Childhood IQ and risk of bipolar disorder in adulthood: prospective birth cohort study”.

The team drew on the Avon Longitudinal Study of Parents and Children (ALSPAC), a long-running project that has tracked thousands of families around Bristol since the early 1990s. At age eight, the children took a shortened version of a standard intelligence test, which gave a full-scale score plus separate verbal and performance (non-verbal) scores.

About fourteen years later, when the participants were 22 or 23, they completed the Hypomania Checklist, a questionnaire that asks about past periods of unusual energy, confidence, talkativeness, reduced need for sleep and similar experiences. Out of more than 9,000 young people who could be contacted, 1,881 had both an IQ score and a completed checklist, and they formed the final sample.

What the numbers really show

Higher childhood IQ went along with higher scores for lifetime manic features. The correlation was modest: about 0.16 on a scale where 0 means no relationship and 1 means a perfect one. Put more concretely, young adults in the bottom tenth for manic features had an average childhood IQ of about 101, while those in the top tenth averaged about 110, a gap of roughly nine to ten points.

A few details matter for reading this correctly:

  • Verbal ability carried most of the link. The association appeared for verbal, non-verbal and full-scale IQ, but it was strongest for verbal IQ.
  • Low IQ did not predict the outcome. The relationship ran in one direction only.
  • It measured features, not a diagnosis. The checklist is a self-report screening tool. Nobody in the study was formally diagnosed with bipolar disorder, and the authors themselves called for proper diagnostic interviews and longer follow-up.
  • The sample was not fully typical. Those who stayed in the study were more often female and had higher IQ and more educated mothers than the cohort as a whole, which can skew results.

So a fair summary is this: in one large British group, cleverer eight-year-olds were a little more likely to report hypomanic experiences at 22. That is a long way from saying that a ten-point difference in IQ changes a person’s mental health.

Why intelligence and mood might be connected

The authors offered a few possible explanations, and none of them is settled.

One idea is an evolutionary trade-off. Some genetic variants that help with verbal fluency, social confidence and creative thinking may also raise the risk of mood instability. If those traits helped our ancestors find partners and status, the variants could persist in the population even though, in some people, they tip into illness.

Genetics clearly matter. Twin studies suggest that inherited factors account for most of the risk of bipolar disorder, with heritability estimates often given at 70 to 90 per cent. In 2015, a large Icelandic study published in Nature Neuroscience reported that people in creative professions were about 25 per cent more likely to carry gene variants linked to bipolar disorder and schizophrenia.

Genes are not the whole story, though. Childhood adversity, heavy drug use, severe stress and disrupted sleep can all affect when and how mood episodes appear. That is why researchers talk about risk and vulnerability rather than destiny.

There is also a simpler possibility. Hypomania itself brings rapid thinking, talkativeness and bursts of productivity. Children with a strong verbal style may notice and report those states more readily, or may express early warning signs in ways that look like brilliance.

Creativity, genius and famous examples

The question of whether great talent and mental illness travel together is very old. Modern research gives a mixed but useful answer.

Swedish registry studies led by Simon Kyaga at the Karolinska Institute are among the largest. A 2011 study of about 300,000 patients and their relatives found that creative occupations were more common among people with bipolar disorder and among the healthy siblings of people with bipolar disorder or schizophrenia. A 2013 follow-up covering more than a million people found that writers had higher rates of several conditions, including bipolar disorder, and that dancers and photographers were also more likely to have it. Yet creative professionals as a group were not more likely than others to have a psychiatric disorder overall.

Researchers also stress that the link appears mostly with milder mood traits or with family history, not with severe, untreated illness. Full mania tends to disrupt work rather than fuel it.

Vincent van Gogh is the classic example people reach for, and he is widely thought to have had bipolar disorder, though other diagnoses have been proposed. Edgar Allan Poe is often described as having struggled with depression and alcohol. Both cases rely on letters and biographies rather than examinations, so they illustrate the idea more than they prove it.

Myths worth dropping

“Suffering is the price of being smart”

This turns a small statistical association into a romantic story. Most highly intelligent people do not have bipolar disorder, and many people with bipolar disorder say their best work happens when their mood is stable, not during episodes.

“People with mood disorders have weak minds”

Bipolar disorder is a medical condition with strong biological roots. It says nothing about character or willpower, and the research above, if anything, points the other way.

“If you are clever enough, you can think your way out of it”

Racing thoughts and sleepless nights do not respond to logic alone. Insight helps people spot warning signs, but effective care usually combines professional treatment, routine and support.

What to do if this sounds familiar

If you, or a young person you know, recognise patterns such as long stretches of very low mood, periods of unusual energy with little need for sleep, racing thoughts or impulsive spending, the most useful step is to talk to a doctor. The NHS advises seeing a GP when mood changes are extreme, long-lasting or disrupting daily life. Bipolar disorder cannot be cured, but it can be managed well, and a specialist can explain the options.

Everyday habits also matter: a regular sleep and wake time, steady routines, and cutting back on alcohol and recreational drugs are commonly recommended alongside professional care. For parents of bright, intense children, the practical lesson is not to fear their intelligence but to help them build emotional skills, rest well and talk openly about how they feel.

The bigger lesson is about stigma. Seeing mood disorders as a sign of a flawed mind keeps people silent. Seeing them as conditions that can affect anyone, including very capable people, makes it easier to ask for help early.

Sources: Smith DJ et al., Childhood IQ and risk of bipolar disorder in adulthood, BJPsych Open (2015); Wikipedia: Creativity and mental health; Wikipedia: Bipolar disorder; NHS: Bipolar disorder; topic first covered by Learning Mind.

COMMENTS