Max Loughan's Coffee-Can Energy Harvester: What It Really Did

Facebook ↗WhatsApp ↗

Originally published 2016-07-27.

Max Loughan's 2016 Energy-Harvesting Demonstration

In February 2016 a 13-year-old from Incline Village, Nevada, appeared on local television in a white lab coat with a coffee can wired to two coils and a spoon. Max Loughan said his homemade device pulled energy out of the air, and in front of the camera it lit a string of LEDs wrapped around his twin brother, Jack. Within months, websites were calling it a Tesla-inspired "free energy" machine that cost less than $15.

The short answer to what he built: an energy harvester, a close relative of the century-old crystal radio. It collects a tiny amount of power that already exists around us, mostly from radio transmitters. It does not create energy, and it cannot run a home. That does not make the project worthless; it makes it a good example of youthful curiosity, and of how quickly the internet can inflate a science fair idea.

What Max Loughan showed on TV in 2016

The report aired on KTVN 2 News, the CBS station for Reno and Lake Tahoe, on 18 February 2016. Max worked in a lab he had set up in his parents' former boiler room. His harvester used a coffee can, some wire, two coils and a spoon, and he put the cost at about $14 (his brother said $15).

Max explained that a frayed wire acted as the collector and that the circuitry inside the can converted alternating current into direct current. "This wire takes energy from the air," he told the reporter. Outdoors, the device lit a strand of LEDs, to the obvious delight of his family and the news crew. He also said he wanted his inventions to help people.

What the broadcast did not include matters as much: there were no measurements of voltage, current or power, no description of how long the LEDs stayed lit, and no independent test. The reporter speculated about a version 20 times bigger, but nothing suggests one was built.

How an energy harvester really works

We are surrounded by electromagnetic waves: AM and FM radio, TV signals, mobile phone networks and Wi-Fi. A long wire works as an antenna. When those waves pass it, they push electrons back and forth, creating a very weak alternating current. A diode or rectifier circuit turns that into direct current, which can be stored in a capacitor or used to drive a low-power device.

This is exactly how a crystal radio works. Since the early 1900s, people have built radios that need no battery at all, because they run purely on the energy of the broadcast signal they receive. The physicist Greenleaf Whittier Pickard showed in 1902 that crystals could rectify radio signals this way, and in 1922 the US Bureau of Standards published instructions for building one at home.

Engineers call a combined antenna and rectifier a "rectenna", and today the same principle powers passive RFID tags, contactless cards and some wireless sensors. The energy, though, always comes from somewhere: a transmitter, a reader or a nearby power line. It is harvested, not created.

Can it light LEDs or power a house?

Lighting a few LEDs for a moment is possible in the right conditions. The amount of power available is the problem. According to standard references on crystal radios, an antenna picking up a strong commercial station a few miles away typically receives microwatts or less. A single ordinary indicator LED draws tens of milliwatts, thousands of times more, although special low-current LEDs can glow with far less.

So a coffee-can harvester near a powerful transmitter, with a capacitor that charges slowly and then flashes, could make LEDs light. Running a fridge, a laptop or a home is a different scale entirely. A typical household uses thousands of watts at peak; ambient radio energy offers a millionth of a watt or so. Making the can bigger does not solve that, because the limit is the strength of the signal, not the size of the device.

That is why the "free energy" label is wrong. A device that seems to run forever on nothing would break the basic laws of thermodynamics. Max's harvester did not break them; the headlines did.

(The video originally embedded here is no longer available on YouTube.)

The Tesla connection: what Tesla actually tried

Max named Nikola Tesla and Albert Einstein as his heroes, and many articles described his device as Tesla-inspired. Tesla really did dream of sending power through the air. Between 1901 and 1902 he built Wardenclyffe Tower on Long Island, New York, with funding from the banker J.P. Morgan. It was meant to send messages, telephone signals and images across the Atlantic, and Tesla also hoped to transmit electricity wirelessly.

The project never became operational. Morgan refused to put in more money when Tesla proposed a much larger plan, other investors stayed away, and Guglielmo Marconi's radio system was winning the race for wireless messages. Tesla abandoned Wardenclyffe in 1906, and the tower was dynamited for scrap in 1917 to help pay his debts.

A popular myth says Tesla's "free energy" was suppressed by powerful interests. The record shows a more ordinary story of funding problems, competition and physics. Wireless power does exist today, in phone chargers and RFID, but it works over short distances and still needs a power source. The site of Wardenclyffe is now home to the Tesla Science Center, a museum project, if you want to see where the idea began.

What happened to Max Loughan later

The 2016 TV clip was only the start of his fame. The journalist Richard Greene livestreamed a presentation by Max and interviewed him at an event at the United Nations; that interview was reportedly watched around two million times. Videos of Max talking about physics and the universe kept circulating for years.

In December 2022 a viral post claimed he had been "missing" for about six years. The fact-checking site Lead Stories found no evidence of that. Max had attended Tahoe Expedition Academy, which shared a video of his 2021 senior presentation; Greene said Max was studying at a major US university. He turned 20 in November 2022.

Try it yourself: safe projects for young inventors

If a young person in your family is inspired by Max's story, there are excellent ways to explore the same science:

  • Build a crystal radio. Kits are cheap, need no battery and show energy harvesting in action.
  • Measure before you claim. A basic multimeter shows how much voltage and current a homemade device really produces. Writing the numbers down is what turns a gadget into an experiment.
  • Compare sources. Try small solar cells, a hand-crank generator and a thermoelectric module, and see which gives the most power.
  • Stay safe. Never connect home projects to mains electricity, and leave high-voltage Tesla coils to supervised clubs and experienced adults.

Max's coffee can did not solve the world's energy problems, but his curiosity is worth encouraging. The best response to a young inventor is not "free energy!" or "impossible!" but a friendly question: what did you measure?

For a teenager whose energy prototype has a clear power source, read about Hannah Herbst's ocean-current generator.

Sources: KTVN 2 News, 18 February 2016: 13-Year-Old Creates Energy Harvesting Device; Lead Stories, 28 December 2022: Max Loughan not missing; Higgypop (2018): what Max Loughan's device really is; Wikipedia: Crystal radio; Wikipedia: Energy harvesting; Wikipedia: Wardenclyffe Tower. The story was widely shared in 2016 by Waking Times and The Anti-Media. Photo: KTVN 2 News screenshot.

COMMENTS

BLOGGER: 1